15號去咗st. cat註冊既媽咪入來傾吓

Mamusia

i've also paid,
this year, there seems a lot of mammies giving up SC and choose KV...

whatever

Anybody will ride #18 school bus?

aammyy

SC間直太商業化啦!老師又沒愛心, 校費又很貴,校舍環境也不是想象中優良.考慮中的家長不坊深思下.

counts01

原文章由 vincy1015 於 07-12-20 01:07 發表



hi hi  咁我地屬同一區啦!
我好似係1號站(清水灣半島) 你呢?

我係第四個站呀!(將軍澳中心),但係想係暑假前搬屋,所以未必可以同到你個囝囝一架車呀!
你係番羅福道定係雅士道呀??

Chingmy1002

我都係4號校車呀...

其實st.cat同根德, st.cat貴成千蚊一個月....但係我都俾我個女讀st.cat, 因為人地話st.cat讀得開心d

kv要填鴨, 冇課外活動, 就連畢業典禮都好似話冇...咁我覺得會好慘囉~~~anyway, 希望我個女會鍾意啦~~

Hollycircle

我都未諗掂我會放棄 kv or st.cat,好煩~
我同你嘅諗法都一樣,不過我老公就想個女讀kv, 到時可以pick up
到上小一,冇咁辛苦喎!哎呀!!

原文章由 Chingmy1002 於 07-12-22 02:38 發表
我都係4號校車呀...

其實st.cat同根德, st.cat貴成千蚊一個月....但係我都俾我個女讀st.cat, 因為人地話st.cat讀得開心d

kv要填鴨, 冇課外活動, 就連畢業典禮都好似話冇...咁我覺得會好慘囉~~~anyway, 希望我個女 ...

joeyma

原文章由 aammyy 於 07-12-21 21:18 發表
SC間直太商業化啦!老師又沒愛心, 校費又很貴,校舍環境也不是想象中優良.考慮中的家長不坊深思下.

我都同我個囡留佐位，我好想知你地點知
1、太商業化
2、老師欠愛心

聽你地成日咁講，點解咁講呢？

cantaloup8

joeyma,

我囝囝今年剛喺SC畢業,或者我可以分享一下個人感受:

1.商業化
坦白講,我一啲都唔覺SC商業化,佢已經收足你學費,所以平時無話巧立名目收其他費用,印象中囝囝讀咗三年,除咗去旅行或者參觀要另外交錢,其餘都無咩使費.

最商業化可能就係年年發通告問學生有無喺出面得過咩獎,等學校可以喺"校訊"登出嚟威威,我覺得呢個好正常啫!

同時學校唔會因為小朋友喺出面攞過咩奬而特別"厚待".記得囝囝去年k3被老師選中負責喺畢業禮致謝辭,我都好奇怪,因為佢班上有好多"優秀"小朋友,時時出外參加比賽,我囝囝反而無.後來爸爸有日去接放學就當面問班主任,佢話:"xx(我囝名)一定做得到,我唔會睇錯!"結果老師正確!

2. 老師欠愛心

好老實,咁大間學校,一班有成廿幾三十人,老師好難做到對毎個學生貼身關懷,呢個係事實,亦唔會好似有啲教會學校老師會主動定期揾家長報告小朋友的情況.不過如果家長揾老師,無論係中文老師定西人老師都會即覆,而且會同家長詳細傾.

純粹個人睇法,老師唔係話要成日呵住小朋友,或者時時揾家長溝通,先叫有愛心.最簡單係問吓小朋友鍾唔鍾意老師.鍾唔鍾意返學,已經係最直接答案,我囝囝三年三個唔同老師,毎年都話:"我好鍾意老師!"以我認識SC老師都有一定經驗,但是否符合個人對"愛心"的要求,就要自己衡量.

原文章由 joeyma 於 07-12-22 09:52 發表


我都同我個囡留佐位，我好想知你地點知
1、太商業化
2、老師欠愛心

聽你地成日咁講，點解咁講呢？

Yanamami

cantaloup8,

Totally agreed with U.  My elder daughter was
graduated from SC and my younger one is
studying at SC too.

原文章由 cantaloup8 於 07-12-22 10:44 發表
joeyma,

我囝囝今年剛喺SC畢業,或者我可以分享一下個人感受:

1.商業化
坦白講,我一啲都唔覺SC商業化,佢已經收足你學費,所以平時無話巧立名目收其他費用,印象中囝囝讀咗三年,除咗去旅行或者參觀要另外交錢,其餘都無 ...

Yanamami

KTS, GH, APS, KRS, St, Frances, Creative, SPCC,
SPC, DGJS, DBS...etc.  I guess most of the parents
target these schools.

原文章由 vincy1015 於 07-12-22 15:34 發表
有無家長知St. Cahterine會考d咩小學呢??

[ 本文章最後由 Yanamami 於 07-12-22 17:59 編輯 ]

whatever

其實兩間各有各好。
如果你想小朋友輕輕鬆鬆地讀，可選SC.
如果你想小朋友早些習慣小學既模式，可選KV.
其實小朋友適應能力很強。以本人經驗，我寧願比小朋友輕輕鬆鬆地讀幼稚園，啓發佢既學習興趣最緊要。到左小學，間間都Feeding the ducks 架啦，吾通到時先至啓發學習興趣咩。佢地見到咁多功課，乜興趣都冇晒啦。

joeyma

cantaloup8

謝謝你！我其實好想個囡囡既學到野又返學返得開心，所以我覺得st.cat會幾好！3xxx可以日日有英文同普通話學，我真係覺得好抵，希望我地既仔女開心快活咁成長啦！

heichumom

I really doubt that there are so many mom gave up or will give up the seats at SC.  If they really think that SC is so commercial and the teachers there are no "heart" and not good, why they still spend the time before to appy and went for the interview? Is there any hidden agenda behide? Are they really got their kids being admitted by SC? If they don't have kids or have friends' kids to studying at SC now (the user), I don't think they are qualified to give out such comment.  But anyway, if they don't think SC is good and wanna give up, please do so ASAP as many kids are on the waiting list.  Appreciate the comment from cantaloup8, your comment is similar to my friend who has her daugher now studies in K1 :

Mui_Chu

Sorry....I do not think to study in SC is happy...my elder daughter studied in SC before...I really think SC is too commerical and not care about the feeling of parents and childrens.. so finally my elder daughter changed to LH.

heichumom

原文章由 Mui_Chu 於 07-12-23 14:52 發表
Sorry....I do not think to study in SC is happy...my elder daughter studied in SC before...I really think SC is too commerical and not care about the feeling of parents and childrens.. so finally my e ...

Which LH your daugher is studying now? My son is now attending the PN class in Hampton branch.  From my point of view, LH is not bad.  The teachers follow very close to my son at the beginning of the school term, however, when the class becomes bigger and bigger (from 14 pax to 28pax), the teachers seldom call me to update my son's status.  I cannot comment on SC but just learnt from some parents who has kids there - all in all, every kind has their good or bad, just u need to put your kid in one which suits him/her the best.   Good Luck!

MandyChau

原文章由 scmail 於 07-12-17 18:24 發表
WHY MORE PEOPLE GIVE UP ST. CATHERINE  係唔係ST. CATHERINE唔好呀!!

唯一原因係對佢interview感覺唔好.