香港華仁申請成為直資不獲接納

Jovywong824

hkpapa852 發表於 18-7-23 13:06
華小學生不濟，頂多令到書院做唔到全英中。觀乎全港不少主收非B1學生既中學，如香島，伍若瑜，聖瑪加利甚至 ...

按 1617 DSE 計,   應系
聖鄧 比  華富呂明才 好
華富呂明才(英文3以上 81%,  中文3以上系70% )  又比   華仁 (最好5科 3 以上系 72% 左右)  好

但我想信大部份人如 港華, 聖鄧 或聖呂都收, 都會去港華, 始終名氣響 , 及設施較好, 關汪負增值的人比較少

adriantai

其實華小轉直私先可以做到雙嬴...

mcl203

adriantai 發表於 18-7-23 14:39
應該"大約"計到, 肯定夠填滿QC果幾十個位....

咁仲要計埋SJC, WYHK, RC， 仲有大戶SKHTSK，條數係好復雜既～～～

adriantai

mcl203 發表於 18-7-23 14:47
咁仲要計埋SJC, WYHK, RC， 仲有大戶SKHTSK，條數係好復雜既～～～

兩間軒小已經包左5X個位

cherrieshum

hkpapa852 發表於 18-7-23 13:06
華小學生不濟，頂多令到書院做唔到全英中。觀乎全港不少主收非B1學生既中學，如香島，伍若瑜，聖瑪加利甚至 ...

那就已經連 band 1c 也不保！！可惜未能成功轉直資，看來落車也是遲早的事！

hkpapa852

cherrieshum 發表於 18-7-23 14:56
那就已經連 band 1c 也不保！！可惜未能成功轉直資，看來落車也是遲早的事！
...

或者睇睇港華過去幾年DSE成績再衡量一下:

畢業年度	DSE成績(5+)	DSE成績(4+)
2013 -  2014	整體5+: ~34%	整體4+: 66.4%
2014 -  2015		4主科平均4+: ~65%
2015 -  2016	Best 5達25分: 20.5%	Best 5達20分: 60.7%
2016 -  2017	Best 5達25分: ~13%	Best 5達20分: ~42%

pccw2017

adriantai 發表於 18-7-23 14:39
應該"大約"計到, 肯定夠填滿QC果幾十個位....

想信有不小他區B1男生都會轉到灣仔抽QC.

mcl203

pccw2017 發表於 18-7-23 16:39
想信有不小他區B1男生都會轉到灣仔抽QC.

露天機～～～

hkpapa852

pccw2017 發表於 18-7-23 16:39
想信有不小他區B1男生都會轉到灣仔抽QC.

他區唔係最Top個班(Top 10%)轉去灣仔區抽QC, 好易出事

pccw2017

hkpapa852 發表於 18-7-23 17:31
他區唔係最Top個班(Top 10%)轉去灣仔區抽QC, 好易出事

唔跌band就得啦，都係靠運氣啫。

hkpapa852

pccw2017 發表於 18-7-23 18:17
唔跌band就得啦，都係靠運氣啫。

如果唔係超強私小B1生轉去灣仔，或名次又唔係校內Top 10%，絕對有機會跌去B2

mcl203

pccw2017 發表於 18-7-23 18:17
唔跌band就得啦，都係靠運氣啫。

似乎hkpapa所講值得參考，他區非強區1C生轉入灣仔係有機會跌落B2~~~

Cliokohonda

王家爸爸 發表於 18-7-20 09:31
This is an assumption made by many people. But I doubt it. If WYK S1 intakes were all B1 boys, as yo ...

band 1 primary school students are everything to DSE result ? my wife was a band 2 students and her HKCEE results are the top 1 percent in HONG KONG . 8A1B , whereas I used to be a band 1 primary school student and turned into a piece of shit ..  you have exaggerated the efficiencies on primary school band one student and show no respect to band 2 n 3 students .

王家爸爸

Cliokohonda 發表於 18-9-3 11:24
band 1 primary school students are everything to DSE result ? my wife was a band 2 students and her ...

The reality is the discovery of black swan wouldn't make white swans black.

Cliokohonda

王家爸爸 發表於 18-9-3 17:09
The reality is the discovery of black swan wouldn't make white swans black.

u are humiliating on all of the so called band 2 and 3 secondary school ..

王家爸爸

Cliokohonda 發表於 18-9-3 17:15
u are humiliating on all of the so called band 2 and 3 secondary school ..

No, I didn't mean it that way.  

王家爸爸

Cliokohonda 發表於 18-9-3 17:15
u are humiliating on all of the so called band 2 and 3 secondary school ..

Although it is not a formal study, but from the available PS1 and DSE results data published by different schools, you can see that there is a rather significant and strong correlation between attainment levels at S1 (HKAT/PS1 results) and DSE results at S6.
Of course, we can't ruling out special cases.  But don't forget special cases are called special cases because they are special cases and they are not the norm.  However, many people have a tendency to put forward their subjective wishes as objective facts.

Cliokohonda

王家爸爸 發表於 18-9-3 17:17
No, I didn't mean it that way.

in my opinion , I consider it is a rank order rather than a determinator on students'abilities in their entire life. adolescenes have a significant change on their desire of learning . I wont discriminate the band 2 3 student as by product in a band 1 school ..indeed . band 1 students have the priority to choose their school but they MAY not more superior than band 23 students in d future

Cliokohonda

王家爸爸 發表於 18-9-3 17:31
Although it is not a formal study, but from the available PS1 and DSE results data published by diff ...

band 2 students may have a good HKAT results .. I agree the point that band 1 student has a higher chance to obtain a good HKAT but we cannot rule out band 2 students' potential abilities and regard them as a burden on band 1 school.