唔知應該"驚"定應該"喜"--我個女係perfect pitch

JP

I&IMom 寫道:
JP,

gum 不如俾細仔學埋 string!  

I&I,
佢冇興趣學埋 string，我又冇時間/心機陪學！
  
我尋晚督師兩隻仔練琴都用左1.5 hr,就算佢有興趣學埋 string我都C5到時間出黎跟佢,我5同妳全職C9

wewangwang

我諗我個仔是perfect pitch, 佢聽完首歌,自己彈番出黎既(雙手), 連Blue Danube都彈到,咁又點?

Sindy

有perfect pitch都無用,我女之前係聽到錯既都照去...我話媽咪都聽到唔啱,你唔覺既咩...?佢話聽到呀....咁應一句就算...而家叫好d,我成日笑佢,聽到都唔改啱,難為有d人想改但聽唔到.....hehehehe

[quote]
JP 寫道:
Charlotte_mom & sindy>>

之前有老師identify到我細仔係perfect pitch, 大仔係relative pitch. 佢地學piano, 細仔perfect pitch冇乜幫助，反而佢sight reading 、節奏感、領悟力不及哥哥，所以哥哥彈得好D！

如果妳囡有學string都算行

neighbour931

我無乜話邊個, 只係有感而發姐, 得罪!得罪! [quote]
Sindy 寫道:
做乜講我呀       [quote]

Sindy

neighbour931 寫道:
我無乜話邊個, 只係有感而發姐, 得罪!得罪! [quote]
Sindy 寫道:
做乜講我呀       [quote]

講笑啫...你咪鬼咁真啦.....     

kelly-li

Charlotte_mom 寫道:
平時教睇譜唱, 永遠都係最低條線再對落係d, 無論咩major都係, 只係彈琴時雙手擺既位唔同
今日老師教aural, 第一次叫佢拎轉面完全靠聽, 當老師彈c major無發現問題, 不過一轉major, 譬如佢講indicate左g做d, 然後彈d,r,m,f,s, 我個女唔係唱d,r,m,f,s, 而係唱s,l,t,d,r
跟住發現再轉major都係咁, 譬如a major, drmfs, 我個女就會唱l,t,d,r,m (希望你明白我講咩)
請問咁叫perfect pitch嗎............?? 因為我地都係初發現原來佢唱既方法, 同我地想佢唱既方法, 根本唔相同, 所以我有d煩惱
我個女definitely無good voice, 佢唱歌走音架   

a major, drmfs 唱l,t,d,r,m
不是 l, t, d#, r, m 嗎 ?
l,t,d,r,m 會唱成 a minor 的