九華好定係港華好呢！

kpw

兩間華仁夠景邊間叻D？

mmylau

您到書店買一本書叫《56號的星光》便會知道

kpw

當然會有一定參考價值，但本書係華仁自己出嘅，唔通佢會將自己D 負面野寫出嚟？所以希望知道坊間對佢地嘅意見。

mmylau

那你可多買一本書叫《自由之路》。

不過看完《56號的星光》終於明白九龍華仁為何是一間名校。

我相信這批華仁畢業生，個個有頭有臉，亦不會過份吹噓

kpw

Thanks mmylau.

mmylau

不用謝了！

希望你看完《56號的星光》也有我的同感

ilovemychild

hk

kpw

Hi Ilovemychild,
可否提供多一些細節及个人意見？我明白每人都有不同嘅選擇條件，因此結果亦未必相同。但我希望係各位嘅意見裡揾到方向，幫助我的細路做个計劃。
謝

hotdogpapa

kpw

“幫助我的細路做个計劃。”

咩計劃？

ALAL

one graduate from Kln Wah Yan told me :
Wah Yan in HK side is better because it is far from shops and has less attraction than in Kln Wah Yan.

kpw

Hi Alal,
Good point. Does HK Wah Yan use different teaching method, or they are executing the strategy differently?

Hi Hotdogpapa,
It is a plan for my childern to study in good university and with strong social group supporting.

mmylau

Wah Yan Kowloon has a bigger campus.

Student has plenty of room to explore himself.

efamily

想請問讀華仁小學o係唔o係可以直升香港華仁或九龍華仁?

mmylau

no directly promotion to Wah Yan Kowloon

kpw

Do you know how they train student "the way to think"?

mmylau

The school will allow students have time and room to think.  Let's the student to decide their own way.

You can buy "56號的星光".  Inside, the old boys of Wahyan have given many examples.

hotdogpapa

kpw：
相信你問一百個人，都有唔同o既見解！
“本是同根生，相煎何太急…”“熱狗”個人認為將兩間名校(仲要同埋亞爺添！)比較是殘酷的！
就有如將郭羨妮同向海嵐比較一樣；兩個都是港姐冠軍，兩個都在娛樂圈發展，你可以喜歡你的嵐嵐、他有他獨愛妮妮！
兩間華仁都是一流一o既百年老店，兩間都同樣以作育英才為依歸，當“我們”全部都蒙主寵召的時候，相信兩間華仁依然在照耀著莘莘學子！要比：
比地方：港華好大好大(兩萬二千米！)，但得九華一半！
比會考成績：九華去年人均摘A率0.99個、港華人均摘A率1.24，贏番場！
比名人：港華出了曾樹蔭、孫明楊、何兆煒(似乎做官多d…)但56號星光(賣左書未？)粒粒都唔差~李柱銘、梁家傑、陳祖澤、李業廣、梁定邦、邢李源、袁天凡、曹宏威等等，仲有董伯伯o既家臣路祥安…
仲要比咩呢？唔好問我教學方法有咩唔同，有冇人讀過兩間華記？搵佢答你！但是“熱狗”心目中唔同狗狗打交o既唔理黑貓白貓都係好貓…唔強迫小朋、有良好學習氣氛o既就是好學校...
所以小朋友入到邊間“華記”同樣值得慶賀…舉杯！要擔心的反而是：“爸媽為我揀了最好的軟件和硬件就走了…”小朋友o既成長與學習不單是靠最top之(器材)就可以平步青雲！有興趣睇下“熱狗”前小學雜談貼題《課外習作DIY、Band 1學生DIY》，“熱狗”只把囡囡放在一間有教無類o既街坊小學…
“熱狗”試過用一部阿爺級486電腦加上古董級lotus123做一份report快過同事用 P-4級配合excel 2002做的！(我說：懂得利用小刀一樣可以宰羊，不懂得利用牛刀只能殺雞！)
又試過用一部國產海鷗35mm相機配一支萬能達鏡頭影夜景靚過身懷數萬蚊nikon器材之闊少！(佢只是鐘情於器材之素質，o係一切都自動化下頭腦生了鏽而已…)
小朋友之成長、學習最重要的是父母o既愛心、關懷、參與、鼓勵、體諒、支持…而並不一定要一間最好o既學校！
還是不明白？就用“身家”去決定好了！聽說九華窮人多、港華富人來….哈哈
你的小朋友今年升中還是小一階段？已經要準備大學之事？

kpw

Hi hotdogpapa,
小兒現在讀幼兒班。現在正在訂定目標及計劃。請恕我長話短說，客氣說說唔講，因為用手寫板後慢。
1) 幾位家長在此提供的資料習中於設備及成就方面。當然，設備是可用來衡量適時性, 名人可用來衡量結果。但我認為training method 同理念最為重要，有冇家長可提供多些其它資料？
2) 有家長話華仁給與學生好多思想上之空間，但唔知兩間華仁用乜野方法幫小朋友建立佢地嘅思考方法？可否有多些資料？
另有閣下對小朋友學習之安排及意見，我亦見很多家長循此方向走。但我沒有勇氣去認同。社會變化太快，我亦唔知將來係点。我只有盡我所能, 提供較好嘅硬件比佢地，方便小朋友係日後行佢自已嘅。
閣下另舉有關电腦及相機嘅例子正係計對現時社會上嘅現象。我亦有同感。但絕對不應堅持。否則會同社會脫節。

mmylau

To Kpw

Wah Yans do not give pressure to their students.  Once the student has no pressure, they will have freedom to choice and room to explore himself.

There is no formula in Wah Yan to train a student to be independent.  But the student can grow up under an "free" environment, then the student can have their own way to think and develope.

Please remember, Wah Yan boys are not all in "same style".  Every Wah Yan boy has their own thinking method and do not receive the training from the school and teacher.  Wah Yan provide a platform.

If you want your son have many training on "thinking method", then please choose another school!!!!

kpw

Interesting.
What platform does Wah Yan provide? " Free environment" really can train up good student?
If that is the case, it is easy for other school to imitate and achieve the "Wah Yan" result. It cost nothing and it is good to any school in the cut budget environment.
I just wonder how can a F1 student to develop their "way to think" without guideline?