請問呢題英文題應該點答?

HLE2005

老師話呢題用You 唔啱,佢仲話有啲橋妙! 問咗好多朋友都話應該係用You !
Given words : I / my / We / our / You / Your / They / Their / She / her / He / his

should 前面加咩先啱?

-----------should do your homework .

mietwins

They

do123alex

1.  If possible, call other students or parent to find out they have the same situation.  Sometimes it is just a mis communication from children who may have got it wrong from the teacher.  

2. Back to the answer. If the exercise is a normal exercise ( not a fun IQ test), then it should be very straight forward answer.   ask the teacher in a friendly way what the correct answer should be and why?  Don't blindly believe the any answer without verification.  老師也可能會出錯。This is a real 學習態庋，，讓小朋友養成思考疑問習慣.  





2. Which year  grade is this question?

HLE2005

回復 do123alex 的帖子

其真我都諗過只係老師試比一個信心嘅考驗佢地,但我相信唔會係老師出錯,我亦都明白可能係溝通上問題!但我質疑佢,佢就話妳唔信我呀,我真係聽得好清楚架.

我都問過我小朋友,你有無問過老師,佢話無呀!  個個小朋友聽到老師話呢題唔係用You佢地就擦咗個答案,仲同佢地講呢題有啲"橋妙",仲叫佢地Mark 隻Pepper喺條題目隔離,但佢地諗咗好耐都諗唔到!

但我自己都好好奇,所以喺BK又問吓?

我小朋友係P.2

ae.mama

"I"?

jojoplanet

mietwins 發表於 12-9-9 01:37
They

點解you 唔岩？

JustAParent

原帖由 jojoplanet 於 12-09-09 發表
點解you 唔岩？

太明顯了。答案是' Your parents ', i.e. ' they ' , hehehe

cherubic

There are many possible answers.
If you use 'they', 'he', etc, there must be sentence before this one mentioning who are involved.H

cherubic

If there is nothing before this sentence, i think 'I' or 'we' would be sensible answer.

snugglechums

回復 HLE2005 的帖子

It's a very straightforward question. The missing word (subject) should correspond to "your" (the possessive pronoun). I cannot think of an answer better than "you" unless it is a question referring to a story or a given passage. I am interested to know the "correct" answer if it is not "you"!  

HLE2005

回復 cherubic 的帖子

呢句 句子前面係無sentence, 我地最後用咗"We" , 因為係查字典得出 "We" 當對小朋友表示親熱(切)時 可以用We 代替 You .   e.g   How are we this morning, child ?  

其實當中有12句句子 , 我叫我小朋友自己再諗諗當中邊句最有可能可以用You呢? 跟住佢自己搵出以下呢句:

We are in our classroom.   所以我地將呢兩句掉轉   You are in our classroom.

You should do your homework.                                We should do your homework.

jojoplanet

HLE2005 發表於 12-9-10 09:35
回復 cherubic 的帖子

呢句 句子前面係無sentence, 我地最後用咗"We" , 因為係查字典得出 "We" 當對小朋友 ...

We are in our classroom.   vs  You are in our classroom.

You should do your homework. vs We should do your homework.

但2句意思唔相同喎...

MRSKP

答案應該是......................  We.

cherubic

回復 HLE2005 的帖子

In fact, I don't think it is a good question.  Logically, you will expect "You should do your homework." because homework, once given, belongs to the students.  In that sense, "We should do your homework." is not very logic.

Mighty

如果純粋是文法問題、因後面用左代名詞YOUR、所以答案一定是YOU.　但如果是渉及一点内容問題、例如有前面後理、就有可能其他答案。　　老師都是人、錯下一D不出奇、也不需要想得太複雑。　想得太複雑、有時就是停滞不前的原因。

tws2010

The answer should be "You"

Radiomama

為何咁肯定是WE?

maggie789

樓主，答案是什麼呢？

piyomama

我都想知答案是什麼