好開心,收左la根德園(請大家入黎update下比左留位費未)

PMQ

docomo,

唔公平, 哈哈.... 我囡囡都是你所寫讀緊呢間學校嘅小朋友, 唔一定考到&讀緊呢間學校就一定要讚自己所讀的學校嘅, 你今年考之嘛讀過未呀?
(以下只是本人經歷, 唔滿意的可以當冇看過, 不用批抨) :
老師冇愛心, 仲要投訴, 完全唔協助家長解決問題, 學校冇透明度, 如果你是全職媽媽又非常緊張小朋友的學校情况的話, 就是慎重考慮. 囡囡今年K1, 我是全職媽媽,自己接送到班房, 但老師和家長的溝通可以說是0 (一句起兩句止). 一班三十幾人前後左右都病, 缺席少不免, 問老師缺席期間所教的生字班咪唔識囉, 佢居然答 : 梗係啦. 激死. 大家到知老師講一句好過家長講一百句, 囡囡教極都唔記得. 仲有老師居然投訴我, 因囡囡食其他同學的卜卜脆食物, 話我淨你bread and cake, 点解帶脆的食物是對呢?
死讀書, 唔去解釋給學生知對與錯, 係唔係就是一間好學校?小朋友係班房死咕咕聽書,唔可以講嘢否則罰企, 完全和我囡囡的性格完全相反, 所以我好後悔冇學我朋友寫求情信去St.Cat. 一心覺得傳统學校好D, 小朋友會乖D, 唉!...
反而我朋友和個囡囡不知幾happy, 雖然佢take school bus, 但可以留电和老師直接了解小朋友的情况(差不多講成個鐘, 協助家長解决小朋友的問題), 學校透明度高, 每樣事情都會出通告联絡家長, 最近佢哋的小朋友仲話學寄信 (帶stamp和信封),功課不用寫只是剪報找字,  
可能時代不同, 現今的小朋友真係聰明好多, 所以活學活用的教學是比較易吸收的. 希望K2可

Waterkim

其實，評估一間學校好與否的確十分困難。

如我個案，囝囝入讀根德園都是身邊人意見，因害怕學校太深、老師古板及透明度低；但隨著孩子入讀三個月後，害怕感覺隨之而去；學校老師非常有愛心，與她們傾談孩子的問題，她們都很樂意及詳盡解答，小孩子亦很渴望上學；但另一方面，的而且確課程很深(孩子好像明瞭課程的一切)及透明度一般，往往不像其他學校發出通告給予家長有關一切，但我仍然堅持，如果孩子渴望上學的，這間學校是差極有限。

但我朋友個案，與我相反，她說老師很不注意孩子，相反很惡，沒有禮貌，她感覺很慘，想幫囡囡轉校。但對學校教程又十分滿意，囡囡又沒有不快感覺。

以上個案得出，若同一學校都有分別的個案，係沒有一個絕對好或不好，真要看看你的彩數(班主任是一個重要問題)！

因每間學校都有此問題，每位家長都應想想，怎樣的學校(或班主任)才是你心想的。？

yi

Hi, Waterkim
I also worried about the 透明度 of Kentville. you mentioned that 透明度一般，would you please state more clearly? e.g. any parents day? no notice to parents at all? Please share yr experience

elok

PMQ,
我都希望你轉到,不過就算轉唔到,我諗都唔應該留係這校.

我非常同意,每間學校都會好及唔好,最緊要我諗係適合自己小朋友啦.

docomo

PMQ,
你話:
你今年考之嘛讀過未呀?
我唔係今年考,而係個小朋友已經開開心心咁讀完3年,係咪有資格對呢間學校作出評語呢?
我唔會否定你o既不幸遭遇,不過,你有無睇過我上一段留言呢?
其實邊會有十全十美o既學校丫
o係呢度有媽咪好唔滿意根德園,但o係另一個topic就有好多媽咪好滿意,
同樣,有好多人中意sc,
但我亦見過好似PMQ唔滿意根德園咁,
一樣好唔滿意sc,所以,邊會有100%好丫
[size=medium]我就打死都唔信所有讀sc o既學生家長都完全滿意佢

Waterkim

Yi,

的而且確係沒有家長會。

KY

想請問信上面寫著
"by registered post and postmarked by December4 2004"
是否真的一定只可以係當日(SAT)寄出及一定要寄registered post?
點解咁奇怪?
thanks a lot

cwlbbs

hi achan97,
首先多謝你回應。

你小朋友係入邊讀得辛苦嗎？聽聞好多家長comment此校會好谷小朋友學術上技能，是嗎？

冇家長會又真係吾知小朋友係學校做過d咩？叻果d就識同家長講，不善於詞令既小朋友點expect佢地同家長講到？

cwlbbs

achan97

cwlbbs>>好老實!我真係唔覺個女辛苦!反而我有時都真係覺得幾多功課!我都同意docomo講,邊有一間幼稚園係完美架?真係每個人要求唔同,我以前都係鐘意SC多D架,但佢唔收我個女無計,我都擔心亞女入左根德園會辛苦,但我蝦子餅話事解:佢讀得唔開心咪同佢轉返出黎囉!要考入去就話難姐,轉出黎是但一間都收啦!咁佢又講得岩,所以我覺得你地唔駛太擔心,發覺小朋友唔開心先轉校咪得囉!

無家長會,但老師一年會見兩次家長,有問題就直接打比老師!有重要野佢地有通告,佢地唔出通告果D通常唔重要得去邊,老師係想借機會TRAIN下佢地!我個女係咩都唔會講,老師都同我講唔駛擔心,比多少少時間佢地就得,唔會扣分既!咁囉.....    even而家k.2我個女都成日唔記得野架啦,唔駛咁緊張........

JJ1122

同意achan97所講.. 個女亦幸運地3年都遇到好老師.  雖然每年老師都唔一樣, 但係佢久唔久都會記得邊個老師講過d咩.  我見過佢一個老師無咩笑容.. 但係問佢, 佢話個個老師好好人, 成日會讚佢寫字有進步.  所以有時家長見到既野, 未必等於小朋友心中睇既野同感受.  只要佢鐘意番學, 學到應該要學既野.  相信已經係一間唔錯既幼稚園.  
K1 既時候個女因為病無番學一個星期, 我打比老師問應該點, 個位老師同我講"唔洗怕, 其實我地教既野會不停咁重覆, 佢d個星期唔識, 遲下都會識."  
不過如果好鐘意親子活動既家長, d間學校就真係唔會滿足到你.  但係一般小朋友既運動會, 上台表演, party, 同扮鬼扮馬佢地都會有既.  
功課, 測驗係咪好深, 我又唔敢講一定係.  bk 好多其他幼稚園家長話d小朋友默書寫個d字, 佢地有d都未教.  我有朋友個女宣道讀K3, 佢寫個d, 根德都未寫.  
學校要你知既一定會通知你.  只係話比小朋友知, 等佢話比你知既係一種訓練.  始終小學讀傳統既學校都係咁架啦, 細時唔教, P1 先係學咪仲論盡.  老師會教小朋友自己溫習, 見老師既時候老師話明白我地好多都係在職媽媽, 如果每樣野都等放工先跟就好"side" 時間, 所以佢希望佢地識得自己溫習好, 我地放工只係回顧下就收得工.  我唔需要佢成績好, 只係要佢學識自我學習, d樣係終生既野黎架嘛.

danielboy

KY,

Don't worry, 一D都唔奇怪.
1. Yes,一定要寄registered post
2. "by 4 December" = on or before 4 December,
唔係要4 Dec寄.

KY 寫道:
想請問信上面寫著
"by registered post and postmarked by December4 2004"
是否真的一定只可以係當日(SAT)寄出及一定要寄registered post?
點解咁奇怪?
thanks a lot

heimom

indeed, u can hand in the form and all the other relevant documents in person within this week
no need to wait until 4 Dec 2004 and they would issue the receipt to u later

HuiTung

heimom 寫道:
indeed, u can hand in the form and all the other relevant documents in person within this week
no need to wait until 4 Dec 2004 and they would issue the receipt to u later

Are you sure?  

jazzmama

YES, I CALLED TO KENT LAST WEEK & CFM.
IF YOU HAND IN BY PERSONALLY BUT DURING SCHOOL TIME, NO OFFICIAL RECEIPT TEMPERTORY.

NO NEED TO SEND 受權書

makfr

I received letter on Nov 27, Kentville fail my son as well.

Maybe I can try next year since my son is a small boy and there're some babies who accepted by Kentville this year born in Nov & Dec 01.

Even I have applied SC also, I think they will fail my son too.

For the time being, my son will go to St. Nicolas & York for interview on Dec 4 & 23 respectively.  Hopefully one of them will accept my son.

wbmom

mak fr

may I know why do you think Kentville reject your son?

My son is a Dec baby and I am also waiting for St. Cat's result, he didn't do too well there but I still hope they will take into account he is younger than most of other candidates.

I'll also go for York's interview on Dec 23. What is St. Nicolas? I have never heard of it, is it in Kowloon Tong? Has any kinder offered your son a place yet?

cherriemama

makfr,

Don't be so "grey"! 希望在人間! Maybe you have a good news from SC!!

makfr寫道:
Even I have applied SC also, I think they will fail my son too.

makfr

wb mom,

Kentville's letter mentioned that they cannot offer seat for my son due to limited space.

Re St. Nicolas, chinese name is 金巴倫, which is loacted in Kowloon Tong as well.  I'm sure you have seen 金巴倫 discussing group in this bk web.  

Somehow, some people think St. Nicolas is better than York but I know that York will ask their student to join Cambrige English Exam in which that can ensure the students' English standard. (Hope that my info is correct)

For the time being, my son has been to SC, Kent, Cannon for interview.  Cannan (Kln Tong) accept him but this is not my target kinder.

My target kinders are SC, Kent, & Christ Church (will try apply when my son is 4 - 5 years old).  Since my son is still very younger, I don't mind to apply my target kinders next year.

makfr

Cherriemama,

Thank you.

As I said to wb mom, I will try to apply SC & Kent next year if SC fail my son as well.  

Since my son is still very young, I might let him study N1 in other kinder first as for training then apply my target kinders next year.

Bambi

JJ1122:
I 100% agree with you! 尤其係'我地放工只係回顧下就收得工', 岩晒我呢o的'忙/懶'媽咪. By the way, has any school accepted your kid for 05 P1?

JJ1122 寫道:
同意achan97所講.. 個女亦幸運地3年都遇到好老師.  雖然每年老師都唔一樣, 但係佢久唔久都會記得邊個老師講過d咩.  我見過佢一個老師無咩笑容.. 但係問佢, 佢話個個老師好好人, 成日會讚佢寫字有進步.  所以有時家長見到既野, 未必等於小朋友心中睇既野同感受.  只要佢鐘意番學, 學到應該要學既野.  相信已經係一間唔錯既幼稚園.  
K1 既時候個女因為病無番學一個星期, 我打比老師問應該點, 個位老師同我講"唔洗怕, 其實我地教既野會不停咁重覆, 佢d個星期唔識, 遲下都會識."  
不過如果好鐘意親子活動既家長, d間學校就真係唔會滿足到你.  但係一般小朋友既運動會, 上台表演, party, 同扮鬼扮馬佢地都會有既.  
功課, 測驗係咪好深, 我又唔敢講一定係.  bk 好多其他幼稚園家長話d小朋友默書寫個d字, 佢地有d都未教.  我有朋友個女宣道讀K3, 佢寫個d, 根德都未寫.  
學校要你知既一定會通知你.  只係話比小朋友知, 等佢話比你知既係一種訓練.  始終小學讀傳統既學校都係咁架啦, 細時唔教, P1 先係學咪仲論盡.  老師會教小朋友自己溫習, 見老師既時候老師話明白我地好多都係在職媽媽, 如果每樣野都等放工先跟就好"side" 時間, 所以佢希望佢地識得自己溫習好, 我地放工只係回顧下就收得工.  我唔需要佢成績好, 只係要佢學識自我學習, d樣係終生既野黎架嘛.