- 在線時間
- 40 小時
- 最後登錄
- 18-9-25
- 國民生產力
- 51
- 附加生產力
- 4
- 貢獻生產力
- 0
- 註冊時間
- 04-6-17
- 閱讀權限
- 10
- 帖子
- 221
- 主題
- 6
- 精華
- 0
- 積分
- 276
- UID
- 24952
 
|
Re: Jolly Phonics ~~ 一定要睇第一頁呀!!
Hi Laputa,
About a year ago, I learnt that phonics is very important in learning. I myself learnt very limited part of phonics from my secondary school's teacher but I really benefited a lot which reflected at my English scores!! When I had been reminded the benefits of phonics, I, like you, started to search for a good phonics programme.
I came across only 2 programme. JP and Letterland (LL) I finally choose JP. It is because it is a synthetic phonics. There is no complicated storyline & characters. It uses body language + picture + sensory + songs..... It is funny and suits little kids more. It is very straight forward as an action means the sound + letter(s) directly........
I also went to some websit and looked what the others' (mostly teacher) comment. Most of the comment is positive and from their experience, the result is positive too.
Of course, I did not have so much research on LL as on JP. In the very first place, I was attracted by the story and charters of LL. Most of them are very logic, interesting and very creative. LL even teaches more complicated blending then JP and I can say that LL is more comprehensive than JP. However, considering the ability of my little daughter who was 19 months when start JP, I choose JP finally.
I am not a professional on English or phonics. In my own and only personal opinion, JP suits little kids, say can be start from 1.5 or 2. They can learn it very fast. For LL, I think at least 3. May be only at that age, they have the ability to "translate" the story/ character to the sound of letter and vice versa.
What's your opinion?? Have you decided yet?? (as I saw that you are looking for LL's material)
For the sufficiency of the supporting material. As the programme and the method is simple, those materials are enough to support me at the time being. Oh, I attended the parent/ teacher training too. It is very useful.
As I said, some of the sounds of letter are not covered by JP. (For example, g has 2 sounds as in go and gym.) I think when I go further in the future, I will use another programme like LEM. |
|