小一退學(華X小學)

happysiubobo

My son just joined WY in P.4 this Sept. He is transferred from another traditional school. My son enjoys his new school life in WY very much. There are much less homework in WY. The curriculum is not so difficult in most subjects compare to the previous school.

I have been searching lots of information on WY before I sent my application. I totally understand its vision, culture, curriculum, eca and pta activities etc. I have been talking to WY parents and teachers from other schools to get a much better understanding of WY.

Parents are responsible in understanding the schools they select before choosing the right schools for their kids but not just blindly follow the "brand". It is irrational to put the blame on the school (and its secondary school) when realizing it's a wrong match.

原文章由 hk-mum 於 07-10-17 10:58 硐表
詢眾要求, 寫下為何要個仔那麼早(小一)就退學.
因為我終於明白, 以華X小學的方法, 又點可以打好小朋友的基礎呢?
試問用最深嫁課本, 默晒課本內最深嫁字, 是否等如學校有能力提高中英語文質素?
40人一班, 傳统坐定定 ...

麟媽媽

呢度好多都係在職家長，你既難處，
我地好多個一樣係咁，同亞仔溫習，
可以好痛苦，可以好輕鬆，
最主要取決於父母當時既心情！
唔係講笑架，你拿口鞋面，
個仔自然緊張，一驚咪咩都唔知囉。
如果你唔想咁，咪唔好迫佢讀囉，
合格咪收貨，咁你同佢都唔使煩。
默書唔好老師唔會搵你架喎，
你個仔係學校犯規就一定寫你手冊啫。

原文章由 sunnydad 於 07-10-17 17:26 硐表
Agree with HK-mum, Longman出本甘既express，完全滿足大部份急功近利既家長心態．

headmaster, headmistress  唔難，甘你地不如叫學校用'Laws of Empire' （一本法律哲學既書）做教科書！甘咪可以小一畢業就入法律係囉.

深唔 ...

sunnydad

其實大家只要想想如果呢間小學唔同個間中學掛上，你會否揀呢間小學呢???

麟媽媽

我會！因為學校唔止為學生教導知識，
仲有好既校風，德育上既培養。
WY 未必係學術上比得上其他超級名校，
但D 仔既德行呢？我覺得一D 唔會失禮，
所以，又係要睇吓家長想要D 咩囉。

原文章由 sunnydad 於 07-10-17 17:42 硐表
其實大家只要想想如果呢間小學唔同個間中學掛上，你會否揀呢間小學呢???

Raykid

I will, the Home assignment is not much compared with other schools but the discipline is good. Teacher are good and care for the students. My kid study there and feel happy. I usually use about 1.5 hour for revision and homework everyday and still have time for us to play with him. I saw my son is much improved in discipline and language skill in the past one month study.

麟媽媽

我見你講既野又幾前後矛盾架喎？！
呢頭又罵D 家長急功近利？
轉頭又話只顧讀書，攪到D 仔德行差晒？
咁而家又話因為直屬關系，會唔會選呢間小學？
咁你最終想要咩？直升華中？
講真，成績唔好都好難直升架喎？
呢個世界都要付出，先有收成架，係咪？！

原文章由 sunnydad 於 07-10-17 17:42 硐表
其實大家只要想想如果呢間小學唔同個間中學掛上，你會否揀呢間小學呢???

CHUCHU

原文章由 麟媽媽 於 07-10-17 17:42 硐表
呢度好多都係在職家長，你既難處，
我地好多個一樣係咁，同亞仔溫習，
可以好痛苦，可以好輕鬆，
最主要取決於父母當時既心情！
唔係講笑架，你拿口鞋面，
個仔自然緊張，一驚咪咩都唔知囉。
如果你唔想咁，咪唔好迫佢讀囉，
合格咪收貨，咁你 ...

麟媽媽 ,
係囉! agree with 付 U 囉我都係咁諗  
只要家長唔介意小朋友名次同成績,其實間間都可以讀得開心架!:loveliness:
如果好想個細路名列前茅,咁邊間小學讀都要付出代價架啦 對不對  除非~~~~~唔想出力,又想~~~~ 咁就要睇呀媽同呀仔個做化lu.

ssspwong

The pupils of Wah Yah I have met before were polite and humble so I thought it is a good school.

By the way, in my son's school, students are only given a list (about 10) of content words for dictation. These words are usually not difficult to memorize. Teachers will then read out 5-7 sentences with these words, just like unseen dictation. So, not much effort and time is required beforehand. However, students need to do more reading and listening to get familiar with English grammar and sentence structure. Otherwise, they could not get high marks. It is quite challenging and interesting.

[ 本文章最後由 ssspwong 於 07-10-17 20:26 編輯 ]

holokmom

Longman 呢本Express 比舊的 Weclome to English
係深咗，但裏面嘅內容比較靈活，唔似Weclome 咁逐個
topic (grammar ) 教，整體上小朋友嘅reading ability
提高不少。

話呢本番書啱 急功近利嘅家長？

有冇聽過好多人話用嗰本??My Pals???(唔記得)
Express 只係小巫見大巫。

concern_mom

我之前有個topic係想講某名校究竟有也個人之處。當然種種意見都有，但最實質都係話個小朋友好乖…等等。

其實小朋友乖唔乖，你覺得學校真係可以教到? 我個人覺得受同學影比較多。咁點解個小朋友返學真係乖? 因為受其他同學影，細個時侯，亞媽無時無刻話要有家教。小朋友好天真，佢行為其實就係你自己。放學返屋企，你又會睇到D老師係點教你仔女，同埋佢D同學仔，因為小朋友就好似一部錄影機一樣。所以當大家話間學校D學生好乖，其實各家長在家中已經不斷地教緊。

致於用二年級課本教一年級，我覺得無意思。小明友返學係去學習群體生活，並唔係去鬥用深D課本。唔可能話深就一定好，如果令到小朋友無學習興趣，再深課本又有乜意思?

hk-mum，請問你小朋友轉邊間學校?

原文章由 hk-mum 於 07-10-17 16:34 硐表
我曾經問過心理學的counsellor, 這些英文字可以學, 但不須要串.
試問你們小一時懂得串headmistress嗎? 那時才自自然然串懂呢? 須知小孩的認知力是跟時日增長的, 6歲時的死記硬背, 似乎浪費了童年的美好時光.
我要說 ...

concern_mom

我之前有個topic係想講某名校究竟有也個人之處。當然種種意見都有，但最實質都係話個小朋友好乖…等等。

其實小朋友乖唔乖，你覺得學校真係可以教到? 我個人覺得受同學影比較多。咁點解個小朋友返學真係乖? 因為受其他同學影，細個時侯，亞媽無時無刻話要有家教。小朋友好天真，佢行為其實就係你自己。放學返屋企，你又會睇到D老師係點教你仔女，同埋佢D同學仔，因為小朋友就好似一部錄影機一樣。所以當大家話間學校D學生好乖，其實各家長在家中已經不斷地教緊。

致於用二年級課本教一年級，我覺得無意思。小明友返學係去學習群體生活，並唔係去鬥用深D課本。唔可能話深就一定好，如果令到小朋友無學習興趣，再深課本又有乜意思?

hk-mum，你小朋友轉邊間學校?

chelsea

The measurement of success to everyone is different.

One might think calculative, cunning, trade-off, boosting of self-image, rival competition, trap to your team mate and high IQ but low EQ are all the elements for the success.

But I see passionate, considerate, gentle manner, respectful, responsive and always strike for the best in all rounds are some of the attributes to all the WYPS students.  The gift of "talent" from GOD is to help/serve others.  And of course parent will contribute part of these attributes as parent should be the teacher at home, what is modelling behaviour, it's absolutely a mirror effect to your child.  

Chelsea

Yau_Cheung

原文章由 chelsea 於 07-10-18 10:31 硐表
The measurement of success to everyone is different.

One might think calculative, cunning, trade-off, boosting of self-image, rival competition, trap to your team mate and high IQ but low EQ are al ...

passionate, considerate, gentle manner, respectful, responsive and always strike for the best in all rounds - they are important.

[ 本文章最後由 Yau_Cheung 於 07-10-18 10:54 編輯 ]

overview

我都覺得吾一定要好深,
好似男拔小二已做緊一般小五既grammar,
咁又如何呢 ?
小朋友只懂死記, 根本就運用吾到,
我好相信讀多d readers, 思維更好,
作文更流暢..
相比下, 華x程度真係小巫見大巫...
家長可能又要同學校反映一下, 出年要加深d
頂唔順最好快d轉校啦...我囝囝又多個chance..HEHE

原文章由 sunnydad 於 07-10-17 17:26 硐表
Agree with HK-mum, Longman出本甘既express，完全滿足大部份急功近利既家長心態．

headmaster, headmistress  唔難，甘你地不如叫學校用'Laws of Empire' （一本法律哲學既書）做教科書！甘咪可以小一畢業就入法律係囉.

深唔 ...

babygarden

其實，學校教得深好與不好，各有各見解。我覺得每個家長為子女報學校時，都會有考慮自己的子女對這所學校的教學方法適合與否，然而，亦有很多家長為了學校的名氣，而忽略了自己子女的學習能力。其實名校之所以出名，必定有其原因（例如，學生的成績和才能比其他學校強、將來出人頭地的機會比別人高……），所以這些名校的教學方法必定會催谷學生，否則便做不出名氣來。

正所謂食得鹹魚抵得渴，如果想自己子女將來能與其他強者爭一夕長短，那麼便要做好心理準備入讀這些名校了！

最後本人亦想說一說自己心底話，就是本人亦不讚同一些名校採用教高一年級之課本來催谷學生，因為這樣學生無可避免地多了一些壓力。其實，讀書的過程應該是循序漸進的好，因為每個學生不是人人都能夠學深一點，如果每個學生都能夠掌握高難度的知識，那麼教統局便不需要定每個學級的教育課程，任由每所學校自由發揮，不知這樣對小朋友是不是好事和對他們的身心發展是不是百利而無一害呢？

chelsea

男拔 is a DSS school, the principal can determine the school curriculum and does not require to follow EDB syllabus.

華x is a Government aided school, the school curriculum has to follow EDB.

Everyone thinks of changing the school, but no one thinks of changing himself.  

Chelsea

原文章由 overview 於 07-10-18 11:25 硐表
我都覺得吾一定要好深,
好似男拔小二已做緊一般小五既grammar,
咁又如何呢 ?
小朋友只懂死記, 根本就運用吾到,
我好相信讀多d readers, 思維更好,
作文更流暢..
相比下, 華x程度真係小巫見大巫...
家長可能又要同學 ...

babygarden

直資學校不是不用跟教統局，只是自由度大一些！

麟媽媽

剩係唔使跟教局既「政府教育語言政策」已經可以鬆一大口氣啦！

原文章由 babygarden 於 07-10-18 11:50 硐表
直資學校不是不用跟教統局，只是自由度大一些！