英國VS香港讀大學2024

KikiDaddy

回覆 twhkleung 的帖子

PCLL is the only pathway to become a lawyer in HK. Hence, a GPA requirement of 2.7 is very reasonable in order to allow those graduates with commitment can get a place.

If you are a LQ 2:2 honor or 3rd honor graduate, hardly can you convince the university you have a commitment to become a lawyer!

In this connection, for the students want to study law in UK (except for those Oxbridge or LSE students), you need to assess your chance of admission to local PCLL if you plan to practice in HK.

This is a report on legal education in HK: -

https://www.legco.gov.hk/yr2024/english/counmtg/papers/cm20240710-sp048-e.pdf

CityU provides a list of the universities that its PCLL students graduated on page 21 (the other two universities do not provide such information). You can see the students coming from varied UK and Australia universities. Overall admission rate is about 50% but it is lower for oversea graduates.

This PCLL is like a entry barrier to the overseas graduates which is similar to the licensing examinations to doctors and dentists. This is an important point to consider when a student decide to study in UK or HK.

nhi

FNN 發表於 24-10-26 09:52
本帖最後由 FNN 於 24-10-26 09:52 編輯

睇吾上眼係嗰班英國尖子，這是事實。我不跟你咬文嚼字。

你不如問下美本top 30, Ivy League 那批學生 （ 我無話尖子啊）, 點睇英國名校 和你口中的尖子.

正所謂一出還有一山高！

本港大學给獎學金 bright PhD students and 有些學校收錢收次等學生誰勝誰劣！

nhi

FNN 發表於 24-10-16 09:44
以律師為例，在美國大型律師行工作的經過兩年培訓的律師，每月薪酬可達十八萬，而在Magic Circle律師行，薪 ...

尖子讀完英國名校, llb, 加 pcll 再加2年training, 入埋Magic circle, 只得 10-11萬, 你唔覺得好低ma?
Property agents好景時一個月20-30萬！

FNN

nhi 發表於 24-10-27 23:47
你不如問下美本top 30, Ivy League 那批學生 （ 我無話尖子啊）, 點睇英國名校 和你口中的尖子.

正所謂一 ...

喜歡橫睇又得，直睇又得，

FNN

nhi 發表於 24-10-28 00:27
尖子讀完英國名校, llb, 加 pcll 再加2年training, 入埋Magic circle, 只得 10-11萬, 你唔覺得好低ma?
Pro ...

Property agent 好景果時一個月二三十個，你唔覺得好低嗎？

twhkleung

FNN 發表於 24-10-28 00:43
Property agent 好景果時一個月二三十個，你唔覺得好低嗎？

人類本身就係貪心嘅動物(包括我自己), 你畀几多佢都好,係冇完結的, 而係越多越好

FNN

twhkleung 發表於 24-10-28 00:50
人類本身就係貪心嘅動物(包括我自己), 你畀几多佢都好,係冇完結的, 而係越多越好

一個月賣兩三支嘢，都吾只搵幾十蚊啦，未見過大蛇屙尿。

twhkleung

FNN 發表於 24-10-28 00:54
一個月賣兩三支嘢，都吾只搵幾十蚊啦，未見過大蛇屙尿。

咁踩界犯法嘅嘢,我依膽小鬼,又唔敢做啦

FNN

twhkleung 發表於 24-10-28 00:56
咁踩界犯法嘅嘢,我依膽小鬼,又唔敢做啦

地產代理好景時賣幾支樓合法收佣金，為何吾敢做？你以為賣幾支什麼？

nhi

FNN 發表於 24-10-28 00:43
Property agent 好景果時一個月二三十個，你唔覺得好低嗎？

Property agents知道低, 所以唔會週圍唱自己.
勁那批尖子property agents根本睇唔起鷹國名校.

FNN

Property agent 如何低？我從來冇睇吾起人，你吾識笑死人。

買嘢唔係淨係局限喺香港。跨國地產代理部份都係Top Ivy league畢業同時係chartered surveyor，因為搵到錢。 香港吾得吾代表其他地方吾得。我建議你放有時間去compass, Re/max, JLL, CBRE, Knight Frank, Savills約個appointment睇吓，冇錢買都可以睇。

Top Ivy League 畢業有部份回港都要去HKU讀個MSc in Real Estate，攞番個牌，呢個program雖然係taught Master, 但係6個收1個。

早D返工，早D放工，早D返屋企發個好夢，會有二三十蚊個月。

poonseelai

FNN 發表於 24-10-28 01:07
本帖最後由 FNN 於 24-10-28 01:08 編輯

地產代理好景時賣幾支樓合法收佣金，為何吾敢做？你以為賣幾支 ...

你講一支支, 係指一幢幢？有次同上市地產太子女傾開, 佢係咁形容整幢樓宇買賣

FNN

poonseelai 發表於 24-10-28 09:23
你講一支支, 係指一幢幢？有次同上市地產太子女傾開, 佢係咁形容整幢樓宇買賣
...

係！地產行內術語 －蚊 = 一萬

A Wong?

poonseelai

FNN 發表於 24-10-28 09:40
本帖最後由 FNN 於 24-10-28 09:41 編輯

係！地產行內術語 －蚊 = 一萬

你咁醒嘅

FNN

poonseelai 發表於 24-10-28 09:43
你咁醒嘅

你係convent妹？

cafeva

KikiDaddy 發表於 24-10-27 11:41
回覆 twhkleung 的帖子

GPA of 2.7 is roughly the cutoff for 2:2 honor which is not that difficult to ...

2/3 of the HKU law graduates can get places of its PCLL >> 星期六info day 個講者話HKU LLB graduate 95% admission rate to the PCLL program.

poonseelai

FNN 發表於 24-10-28 10:00
你係convent妹？

no, 工作上接觸

elbar

cafeva 發表於 24-10-28 10:22
2/3 of the HKU law graduates can get places of its PCLL >> 星期六info day 個講者話HKU LLB graduate 9 ...

英國 Top 5 U & CUHK law graduates 都應有機會啩

KikiDaddy

回覆 cafeva 的帖子

I got the PCLL admission information from wiki: -

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postgraduate_Certificate_in_Laws

the Legco report on Legal Education: -

https://www.legco.gov.hk/yr2024/english/counmtg/papers/cm20240710-sp048-e.pdf

and HKU PCLL Brochure: -

https://www.ple.hku.hk/_files/ugd/448b6d_74a8c3d57c6d41199cacab7a88477595.pdf

In the Brochure, it mentions that a mid range 2:2 honor is requred for the applicants received offers.

If 95% of all the law graduates can be admitted to PCLL, then some of the graduates with 3rd honor will be admitted.

Let me ask my son, who is a Year 1 HKU law student, if he knows how this percentage is calculated.

FNN

cafeva 發表於 24-10-28 10:22
2/3 of the HKU law graduates can get places of its PCLL >> 星期六info day 個講者話HKU LLB graduate 9 ...

According to the 2023 legal education report, a total of 126 students were admitted to undergraduate programs at the University of Hong Kong (HKU). Additionally, 174 students were accepted into the four LLB dual-degree programs. Furthermore, HKU admitted 54 students for the Juris Doctor (JD) program, bringing the total number of admissions to approximately 354 students.

Assuming a consistent admission pattern over the years, 283 students were admitted to the Postgraduate Certificate in Laws (PCLL) program, with 78% holding a HKU law degree. Out of the total 354 students, around 220, representing a maximum of 62% would be admitted to HKU's full-time PCLL. The part-time PCLL program would enroll an additional 102 students, with 73% holding an HKU law degree. This results in a total of 74 students.

When we combine the 220 students from the full-time PCLL with the 74 from the part-time program, the maximum percentage of students with HKU law degrees reaches 83%.

Consequently, the claim of a 95% admission rate does not appear to be substantiated assuming that all JD and dual degree students were interested in PCLL.

P.S. While some students may choose to pursue the PCLL at CityU or CU, the proportion of these students is not significant enough to accurately reflect the figures.