2010全港中學排位

goodenough

原帖由 ElizabethLAI 於 11-5-5 20:16 發表


在沒有任何証據下,我覺得你這樣說對這兩間中學的持份者很不公平,亦有損有關學校校譽.

yes, I agree with you and I do apologize for that.
As the case has over, I am willing to retract my words。

pandato

若果所有直資都可留位又容許參加中央派位就very good了。始終隨機編號是一個不能控制的數值，band1頭派band1尾每年都有發生。記得當年揸住間私小去大抽獎，真係零壓力。祝大家好運!

原帖由 skytrain 於 11-5-5 22:05 發表
据我所知, 另有直资学校的英文班是這樣做的。例如佢中一有140个位, 70个放出來大抽獎, 70个自已收人，我唔觉得唔妥。講真, 如果你是 band 1中, 佢收咗你但叫你簽放棄你都唔肯啦。 ...

[ 本帖最後由 pandato 於 11-5-6 00:22 編輯 ]

cckidsmm

我又覺得maths2000個排名算ok,個個表都未必做到十全十美,都係給大家多個reference姐.

hi khmama,
我有小小問題不明名白, 其實私校和資的學校都有公開"6科14分百份比、各科平均優良率、拔尖人數…"為何較難一起排名呢?
唔好意思咁多問題 thanks!!

iantsang

khmama, thanks very much for your efforts to put together this list.  I have tried to put together an analysis for a smaller number of schools before and it already took a great deal of time!  Your devotion should be highly appreciated.

Just like to point out a correction on your list for St. Louis School which ranked #100 in your list.  It has participated in the class cutting exercise on previous year so its S1 has only 4 classes this current year.  Please kindly correct it later together with other changes you may have.  Thanks!

Btw, just a wonder, I notice you have added the number of students selected to enter universities in S6 (拔尖) and seems those with over 10 are being put in the top of the ranking.  Does this override the 14 points % in the ranking?  Thanks in advance!

dad1234

我想知學校公開6科14百份比有無法理支持?
如果學校講大話會唔會有後果?
有無部門㈼測?

twcho

As you have tried to put the data together for a smaller size and found it so time consuming, you would agree that the most precious thing that the list Khmama prepared for us is that she has gathered all the factual information in her table. You can pick the parameter(s) that you consider the most critical and alter the rank as you like to suit your own weighting scale.

Tommy

原帖由 dad1234 於 11-5-6 00:42 發表
我想知學校公開6科14百份比有無法理支持?
如果學校講大話會唔會有後果?
有無部門㈼測?

早年好似曾經有相關的作弊行為發生過（未必係明呃，或者係誤導），並被人揭發，但後來都只是教育局和學校之間「私了」算數，沒什麼大的懲處。

greendotdot

原帖由 Tommy 於 11-5-6 00:53 發表


早年好似曾經有相關的作弊行為發生過（未必係明呃，或者係誤導），並被人揭發，但後來都只是教育局和學校之間「私了」算數，沒什麼大的懲處。 ...

你令我想起TVB的義海豪情！

PS.
唔好意思，離咗題，對不起，咁我edit講俾Tommy聽：有段情節男主角捉到大奸角侵吞幫會巨款，如果交大奸角俾警局便是「公了」，交大奸角俾幫會便是「私了」，男主角身為警察隊長佢要決定「公了」抑或「私了」。對唔住，打攪晒！

[ 本帖最後由 greendotdot 於 11-5-6 01:27 編輯 ]

Tommy

原帖由 greendotdot 於 11-5-6 01:05 發表


你令我想起TVB的義海豪情！

呢幾年好少睇電視，其實唔係好明您的意思。Anyway, 跟主題無關，您唔使覆我喇！

kilykilyk

唔知有無睇錯,下面個排名,1-103名裏唔見元朗"趙聿修紀念中學",趙律修真係差咗咁多??盧幹庭都69名..


http://www.maths1000.com/index.php?action=schoolranksdetail&id=6

[ 本帖最後由 kilykilyk 於 11-5-6 01:26 編輯 ]

iantsang

Oh sorry I am not trying to challenge the methods the schools are being ranked.  It's only because this column was not present in last year's spreadsheet as prepared by khmama so I just like to seek some clarifications only.

Please accept my apology if you find my question inappropriate.

原帖由 twcho 於 11-5-6 00:48 發表
As you have tried to put the data together for a smaller size and found it so time consuming, you would agree that the most precious thing that the list Khmama prepared for us is that she has gathered ...

khmama

原帖由 iantsang 於 11-5-6 03:01 發表
Oh sorry I am not trying to challenge the methods the schools are being ranked.  It's only because this column was not present in last year's spreadsheet as prepared by khmama so I just like to seek s ...

因為有熱心家長曾經做過統計, 當然用得唔好徙, 放入個表比多o的資料家長作比較. 我會睇重拔尖人數, 其次係人均優良率, 跟住係各科優良率. 我覺得6科14分比率只顯示達標人數, 如果80%6科14分但係原來個個成績好一般, 咁樣間學校都唔算係好好成績. 上年冇拔尖人數既資料, 所以冇呢一欄, 遲下多o的時間, 希望出番個修訂版. 如果家長有資料,不妨分享, 令個表更完善.

khmama

第一頁個表只係簡化版, 真正既表可以係樓上下載區下載或click呢個link. 不過遲下會有修正.
http://www.FreeUploadShare.com/DOWNLOAD/cc3402228/School Information List4.xls

khmama

原帖由 cckidsmm 於 11-5-6 00:23 發表
我又覺得maths2000個排名算ok,個個表都未必做到十全十美,都係給大家多個reference姐.

hi khmama,
我有小小問題不明名白, 其實私校和資的學校都有公開"6科14分百份比、各科平均優良率、拔尖人數…"為何較難一起排 ...

直資除咗top既幾間有資料外, 其餘band2/3直資好難係校網搵資料, 既然資料不足就不如唔做, 免得誤導咗家長. 不過我會研究下中六第一階段有冇o的有用資料作分析.

lopoto

我想問下 體藝 大概係邊個位到? 我搵唔到呢間學校。

THX !

LSEAANU

Hi  KHMAMA
You are very great to help us.
Please include the 直資(有幾多資料就list幾多) to make it 更完善
Thank you once again.

Summer

That's brilliant!

多利是

香島中學,而家係未報唔到架啦,要等放磅後?

skytrain

I think so.  The deadline was 11 March.

chanpa

原帖由 khmama 於 11-5-6 22:48 發表
第一頁個表只係簡化版, 真正既表可以係樓上下載區下載或click呢個link. 不過遲下會有修正.
http://www.FreeUploadShare.com/DOWNLOAD/cc3402228/School Information List4.xls

It is great to have KHMAMA to collect such large number of data and make such a great and difficult analysis.  I totally agree with her.
After getting into the dream school, the student has to study hard not from the teachers, schoolmates but by himself.  We are sending our kids to MARS to explore 3+3 system, a system full of mystery.  
For me, I have got out of the nightmare of DSS, back to the traditional system.