聖保祿小學 vs 港大同學會

triceramum

mcl203 發表於 20-4-16 15:51
你寫咁大堆論點，似乎都證明唔到甚麼，SPCS本身一向嘅傳統風格如是。你話人哋drop out rate，人哋可能去咗 ...

不如咁諗, 打算出國ge就spcs因為氣氖都係放洋多, 話唔定到時同同學一齊去; 不打算或未諗店去唔去就港同至於其他因素ge比重, 我諗樓主最清楚
btw, 希望你能快啲揀定就放位啦, 同學仔等緊call

interview

最緊要看孩子/家長性格

對於 convent:

好鍾意自由奔放嘅小朋友或者好鍾意比意見嘅家長絕對不適合讀

乖嘅小朋友會讀得開心因為老師會鍾意。但乖不代表呆板！懂得適應環境也是一個也是一樣很重要的技巧

學校也有project做，好處是好多時校內完成不用家長參與。 從幼稚園起學校是訓練小朋友要獨立處理事情也不喜歡家長插手。

小學時期的確每年有幾個人走，多數去國際學校，DGS，少部份真係讀不上（我認識的幾個都是clinically diagnosed專注力不足或其他情緒問題發展問題）。冇走嘅，個個都讀得好開心好喜歡學校

monodad

我終於明白原來個個人去睇school report係可以睇珅唔同嘅結果出嚟，樓上某D嘅分析數據我睇到抓晒頭，我剩係睇到：

HKUGA degree offer 103/128 = 82.81%
HKUGA DSE 3大 offer 64/128 = 50%

SPCS degree offer 142/147 = 96.59%
SPCS DSE 3大 offer 52/90 = 57.77%

其他33222 ratio我從來唔睇，入得B1學校你自己33222都冇嘅話咩學校都幫你唔到。

學費：SPCS $2500/M (另外應該有8成人以上攞到學校嘅scholarship) vs HKUGA $4000/M

除咗要親身體驗教學模式、校風、體藝成就等考量因素外，所有數據已經好透明咁擺喺枱面俾家長㨂（除非如樓上所提係假數據啦，我相信百年天主教老校唔會提供假數據嘅）

monodad

mcl203 發表於 20-4-16 15:51
你寫咁大堆論點，似乎都證明唔到甚麼，SPCS本身一向嘅傳統風格如是。你話人哋drop out rate，人哋可能去咗 ...

多數讀唔掂去放洋？唔會掛？人地igcse 4 subject 8 level 以上 87% 人考到喎⋯⋯考到呢個成績，外國大把好嘅college 收啦⋯⋯讀唔掂？

SPCS 同HKUGA畢業生都係 14X個？唔通SPCS F1收好多人， HKUGA 收好少？ 所以drop our rate SPCS 好高？ 而佢地又係因為讀唔上而Drop?

mcl203

monodad 發表於 20-4-16 16:53
多數讀唔掂去放洋？唔會掛？人地igcse 4 subject 8 level 以上 87% 人考到喎⋯⋯考到呢個成績，外國大把好 ...

為咗滿足自己嘅正確睇法，要搵啲論點嘅，這並不只出現於某一間學校或某一個po ~~~

interview

monodad 發表於 20-4-16 16:53
多數讀唔掂去放洋？唔會掛？人地igcse 4 subject 8 level 以上 87% 人考到喎⋯⋯考到呢個成績，外國大把好 ...

還有一點，是中學好像不收插班生，F1 後沒有外援

monodad

mcl203 發表於 20-4-16 16:57
為咗滿足自己嘅正確睇法，要搵啲論點嘅，這並不只出現於某一間學校或某一個po ~~~
...

典型嘅.....if you can’t convince him, confuse him

monodad

interview 發表於 20-4-16 16:59
還有一點，是中學好像不收插班生，F1 後沒有外援

F1有外校生，而是都係好好成績嘅外援，之後都有個別插班生㑹考慮

mcl203

interview 發表於 20-4-16 16:59
還有一點，是中學好像不收插班生，F1 後沒有外援

只數人頭，又可以假設spcc/dgs無乜讀唔掂嘅學生要被離開～～～

interview

monodad 發表於 20-4-16 17:02
F1有外校生，而是都係好好成績嘅外援，之後都有個別插班生㑹考慮

原來有插班，咁我收錯料，謝告知

mimi1102

樓主其實你三年前揀SPK, 多多少少都反影左你鍾意邊類型嘅學校, 當初你考港小, 可能只係想買保險,既然SPC 收番你個女, 表示你女都好適合讀SPC, 其實都冇咩好煩惱.

百年老校, 真係好難同新派直資(雖然都成廿歳) 比, 各有各好, 各取其所. 雖然港同書院有出過狀元, 但整體成績先最重要, 我心目中嘅神校, 香港只有兩間.

其實港小黃校長亦講過好多次, 活動教學, 唔係唔洗上堂, 唔洗温習, 只係相比傳統教學, 用另一種方法去教而已. 去到港同書院, 一樣有好多UT, quiz, 一樣要温習, 唔温習一樣會好低分, 港同仲要加埋好多project, 但老實講, 我只係小一時, 輕輕咁幫過佢一次, 之後就冇理過佢嘅project.

疫情中, 佢地繼續online learning, 當然有人話好, 有人話唔好, 因為佢地係冇停過上堂, 默書, 下星期仲有唔知測驗定考試. 哎...講遠左, 總之, 無謂再比併兩間學校嘅成績喇, 樓主應該自有選擇.

et04032007

回覆 monodad 的帖子

SPCS primary tuition is not $2500; HKUGA primary one tuition is $31000/year

Admission rate to HKU, CU, UST (even count just the 60% of S6 taking dse) is also not 57% as shown from school prospectus. A parent has fact-checked that overall admission of HKU, CU, UST (DSE and A-level) and  is 45%


From the keeness of this thread, it is apparent many parents are eager to get call wait of HKUGA and do not mind to inflat SPC for the thread owner to drop the call wait offer

et04032007

回覆 monodad 的帖子

Chinese is the struggling subject.

IGCSE and A-level results do not mean the student can excel as well in DSE with Chinese subject as the compulsory subject.

Besides, SPC take far more students in S1 than HKUGA.

monodad

et04032007 發表於 20-4-16 17:44
回覆 monodad 的帖子

SPCS primary tuition is not $2500; HKUGA primary one tuition is $31000/year

所以我話唔同人會睇到唔同嘅result，我㨂得考GCE就梗係first priority 去外國啦⋯⋯會留喺香港讀大學自然考DSE，唔該Apple to apple比較可以嗎？ 你比較中學成績，我當然比較中學嘅學費，就算平均返中小學學費，亦唔見得差好遠。呢個post嘅本意係問咩我諗亦唔到你閣下去代為發表掛？

et04032007

回覆 mimi1102 的帖子

Exactly, the difference in academic results isn't the key and two school is in the same range anyway. Apart from SPCC and DGS, most of other band 1A does not present the big difference.

It is the learning approach and style that can impact the child's motivation of learning. And every kids are different. There is no one school that fits all kids.

monodad

et04032007 發表於 20-4-16 17:51
回覆 monodad 的帖子

Chinese is the struggling subject.

中文係死亡之科所以令HKUGA入U率得82%?咁學校要更加努力先得囉⋯⋯如果閣下要咁比較學術嘅話，咁我寧願讀間96%入U嘅學校好過入一間要考中文科DSE試，而又有機會唔合格學校又幫唔到手咁

et04032007

回覆 et04032007 的帖子

From the school prospectus, admission to HKU, CU and UST (DSE candidates) is 52%

et04032007

回覆 triceramum 的帖子

Yes, as the culture is going abroad. If the parents aren't prepared to send the children abroad but the student might still insist on it. Power of peer influence.

et04032007

回覆 monodad 的帖子

The merit of 100% promotion instead of selection and filtering and dropping out the under-performing students. Many so-called through train schools in fact are blocked-train.

et04032007

回覆 monodad 的帖子

High admission degree rate is easy to be acheived if parents are willing to spend the extra to send the children abroad. It is more about affordability than academic results.

Back in the old days, those failed the HKCEE would easily got nice degrees in other countries.