第二屆播道書院小學部懇談室

freddielau

原帖由 bebe_c 於 08-10-19 11:35 PM 發表
我都唔知好唔好搵PTA傾傾, 問過幾個同班同學仔的意見都一樣.....但細路仔的說話亦不能盡信,只見大家的worksheets, dict, quiz....成日老師都改錯野...問其他同班生,老師教grammar時有冇講點解eg. write 點解要change ...

I think need to talk to Principal or the class teachers directly....to my knowledge, there should be a Parents-Teacher gather sometime in Nov...

Dennisk

原帖由 freddielau 於 08-10-20 00:03 發表


I think need to talk to Principal or the class teachers directly....to my knowledge, there should be a Parents-Teacher gather sometime in Nov...

In my opinion at this moment I will keep to identify what the problem is through the PTA. I will try to ask PTA to help me to collect the information that I missed. Course I don't know what the curriculum in P2 really are. May be our expectation are even higher than they really have to learn, or they use the method we didn't know. I'm not to defend what the thing they have been done but try to understand what we need to know. I think PTA can help in this situation to figure out the curriculum and disclose to the parents even they could act to be a buffer zone between teachers and us to communicate with them in a soft tone.

Directly talk to the Principal is my last step, which mean I had collected all the information or investigate deep enough to prove and to provide a more practical solution to Mr. Lo for following the case and PTA can't help no more.

Dennis

[ 本帖最後由 Dennisk 於 08-10-20 22:25 編輯 ]

labuser

I also have the same question as BeBe C. I agree with dennis's idea. Moreover, I wish the children can go to the school library freely during recess and lunch time. My kid tell that the children are prohibited to use the library.

freddielau

There is a parent talk on 24/10 and god chance to learn more from the Principal

ecec1122

原帖由 bebe_c 於 08-10-19 23:35 發表
我都唔知好唔好搵PTA傾傾, 問過幾個同班同學仔的意見都一樣.....但細路仔的說話亦不能盡信,只見大家的worksheets, dict, quiz....成日老師都改錯野...問其他同班生,老師教grammar時有冇講點解eg. write 點解要change ...

Hi bebe_c,

個人覺得你現在就應該向校長反映, 無須再收集什麼証明 (既然改錯和不作解釋已不只一次, 而且其他的同學仔都是這樣的話), 除非你是想投訢老師的不是, 否則你現在已有所需的資料.
我覺得最重要的問題並不是老師的能力是否未達標, 而是老師這樣做會否打擊學生的自信心, 失去尋根的興趣又或會否令小朋友夾在老師和父母之間(應該相信誰?)令他們感到無所適從, 以後不再發問.

我相信校長是個開明豁達的人, 會明白家長的憂慮和担心, 再且我們是對事而不是針對人, 早些讓校長知道改善利弊不是更好嗎?
播道是一間新校, 我相信正面的意見是有助學校的改進.
未來還要招聘更多老師呢!

再拖的話便要等第二學段了.

freddielau

各位小二家長,又收到Life Wide Learning 的outing 通告了,有冇興趣搞番個集体行程,順便聚聚?

David_Dad

我最近睇過一篇文章, 當中提到小朋友到小三才適合學grammar. 小一, 小二 則類似生活學習.

至於 journal, 我贊成目前老師的做法, 只給正面的評語, 鼓勵學生利用文字創作和表達感受. 若果而家幫他們的大作改 grammar, 我們就大鑊了, 不知由那處教起.

再者, 香港學生普遍的問題不是文法, 而是作文沒有內容.

原帖由 bebe_c 於 08-10-19 23:35 發表
我都唔知好唔好搵PTA傾傾, 問過幾個同班同學仔的意見都一樣.....但細路仔的說話亦不能盡信,只見大家的worksheets, dict, quiz....成日老師都改錯野...問其他同班生,老師教grammar時有冇講點解eg. write 點解要change ...

beetle

David_Dad,

I totally support what you said.  In Western countries, vocabulary, writing freely is emphasized at lower primary while grammar is taught at a later stage.   On the other hand, oral and listening are very important too.  

In order to achieve with this kind of teaching, the quality of the teachers become very crucial.

My daughter will become a member of EC family next year. I concern about the quality of the English teachers and whether they teach whole-heartly.  What do u think about the standard of the English teachers?

原帖由 David_Dad 於 08-10-22 22:56 發表
我最近睇過一篇文章, 當中提到小朋友到小三才適合學grammar. 小一, 小二 則類似生活學習.

至於 journal, 我贊成目前老師的做法, 只給正面的評語, 鼓勵學生利用文字創作和表達感受. 若果而家幫他們的大作改 grammar, ...

Dennisk

原帖由 David_Dad 於 08-10-22 22:56 發表
我最近睇過一篇文章, 當中提到小朋友到小三才適合學grammar. 小一, 小二 則類似生活學習.

至於 journal, 我贊成目前老師的做法, 只給正面的評語, 鼓勵學生利用文字創作和表達感受. 若果而家幫他們的大作改 grammar, ...

由其同意你最後一句：「香港學生普遍的問題不是文法, 而是作文沒有內容。」不過一個好的內容是需要歷練加上創意的，而這些都是急不來。所以正如小學那面門口的一段勉勵家長的話，我們作家長的是需要等待，等待我們的子女成長。正如我們天上的父，每天正等待我們悔改一樣。

Dennis

ling2304

好唔開心呀...... 我女入唔到 EC呀......有哥哥係到讀都 REJECT 左, 點算呀......, 一定要搵校長. 仲有下星期見家長問一問班主任先, 我唔想2個小朋分2間SCHOOL.

都好, 一齊去開心D, 但大家想去邊一個地方先. 最近係咪科學館.

但點解咪考試咁快見家長, 上年都好似冇嫁.

Emailfamily

原帖由 freddielau 於 08-10-22 21:29 發表
各位小二家長,又收到Life Wide Learning 的outing 通告了,有冇興趣搞番個集体行程,順便聚聚?

good idea!

Dennisk

原帖由 freddielau 於 08-10-22 21:29 發表
各位小二家長,又收到Life Wide Learning 的outing 通告了,有冇興趣搞番個集体行程,順便聚聚?

係唔係你做領隊先？你搞我實支持！

Dennis

Dennisk

尋書！

請問有冇家長見到 Daniel 鄺栢謙本數學書 (Book B) 呢？如知下落請pm本人。Thank you

Dennis

freddielau

Dennis,
今日PE堂發生accident, Daniel 和Ian跑步相撞,Ian須入院联針....希湟Ian快d好番,亦希望学校多注意小朋友的安全

hoyhconnie

佢下爬聯咗四針......

我好心痛.......

我明天會去學校搵老師了解吓...點解在PE堂容許小朋友走得咁快時又咁貼????????可以跌到咁傷...咁"應"...

我只希望佢以後每天平平安安上學去,平平安安回家來...

其實我每次見到EC的來電....我個心都會好驚....呢次都冇例外...........

Ian 媽媽

原帖由 freddielau 於 08-10-23 22:32 發表
Dennis,
今日PE堂發生accident, Daniel 和Ian跑步相撞,Ian須入院联針....希湟Ian快d好番,亦希望学校多注意小朋友的安全

midcochow

hoyhconnie

我剛去完旅行回來, edison 就講比我知PE 堂時Ian 撞傷了下巴, 仲流左好多血tim, 而家佢好d 未呀? 希望佢快d 好番啦!

freddielau

我今日一睇到又有Parent-Child Life Wide Learning 時, 我仲諗唔知今年又會唔會有人帶頭做攪手先呢?哈哈... 點知一上BK,就見你Post. 唔駛講, 我緊係去啦, 記得要預我哋呀..........   

原帖由 hoyhconnie 於 08-10-23 23:17 發表
佢下爬聯咗四針......

我好心痛.......

我明天會去學校搵老師了解吓...點解在PE堂容許小朋友走得咁快時又咁貼????????可以跌到咁傷...咁"應"...

我只希望佢以後每天平平安安上學去,平平安安回家來...

其實我每次 ...

safarimama

hi ecec1122 & 各位現任家長

可否講吓播道的課程? 如英文在一,二年級教什麼? 用什麼 READERS? 英文科是否全由外藉老師教?還是一星期教一兩堂phonics/oral 嗰種? 而其他科又是否由"全英語" 教?普通話程度如何? 而普通話老師是從內地請來嗎? 因如從北方來的其音準和文學修養都會好好多. 而在數學堂,老師是否都用全英語教呢? 課程又如何呢？
請多多指教！

原帖由 ecec1122 於 08-10-21 15:03 發表



Hi bebe_c,

個人覺得你現在就應該向校長反映, 無須再收集什麼証明 (既然改錯和不作解釋已不只一次, 而且其他的同學仔都是這樣的話), 除非你是想投訢老師的不是, 否則你現在已有所需的資料.
我覺得最重要的問題 ...

freddielau

[quote]原帖由 safarimama 於 08-10-24 01:36 AM 發表
可否講吓播道的課程? 如英文在一,二年級教什麼? 用什麼 READERS? Backpack
英文科是否全由外藉老師教?no
還是一星期教一兩堂phonics/oral 嗰種? 通常初小都係教這些
而其他科又是否由"全英語" 教?all except Chinese , VA, PE
普通話程度如何? I think ok
而普通話老師是從內地請來嗎?I don't think so
因如從北方來的其音準和文學修養都會好好多.
而在數學堂,老師是否都用全英語教呢?in English
課程又如何呢？standard

Emailfamily

原帖由 hoyhconnie 於 08-10-23 23:17 發表
佢下爬聯咗四針......

我好心痛.......

我明天會去學校搵老師了解吓...點解在PE堂容許小朋友走得咁快時又咁貼????????可以跌到咁傷...咁"應"...

我只希望佢以後每天平平安安上學去,平平安安回家來...

其實我每次 ...

呀女都有同我講,希望Ian快D好番!

Dennisk

原帖由 Emailfamily 於 08-10-24 09:16 發表


呀女都有同我講,希望Ian快D好番!

Daniel就只係撞到大腿無乜大外，Ian就嚴重很多，祝Ian早日康復！

Dennis