第二屆全港學生公開朗誦比賽--揾笨!

ystaihk

中國青少年藝術節

請問各位家長，有沒有人參加過去年“第三屆中國青少年藝術節”或前年“第二屆中國青少年藝術節”到北京參賽的活動。

孩子參加了今年第四屆香港選拔賽，得了季軍，獲邀去北京參賽，由於費用比較貴，所以想問問有經驗的家長，是否值得去參加。

感謝。

Crabtree

係勁多人.  我囡參加的英詩朗誦有成74個人噃!

原帖由 wootaitai 於 09-6-12 00:50 發表
not true. the session I went to had 100 kids.

lilyma

我覺得pianokc同tcmom講得好中肯，呢個比賽無論個組別有幾多人參加都係得5、6個獎，唔似坊間啲分豬肉獎比賽咁，如果家長諗住參加咗就會攞(或買)到獎就會好失望，其實最緊要係小朋友係比賽中汲取經驗，訓練到自信心已經係好大嘅得著。

Pianokc

I entered my children into this competition, for the VERY reason, it is NOT like HKSMA competition.

HKSMA competition, all the parents care about is winning, and then get recognition from their school. How about the students who work very hard, but didn't win ? I think they deserve a pat on the back, and also a big hug from their parent for trying their best. You know it's not easy to stand on the stage alone with hundreds of people looking at you while you perform, and they all hope you will make a mistake ?

I was at HKSMA's speech competition this year watching my daughter, my daughter didn't win any prize, she got 85, 1st winner was 89.

I heard a parent yell at her son at the elevators at the City Hall, "You are USELESS! You waste my time bringing you here, I took half a day off work, and you didn't even WIN anything!" She took the piece of paper and stuffed it in a bag and dragged the boy into the elevator.

I felt so sorry for the boy.

I NEVER want to do that to my children.
No matter how they do at a performance, I always praise them for having the courage to step up there.

I don't see any logical reason for the ones who complain against this competition.

Schedule- no reason because it's stated clearly.
Winners results- you have no idea how winners are chosen, and just because your child didn't win, doesn't mean the competition was unfair.

Spidermum

i agree with lilyma, pianokc and tcmom.  

my child entered a few competitions organised by different organisations.  i really think that this is better than others - more well organised and serious.  i have to say that the winners are really outstanding ones - and all parents were there to see the whole process and prizes were given on the spot - Not like some other competitions, parents had no way to find out how all candidates had performed and winner were announced after the competitions (this is tricky).

besides, this organisation does not have conflict of interest - it doesn't offer any training courses.  you may also notice that their judges are from reputatable institutions such as HKU, VTC, etc.  i do think that this competition is one of the better ones.  

i think parents need to observe carefully the guidelines before they enter any competition.

原帖由 lilyma 於 09-6-14 12:30 發表
我覺得pianokc同tcmom講得好中肯，呢個比賽無論個組別有幾多人參加都係得5、6個獎，唔似坊間啲分豬肉獎比賽咁，如果家長諗住參加咗就會攞(或買)到獎就會好失望，其實最緊要係小朋友係比賽中汲取經驗，訓練到自信心已經係好大嘅 ...