有關學鋼琴的問題(交流分享)

小伊

我就覺得學琴只有走冤枉路，並無捷徑。學琴之路每個人也不盡同，A可能入門好快，但之後進展好慢；B卻相反。總之離不開3個因素：天份+老師+苦練。至於X世傑，有聽過，但覺得很離奇，不知是何方神聖，只知世界上有很多音樂騙徒。

小伊

我都見好多媽咪都系等亞仔真係有興趣先買綱琴，求其揾部電子琴頂住先。不過，結果就系亞仔彈兩彈就就真系無興趣，唔使買琴。

miss321

係呀係呀, 就係呢個人! 我朋友話我知佢呃人的。拎果d獎完全未聽過。打電話去個人又咦咦哦哦，賣廣告咋喎。

原帖由 小伊 於 09-8-3 23:59 發表
我就覺得學琴只有走冤枉路，並無捷徑。學琴之路每個人也不盡同，A可能入門好快，但之後進展好慢；B卻相反。總之離不開3個因素：天份+老師+苦練。至於X世傑，有聽過，但覺得很離奇，不知是何方神聖，只知世界上有很多音樂騙徒。 ...

小伊

Overview:
所指的是哪本magazine呢? 網上說他是全港最好的piano teacher, 15歲已經學完"
所有"鋼琴技巧.

Radiomama

我反而覺得呢個係惡性循環: 開始時試試下>小朋友表現求求其>有時練有時唔練>無興趣而放棄。

其實如果唔太壓迫孩子考琴試，練琴可以練得好開心和有滿足感。我和姐姐的經驗是用二手琴吧!

我的琴用了15年，5年前借給姐姐的孩子作初學用，2年前，他們添置新琴於是剛好又搬番給我，讓我的兒子初學用。

坊間二手琴不少，可考慮。

就算初學都要堅持日日練琴，仔仔3歲初學時每天練琴5-10mins，依家4歲半，可以每天練45分鐘。

原帖由 小伊 於 09-8-4 00:07 發表
我都見好多媽咪都系等亞仔真係有興趣先買綱琴，求其揾部電子琴頂住先。不過，結果就系亞仔彈兩彈就就真系無興趣，唔使買琴。

Pianokc

Which magazine article is this ?

overview

果名好似係....我都唔記得咩名, 好似centre係hunghom.本書今星期係library睇到, 所以都唔記起咩名, 只知係親子雜誌.  我最近見有位k3係校際音樂4級拿了第一, 覺得好神奇, 點可以咁細已彈得咁叻, 跟住又有朋友跟我說, 剛剛考完2級, 話出年去考5級, 我知好多人係為考試而考試, 基本功係未夠, 但小朋友會好有滿足感, 咁快就5,6級.

原帖由 小伊 於 09-8-3 23:59 發表
我就覺得學琴只有走冤枉路，並無捷徑。學琴之路每個人也不盡同，A可能入門好快，但之後進展好慢；B卻相反。總之離不開3個因素：天份+老師+苦練。至於X世傑，有聽過，但覺得很離奇，不知是何方神聖，只知世界上有很多音樂騙徒。 ...

[ 本帖最後由 overview 於 09-8-4 15:49 編輯 ]

Rainky

其實學琴有時都要睇下好唔好彩,
一間音樂中心o既老師都有唔少
質素可能好參差,又或者未必同小朋友夾到

所以選一個老師同小朋友夾到便可!
而且當然要有返咁上下質素

broadband

幾歲才開始學琴比較好?

Pianokc

I hate seeing kids like this.... and teachers allowing this to happen. Kids only get ONE chance in their to fully intake all there is to learn at THAT stage.

Sure this kid can play Grade 4 when he's only 5 years old, impressing everyone who hears and knows it..... but what happens when he gets to Grade 8, all the foundation work, and knowledge about music, history, counting, appreciation, composers.... all is NEVER learned. Then the child misses out all that because there is no way the child and parents will have patience to go back to pick up these things that he missed along the way.

What would be a BETTER description is : A 5 year old can play THREE examination graded pieces that is at Grade 4. That's all. How's the sight reading? How's the aural? How's the general knowledge of what a real grade 4 piano student should know?

Ughhhh !!!!!!

Snoopy_Mom

我諗無人可以講呢句說話.....學無止境........

原帖由 小伊 於 09-8-4 13:07 發表
Overview:
所指的是哪本magazine呢? 網上說他是全港最好的piano teacher, 15歲已經學完"
所有"鋼琴技巧.

yautoto

鋼琴與電子琴的觸鍵感相差很遠，所以不要以其代替太長時間。

Pianokc

Bravo Snoopy Mom !!! It makes me sick to read that.

Snoopy_Mom

有無親戚朋友可以介紹琴老師比你呀?
我唔係好相信琴行老師(尤其是柏斯).....

靜雞雞話你聽, 我兩個囝囝而家個鋼琴老師係o係BK度搵o家, 跟左佢大約一年.....

開頭都驚驚地, 我同佢講我比住一堂錢先, 睇下佢同我囝囝夾唔夾到先, 之後就一路跟佢到而家....

不過我都聽過一o的BK媽咪話o係BK搵o既鋼琴老師超唔掂, 始終都係人夾人緣o既.....睇下好唔好彩啦.....

Snoopy_Mom

最好頭o個幾個月都跟埋上堂, 我o個陣都係咁, 起碼知道要做o的咩, 睇下點幫佢....

原帖由 maybaby 於 09-8-3 13:00 發表
但去琴行練琴冇問題，但佢初學比佢自己練真係無從入手，我自己又唔識！！！

小伊

咪系，大部份嘅小朋友都唔識練琴，開頭要tum、逼、利、誘、鬧、鼓勵、稱贊，mud都出齊。無法，我地自己以前學琴都經歷無數次想過放棄。

Edsie

My husband and I believe that playing the piano is mainly to train our son to develop his patience and good temper!  It's ok that he doesn't play very well as long as he has the patience to practise it everyday!!!  It's too boring to play the 3 exam pieces over and over for so many times for the whole year before the exam!!!  hahaha!!!

Some parents just want to show off how good their kids are with the 'certs'!!!  After all when they grow up, they will never touch the piano again!!!

Sindy

原帖由 小伊 於 09-8-5 00:02 發表
咪系，大部份嘅小朋友都唔識練琴，開頭要tum、逼、利、誘、鬧、鼓勵、稱贊，mud都出齊。無法，我地自己以前學琴都經歷無數次想過放棄。

我放棄過一次啫....但我媽如我所願...