band 1學生是否真正band 1呢？

2008mum2008

原帖由 G-Ma 於 09-5-25 16:57 發表
如果真係有升中試, 對小朋友壓力真係幾大, 好似一試定生死咁.

現在考三次呈分試壓力咪一樣咁大, 考完仲要等餐死至放榜, 真係好心急呀!

Yanamami

It's really a torture to both students and parents.

原帖由 2008mum2008 於 09-5-25 23:08 發表

現在考三次呈分試壓力咪一樣咁大, 考完仲要等餐死至放榜, 真係好心急呀!

jackjackma

帖由 麟媽媽 於 09-5-22 17:03 發表
其實有直屬小學既band 1 中學，
因為小學有既定既直屬額，
當中必定會收左一d band 2 生，
但校內band 2，亦有可能係全港性band 1，
哈~~唔好意思，講到好似好複雜咁。 ...

麟媽媽,

唔好意思.想搭下訕.
有直屬小學既band 1 中學唔係全部都收band 2 生,
中學有權去決定只收band 1 or band 1+band 2,
st jo 咪只收band 1,
係我地中學揸住有教無類的宗旨先收band 2.
在某地區小學校內band 1亦有可能係全港性band 2.

[ 本帖最後由 jackjackma 於 09-5-30 22:23 編輯 ]

popokit

原帖由 88muimui 於 09-5-23 17:15 發表
我仍然認為最公平方法是升中試

Agree

2bzmummy

原帖由 88muimui 於 09-5-23 17:15 發表
我仍然認為最公平方法是升中試

呢句說話，我幾時都掛係口邊，我既年代仲係升中試年代（好老。。），讀既係屋村小學，但選校表係包含全 HK 中學，全部按成績派位，今日我既小學同學好多都學業有成，因為佢地憑成績入到好學校（都係現今既所謂名校），有些仲係知名人士 。。。。

88muimui

原帖由 2bzmummy 於 09-5-31 10:45 發表


呢句說話，我幾時都掛係口邊，我既年代仲係升中試年代（好老。。），讀既係屋村小學，但選校表係包含全 HK 中學，全部按成績派位，今日我既小學同學好多都學業有成，因為佢地憑成績入到好學校（都係現今既所謂名校），有些仲係知名人士 。 ...

X2

hillsamuel

原帖由 2bzmummy 於 09-5-31 10:45 發表


呢句說話，我幾時都掛係口邊，我既年代仲係升中試年代（好老。。），讀既係屋村小學，但選校表係包含全 HK 中學，全部按成績派位，今日我既小學同學好多都學業有成，因為佢地憑成績入到好學校（都係現今既所謂名校），有些仲係知名人士 。 ...

完全同意升中試,公平公正,真正憑實力.現在用隨機No.分配學位就算同一組別No.的先後都好大影響.再加上小學的師兄師姐亦影響到派位. 自己的未來,被上屆的師兄,師姐影響,實在荒謬.

漢堡飽

好似現在每件政策都要走回頭路。
教學語言已經是這樣，唔通升中都也一樣？
香港政府這十幾年推行的政策完全是.....

qrasalo

點都好啦！香港教育政策，玩死家長同小朋友！都唔係為學習而學習，只係為咗考試而返學！悲哉！

patlychan

唉所喟banding要睇前人種o的福,學生呈3次試先知乜banding。出嚟banding係未真係小朋友o的banding呢?咁o的考試制度一的都唔公平。應該要廢除,改番一試定生死(升中試),統一試卷唔會有深淺之分。甘樣分banding先叫做公平。

com7hk

HAVE A GREAT DIFFERENCE FOR BOTH BAND 1 STUDENT BETWEEN OLD SCHOOL AND NEW SCHOOL

FOR EXAMPLE, FOR OLD SCHOOL, IT WILL HAVE 60% BAND 1 STUDENT.

FOR NEW SCHOOL, IT WILL HAVE 1X% BAND 1 STUDENT.

I DONT THINK THE 60% STUDENT 'S SCHOOL RESULT IN OLD SCHOOL IS BETTER THAN THE AROUND 20% BAND 2 STUDENT IN NEW SCHOOL.

I HAVE BEEN FACED THIS PROBLEMS FEW YEARS AGO.  I UNDERSTAND AT ALL.

I HAD OBSERVED MANY BAND 1 STUDENT IN OLD SHCOOL HAVE OBTAIN WHAT THE BAD SCHOOL RESULT IN EMI SCHOOL.

THE WORLD IS FAIR, EASY TO GRANT TO BE BAND 1 STUDENT AS A RESULT THAT THEY WILL FACE DIFFICULTY IN EMI SCHOOL.

com7hk

HAVE A GREAT DIFFERENCE FOR BOTH BAND 1 STUDENT BETWEEN OLD SCHOOL AND NEW SCHOOL

FOR EXAMPLE, FOR OLD SCHOOL, IT WILL HAVE 60% BAND 1 STUDENT.

FOR NEW SCHOOL, IT WILL HAVE 1X% BAND 1 STUDENT.

I DONT THINK THE 60% STUDENT 'S SCHOOL RESULT IN OLD SCHOOL IS BETTER THAN THE AROUND 20% BAND 2 STUDENT IN NEW SCHOOL.

I HAVE BEEN FACED THIS PROBLEMS FEW YEARS AGO.  I UNDERSTAND AT ALL.

I HAD OBSERVED MANY BAND 1 STUDENT IN OLD SHCOOL HAVE OBTAIN WHAT THE BAD SCHOOL RESULT IN EMI SCHOOL.

THE WORLD IS FAIR, EASY TO GRANT TO BE BAND 1 STUDENT AS A RESULT THAT THEY WILL FACE DIFFICULTY IN EMI SCHOOL.

com7hk

HAVE A GREAT DIFFERENCE FOR BOTH BAND 1 STUDENT BETWEEN OLD SCHOOL AND NEW SCHOOL

FOR EXAMPLE, FOR OLD SCHOOL, IT WILL HAVE 60% BAND 1 STUDENT.

FOR NEW SCHOOL, IT WILL HAVE 1X% BAND 1 STUDENT.

I DONT THINK THE 60% STUDENT 'S SCHOOL RESULT IN OLD SCHOOL IS BETTER THAN THE AROUND 20% BAND 2 STUDENT IN NEW SCHOOL.

I HAVE BEEN FACED THIS PROBLEMS FEW YEARS AGO.  I UNDERSTAND AT ALL.

I HAD OBSERVED MANY BAND 1 STUDENT IN OLD SHCOOL HAVE OBTAIN WHAT THE BAD SCHOOL RESULT IN EMI SCHOOL.

THE WORLD IS FAIR, EASY TO GRANT TO BE BAND 1 STUDENT AS A RESULT THAT THEY WILL FACE DIFFICULTY IN EMI SCHOOL.

2bzmummy

原帖由 EVA222 於 09-6-1 16:23 發表

有次睇"亞洲新世代之新加坡",有個十多歲尖子學生,生於富裕之家,除了個人天資外,看得出是父母栽培的功勞,父母知識水平高,又有能力遊遍整個世界,看不同的事物.
我覺得大部份人的命運,出生時已註定,首富兩個仔,如果生 ...

所以公平的升中試，先會有可能俾到叻既窮家小朋友一個出頭的機會

Martina

FOR NEW SCHOOL, IT WILL HAVE 1X% BAND 1 STUDENT.  ----->  新校(小學) 是以公平起見,  3個band 各33.33%的.  而且教署也不敢指某某小學只得很少band 1生吧!

以我接觸到的學生,  不同校的band 1生standard真的有很大分別.

cow

同不同校乜好,band 1生的standard就有佷大分別。

candy8

原帖由 CHUCHU 於 09-5-22 20:59 發表
有嘜真唔真正band 1 呀.
學生在全港名次係第幾,都要睇上屆師兄姐考成點,同個排位.

好似我朋友個仔咁,今年d學生成績奇差,係學校平均分七十幾左右,每科都介乎六七十分,但考第五十幾,仲係band 1 組別.

佢呀媽都話好彩 ...

很同意！