原來而家維小都好難入

Jane1983

今日聽朋友講，而家Victoria 幼稚園學生只得不足20%可以入到維小，收咗要比4萬幾元費用留位。當初朋友仲有d吳中意維記歷史短，非IS，而家就好擔心小朋友無地方去。

吳聽佢講都吳意世界真係咁艱難。

pollybell

我朋友講既同你剛剛相反,維小收返晒自己幼稚園既學生,外人得三五個重要好SAMART先收,自己學生收左唔洗比留位費,可以自行考私小.........可能唔同分校所以有唔同.

poonseelai

pollybell 發表於 12-6-14 23:16
我朋友講既同你剛剛相反,維小收返晒自己幼稚園既學生,外人得三五個重要好SAMART先收,自己學生收左唔洗比留 ...

There was no longer a through train system between kindergarten and primary about 4 years ago, and all Victoria kindergarten students need to go through interviews.  

Jane1983

吳係話佢吳收自己學生，係得＜20%的幼稚園生入得番。以前以為好top的去私小直資，英文勁的去IS，有d吳中意IB、嫌貴吳讀，咁起碼有過半機會收....原來而家吳係咁！

吳使比留位費咁好！我朋友係銅鑼灣果間。

pollybell

回復 Jane1983 的帖子

即係收80%出面既學生??咁奇怪自己學生唔收.......................定好似我朋友所講,唔係咁多自己學生.想讀返....學費太貴.

Ving

Even if you are Victoria Kinder student, you still need to pay reservation fee once accepted by Victoria primary. And it is heard that Victoria primary is considering to collect debenture few years later

panala

我諗你地講嘅都啱， 因為我聽番黎係佢地自己幼稚園太多人（幾百人， 唔記得係唔係大約800）， 但小一淨係得百幾個位， 所以自己人都收唔晒，得唔夠20﹪嘅人入得番， 同時因為全部都係自己幼稚園上， 所以收得幾個外人。

poonseelai

pollybell 發表於 12-6-15 00:15
回復 Jane1983 的帖子

即係收80%出面既學生??咁奇怪自己學生唔收.......................定好似我朋友所講 ...

Majority will still be from Victoria kinder. In prior years, only about 10% is from outside and I heard that the school may intend to take more from outside.    For a full IB school, VSA's school is not considered particularly high, especially when there is no subsidy from government or from charitable organisation.  Heard that debentures will be required from school year 2014 onwards.

poonseelai

Every year there are about 600 kinder students from all campus.  20% means about 120 students, and this is roughly the number of intake in primary every year.  I guess that's what 20% kinder students will go to VSA primary mean.

112200

回復 pollybell 的帖子

hi Pollybell,

The real situation is totally opposite to what you said. For sure not all K3 can promoted to P1, you can think there are so many Victoria kindergardten in HK but only 5 classes of P1 . And the reality is I know quite some existing K3 is " rejected " and quite some K3 kids are on waiting list until now. Once accepted, must pay the fee .

hope this info help la.

patpaul_mama

Really ? There are reject letter ? I original thought they only have waiting list .....

elmostoney

pollybell, 冇可能唔收 deposit, 因為係劃一規定, 不分campus. 我都有朋友比左 (佢係九龍), 四萬幾. 另外, 我有朋友係維小讀緊, 所以佢都好update知道情況. 大家諗都諗到, 如果有d campus要比, 有d唔洗, 咁點解要留位比個d唔洗比訂嘅呢? 聽落去都唔合理啦, 咁隨時唔要個位, 又個個留左位先?有d sibling 都入唔返維小, 的確難入係真架.  今年in 維小的維幼K2生, 有27個sibling都入唔返.

elmostoney

據我所聽聞, 維幼有800學生, 佢地會收300人左右, 因為預左有d學生會考IS同直資, 呢批人入到其他學校會走, 所以維小會收得超過佢地 actually有嘅位.  到每年六月, 大家都知道自己入邊間學校, 維小就會做個final count, 如果give up個位嘅小朋友多, 學校有空位, 咁就會通知waiting list嘅 applicants. 聽講今年九月開學, 佢地真係收突左, 因為冇預期咁多人唔要個位, 結果要開多一班.

chansiub

維小其實好唔好? 維小的評價好像比其幼稚園的還要恐怖。

pollybell

留位費問題我當然有質疑啦,我朋友咁講咪咁聽..........佢小朋友讀緊唔通我同佢對質嗎....anyway聽返黎既野都係唔好發表避免誤導其他人.sorry.

HKTHK

pollybell>  Don't think you are right.  Friend of mine just complained about having to pay the deposit to retain the spot.  But of course many will have to do that as it is a good safety backup.

patpaul_mama

Is it work to send letter to the principal and ask for a seat ? My son in on waiting list but quite eager to get in.

Any parents can share your experience ? Thanks

slamai

It will help if you talk directly to the Head of Academy ...

patpaul_mama 發表於 12-6-27 17:58
Is it work to send letter to the principal and ask for a seat ? My son in on waiting list but quite  ...

Jane1983

回復 chansiub 的帖子

其實維幼幾好，語文同presentation skills都好好, 考直資和私小成績都吳錯。起碼佢間間分校年年公佈學生升小學情況，透明度高。

維小就吳敢講，佢出過IB狀元，個女仔係由維幼讀起，出過去一、兩年，又由其他學校轉番去維記，好似吳差。不過，之前google過維小comment，有d家長鬧爆，講得好難聽，真係吳知真假。

chansiub

真係唔知真定假。