請問有冇上過 doremi music wonderland 的課程?

UKCB

請問有冇上過 doremi music wonderland 的 1:1 的鋼琴課程? 他們的老師好嗎? 懂得如何因材施教嗎?
我小朋友只有 3 yrs, 雖然暫時未知佢有冇呢方面既天份, 但希望懂得與小朋友溝通及小朋友心理的老師 ~
多謝回覆 :)

BALLNET

I had once asked this question... until I found this post

http://www.baby-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2003315

[ 本帖最後由 BALLNET 於 11-6-15 21:23 編輯 ]

daisy17772

原帖由 BALLNET 於 11-6-13 23:44 發表
I had once asked this question... until recently I found this post

http://www.baby-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2003315

Yes I recently found this thread as well.  But the center in Tin Hau is huge, they still got lots of students there!

小伊

大部分都系幾歲大小朋友，老師會同父母講，你個小朋友好有音樂天份，然後每月進貢直到天才夢醒時。

yinglongma

太貴了, 不會考慮.

UKCB

多謝你地既回覆, 雖然我無打算搵邱 sir 教 ( $2000/hr) , 太貴, 就算想都負擔唔起, 更何況而家知道係流料 , thanks to all of you

daisy17772

原帖由 UKCB 於 11-6-15 18:46 發表
多謝你地既回覆, 雖然我無打算搵邱 sir 教 ( $2000/hr) , 太貴, 就算想都負擔唔起, 更何況而家知道係流料 , thanks to all of you

邱 sir , mug liu ah??!

BALLNET

佢仲唔係個個肯教，佢先要知道孩子父母是否從事企業高層或銀行家才會考慮

一個從未話過自己跟過某某名師習琴，亦無出示任何演奏或教學文憑，都可收天價，簡直巴閉過註院的演藝名師

現今世道，收費是要貴到一定程度才有人信你勁，大家服未?!!!

katherinelam825

原帖由 ilovethiscow 於 11-6-15 18:56 發表
$2000/ hr...... wow~~~~

閻韻都未收到佢呢個價~

嘩! $2000/hr
岩岩check過蔡祟力都無, 得黃2倫

cyyea

Why not TL Music Wonderland? Reasonable price and interesting for very young children. Don't waste money.

小伊

$2000/hr 學混水摸魚？

daisy17772

However, there have been students from him who successfully got Grade 5 at 5-6 years old.  So there have to be some "monster parents" still believe in him.

That Peekaxxx magazines likes to report his successful cases.

BALLNET

只集中教小朋友練來練去果幾隻五級考試歌，齋練 fingerworks，家長及行外人當然覺得好 impressive

不過叫番小朋友彈番低級歌，佢地就可能連譜都唔識睇

小朋友這樣學琴，過了一段時期便會出現學習樽頸，因為欠缺穩紮基礎訓練

任何學習都是須要從序漸進，未學識加減乘除就教孩子計開方及代數，公式改變少少就唔識得計

ohmygosh

AGREE!

原帖由 cyyea 於 11-6-15 22:19 發表
Why not TL Music Wonderland? Reasonable price and interesting for very young children. Don't waste money.

daisy17772

原帖由 BALLNET 於 11-6-16 14:27 發表
只集中教小朋友練來練去果幾隻五級考試歌，齋練 fingerworks，家長及行外人當然覺得好 impressive

不過叫番小朋友彈番低級歌，佢地就可能連譜都唔識睇

小朋友這樣學琴，過了一段時期便會出現學習樽頸，因為欠缺穩紮基礎訓練
...

True, in this world full of mystery, this kind of "icon" figure could still survive 'cause they "make" people believe in them by knowing how to crack those public exams.  Many of those students who quickly pass Grade 5 could not proceed further to Grade 8 due to lack of fundamental skills.

yinglongma

其實討論也太一面倒了，我女初學琴曾跟過他5個月，老實說進步得好好，三個月學了雙手彈14個major minor scale.之後彈歌，雙手的。之後女兒話想考試，所以開始彈考試歌，二級的。
我們是被報導吸引了，問价後，覺得當時$3OOO/4堂，不會加价，若真兩三年考到8級，比較學十幾年的費用，其實不是貴很多，所以就試一試了。
不學的原因是女兒進度沒有報導的快，當時以邱Sir建議的進度只是一年考二級，當然他說會看女兒的進度同年再考更高級試，並表示若一下子彈三級的話，她會感到困難和欠動力。
其實跟他的時間女兒的進度我很滿意，只是宴用慢些的進度，我也不需用這麼貴的$去學。

yinglongma

補充，其實除了$和其商業手法外，其餘我覺得她對女兒的學琴有重要影響。
女兒在開始了跟他學二級考試歌后，已轉了普通老師，但仍然考了二級也曾在公開彈琴比賽中取了第一。

BALLNET

難得夾得到妳女兒，應該 keep 住上，一年考到兩級係幾好成績

有時都好講學生夾不夾個老師，不過妳付得這個價錢，好可以找真正有名氣或演藝畢業生

原帖由 yinglongma 於 11-6-17 16:39 發表
補充，其實除了$和其商業手法外，其餘我覺得她對女兒的學琴有重要影響。
女兒在開始了跟他學二級考試歌后，已轉了普通老師，但仍然考了二級也曾在公開彈琴比賽中取了第一。 ...