It says in the bible, "Who asks here shall receive, who seeks shall find, who knocks may enter." Everyone should have the same chance in front of God. Why do the schools have to retrict to kids who carries the same religion ?
Though I'm a Catholic but I'm against the 5 points for religion.
No pointing counting system;
No separate round 1 & 2 application procedure;
Every student can make application to their prefered school (one choice only) without area demarcation as 1st stage;
If fail in stage 1, student can make application to their next preference;
Repeated.
I opine that the deletion should not only apply to the religionary point issue but also the entire system.
Without area demarcation？！
咁攪法咪分分鐘住北角抽左去牛頭角，
住柴灣攪左去荃灣？！咁樣唔掂喎......
原帖由 zzidane 於 08-11-28 11:01 發表
My opinion is:
No pointing counting system;
No separate round 1 & 2 application procedure;
Every student can make application to their prefered school (one choice only) without area demarcation as 1s ...
This "5 points" not only for Catholic church members. But also for 與該校的辦學團體有相同的宗教信仰 like Christian Education Organization: SKH, Baptist and Methodist or 香港佛教聯合會.
Please do not only pin point on Catholic and Christians.
There is huge contribution from these organizations to their school. To have 5 points is not overvalued.
If you look at the point system, why no people challenge 父／ 母為該小學的校董 has 20 points or 首名出生子女（ 即為家庭各子女中最年長者） has 5 points. Or 父／ 母為該小學主辦社團的成員 has 5 points
Agree that the point system is not perfect. But without a point system, how can the school decide who can be selected among thousand of applications. What should we do? Like I said before, should we go back to our old time, to have the P1 admission test?
Also for the 自行分配學位, 每所小學可將其全部小一學額的大約50%作為自行分配學位之用, not for all application leh.
We discuss this topic only with a the hidden agenda on some famous schools that we like. If we forfeit any point system, how can we judge?
發表於 08-11-28 10:16
)
