in完協恩的感覺，唔係咁好

yy0000

唔知協恩幼稚園係唔係名校，我個日去到無招呼無佈置，
又唔開放d滑梯黎玩下，
我仲以為自己搞錯左日期，
之後老師叫no.好細聲，
人又多喎！
真係唔係個阿嬏叫都唔知叫到自己的時間，
最慘係個厠所，
傷殘人士厠所，
水浸！
哈，我同老公最後都有in
但我同老公都不約而同話可能想像得太好啦！
現在有些失望！
但呢個只係個人意見，
我相信有好多父母覺得無問題！
我相信協恩有名氣是有她的原因，
可能係我察覺唔到姐！
希望有多d人分亨下啦！
我個女就一定無希望呢間啦！
因為她喊，
祝大家好運啦！

溋溋

佢得60個位，全土瓜灣人都去考，一開始已冇諗住考。收生少得太離譜。

sammilcm

我果日in 10:45a.m, 我就覺得安排有問題, 有d老師好冇禮貌, 同冇咩愛心.  因為我個女同老師講早晨同thank you,佢都冇理佢, 而且安排又有D奇怪.  講真可能係我個女冇用啦!!  我同佢講咗好耐話要自己入去, 佢最初都話OK, 但到入去果一剎那, 佢都想喊, 但我比咗D嘢佢拿住佢就肯入去, 但入到去竟然要係走廊到停下來, 比之前果D見完佢地先可以入去, 係個走廊到等下等下, 佢就越來越驚, 跟住重喊.  老師就叫我同佢入課室, 一到行老師就一到同我講"係同佢hi得太多了, 咁佢咪喊囉" (怪責嘅語氣)  但我相信冇人比我更了解我自己個女, 如果當時佢一入去我就走開, 佢一定喊得更行害.  如果學校可以直接同佢入課室, 佢就冇時間唸喊啦.  ANYWAY, 已經過去了.  呀女依個見學校嘅旅程都已經完結了, 現在就只係唸我地最後為佢選擇邊一間.

candykiki123

我都係一樣,interview程序同張便條講有出入,張便條寫話家長同小朋友在一個課室玩4分鐘後由一個先生帶佢地入第二個課室in,完全唔一樣,一去到登記完就要即刻排隊入課室,行一條窄走廊,家長已經唔可以陪,d小朋友梗係唔肯啦  , 我個女就係咁拉住我入埋課室,個先生就叫我走,但見阿女想大喊,個先生先叫我一齊入去,佢地有個鬧鐘計時,入到去我企埋一邊,盡量都等阿女自己一個in,見到兩個先生in四個小朋友, 一個入到去大喊,其餘果三個係到玩玩具,剩係大喊果個都攪左好耐(不受控制),結果佢地兩個先生唔夠時間in其餘果三個小朋友, 個計時器就響,咁就要走...
我覺得好唔公平,未睇清楚每個小朋友就夠鍾,想而之佢地機會好多大 ??

果日都幾失落, 無望啦!!最最心儀既學校in 成咁,可以話阿女in咁多間in得最差既一間

maysiupoon

The notice clearly stated that kids are interviewed for 4 min. without parents' accompany. I think you have misinterpreted the words.

No matter how our kids performed in the interview, we should still believe that they have done their best although we really don't know how the school makes the assessment.

Anyway, good luck to everyone!  
     

原帖由 candykiki123 於 10-2-1 12:58 發表
我都係一樣,interview程序同張便條講有出入,張便條寫話家長同小朋友在一個課室玩4分鐘後由一個先生帶佢地入第二個課室in,完全唔一樣,一去到登記完就要即刻排隊入課室,行一條窄走廊,家長已經唔可以陪,d小朋友梗係唔肯 ...

[ 本帖最後由 maysiupoon 於 10-2-1 13:28 編輯 ]

brian61950

其實都唔駛失望既.
雖然小學是名校,但入左幼稚園都有好多入唔到小學.

linglingng

我 in 30/1, 3:05, 當日真係同果紙條上所寫的唔一樣. 冇4mins playtime 呢. 老師黑口黑面, 唔多有愛心 (可能真係太多人in). 雖然話3:05, 但都要等到差唔多3:30 先到登記. 呀囡初頭都冇喊. 但一見另外小朋友喊佢就即刻喊同要抱. 老師就比一齊入去, 但入到去老師見我個囡喊都只係問咗一條問題. 就係 what your name? 跟住都只係問冇父母帶的小朋友 (叫麥名, 幾多歲) 跟住叫果兩個小朋友去玩. 好快又話攞禮物走得. 好似德望 in 咁, 好兒戲.
祝各位好運.

MitchellDaddy

I've also accompanied my daughter for the interview. I think the logistics can be further improved:

1. Registration and Waiting: It's too crowded in the registration areas and the waiting areas. There are many parents (some families have more than 1 accompanying their children) jamming the corridors. Given there are delay in interviews, I can say that the areas are totally jammed. Worse still, those who have finished interviews did not leave and keep playing in the waiting areas. That's why the environment frightened the children. Actually it is too noisy and crowded. I personally think it is not surprising that some were crying!

2. "Golden 4-minute" : I always wonder how deep and how far teachers can assess a child in a 4-min session. Unless they have a pre-scanned list of accepted student, it is difficult to use the short interview time to select for what they want.  Use your logic to deduce: 2 teachers to assess 4 children in 4 minutes.  Each one can receive at most 2 minutes’ attention, not to mention if there is one crying, then the teacher needs to comfort and use up the attention at the expense of other children!

3. Post-interview administration: some kindergarten will open the school for others to visit (like its classrooms). I would appreciate this can be done. This will also prevent the situation all parents/children are jamming in the waiting areas and corridors. If the kindergarten heads think that they do not have manpower to do this, at least there should be some crowd control to invite those finished interview to leave the areas.

Anyway, that’s my little opinions and I believe every kindergarten has its room for improvements. HY is still one of the most admired kindergartens many parents want their daughters to join (not only for those living in To Kwan Wan). But don’t be too happy even when your daughter is admitted: there is still another round of game to play after 3 years! There is no “through-train” in this school. That’s why GH and PC are sometimes preferred than HY to some parents.

Good luck to everyone!

yy0000

原帖由 candykiki123 於 10-2-1 12:58 發表
我都係一樣,interview程序同張便條講有出入,張便條寫話家長同小朋友在一個課室玩4分鐘後由一個先生帶佢地入第二個課室in,完全唔一樣,一去到登記完就要即刻排隊入課室,行一條窄走廊,家長已經唔可以陪,d小朋友梗係唔肯 ...

你可以跟埋入去就好啦！
我個批家長係出面係咁搵玻璃窗的隙縫位望入去，
你地知啦，個窗根本係遮住晒，
無可能看到(好高的家長除外)

我覺得協恩幼稚園老師無愛心之餘，
唔會主動打招呼，
反而係我個女向老師講早晨先，
我諗如果我個女有幸或不幸入到去讀，
我諗想問多老師幾句，
個女返學返成點都唔會好想答你，
咁我又點放心將個女交俾佢地呀！

希望只係面試的老師先係咁衰啦，
因為呢間話晒都係名校呀，
一定有好多家長對呢間學校有好大期望，
包括我，但我係覺得好失望！

學校安排係有問題，
唔了解小朋友離開父母的不安，
仲要喊緊的小朋友入去in，
影響其他唔喊的小朋友情緒，
應俾d時間父母去安撫下小朋友的情緒，
(我知係好多人等緊，咁學校應該諗到會有咁情況)
成4個小朋友兩位老師根本有一個小朋友唔合作，
老師就無時間去in其他小朋友，
對其他合作的小朋友真係不公平。

我去左幾間幼稚園面試，
間間都有人量體溫，
清潔雙手，但為何呢間無？(可能有d都係無既)
唔知平時返學的協恩學生要唔要量下體溫呢？
定係面試當日，學校真係咁唔得閒咁無人手呀？

希望呢間學校好好咁檢討下啦！
老師唔好再黑面咁對住家長和小朋友，
小朋友離開父母第一個接觸的人就是老師，
你們的態度將會影響小朋友對成人的睇法！

係度希望各位07年的小朋友，
個個都入到心儀的幼稚園啦！

[ 本帖最後由 yy0000 於 10-2-2 00:51 編輯 ]

eggmama

有無現任家長可分享下? 老師如何? 課程如何?

ac917

我在面試那天都碰到幾位朋友，大家同樣帶著女兒緊張面試，可見都很多人對HY有祈禱望，我都想請各現在家長多多給意見。

anntx3

世上真係冇完美的學校，事實上，看了這版，基本上所有名校都有人投訴冇愛心和冇禮貌，令人失望，不公平，...等等。
又有落選的，會指學校只收有$父母、高學歷父母..等等。

你們當天見到的，我很相信是真的。

不過，我自己遇到的老師，都是夠禮和良善，當我女兒出課室，跟老師say bye時，她們也有回應。
事實上，in得短，會被指責求其。in得耐，會被指責等得耐。

老細，收你$20，全港最平，想做死人咩

candykiki123

小朋友個個都仲係好細個,小部份剛好三歲,大部份三歲都未夠,唔係話唔同意小朋友自己單獨入課室in,因家長唔係身邊,老師可以見到佢地既真性情,但始終佢地仲細,有好多時佢地都唔知發生咩事,比人拉左入去in , 雖然之前可能會同小朋友講我地離這度係做d咩野,點解會離這度,但當佢地離到一個陌生既環境時, 佢地一定會有d驚,仲要自己一個,我好欣賞培正,培正都係小朋友自己入課室in,但之前會去一間課室比佢地玩一陣warm up,等佢地無咁驚,亦知學校in 既小朋友會好多,亦要體諒老師當天既辛苦,不過,但求盡左力便算,小朋友入到邊一間學校讀書係一種緣份,最緊要佢地開開心心肯去自發學習

原帖由 yy0000 於 10-2-2 00:45 發表


你可以跟埋入去就好啦！
我個批家長係出面係咁搵玻璃窗的隙縫位望入去，
你地知啦，個窗根本係遮住晒，
無可能看到(好高的家長除外)

我覺得協恩幼稚園老師無愛心之餘，
唔會主動打招呼，
反而係我個女向老師講早晨先，
我諗如果 ...

咕嚕

我都想分享一下, 係room 1 係真係可以係一條好細隙縫位望入去, 係睇到架...
另外, 我又唔覺d 老師好衰喎..
我個女走個陣, 有個企門口既老師仲叫佢個名同佢講byebye.
可能各位家長既 認為衰 既程度 唔同la.

elmolly

原帖由 咕嚕 於 10-2-2 13:19 發表
我都想分享一下, 係room 1 係真係可以係一條好細隙縫位望入去, 係睇到架...
另外, 我又唔覺d 老師好衰喎..
我個女走個陣, 有個企門口既老師仲叫佢個名同佢講byebye.
可能各位家長既 認為衰 既程度 唔同la. ...

oh, 我都係room 1, 不過我見唔到條細隙縫.

我唔會將一次interview就去決定d老師好唔好, 因為我小朋友而家讀緊間n1, interview果陣都覺得d老師唔好, 但真係入左去讀又完全係兩回事. 當然, 做老師既係應該幾時都態度一致, 不過已經唔敢要求咁高, 身邊教書既朋友亦都做唔到.

babychin

[quote]原帖由 咕嚕 於 10-2-2 13:19 發表

我地 IN room 2, 係有一條好細隙縫位望入去, 係睇到架..... 只見小朋友在玩玩具, 之後, 老師在她身邊問野, 之後, 排隊取貼紙....好快出左來了.

我都覺得有少少失望, 地方比較細, 在中學下面只得幾個班房, 不知仲有冇地方係屬於幼稚園的 ??  IN 完後, 反而唔明點解甘出名, 甘多人想入讀 ?  如其他媽咪知道, 請 SHARE 一下.

mayui

in完好失望，感覺真係唔係幾好。老師黑口黑面，我個女叫佢都唔應。如果收都未必讀！

cherylyau_b

我都覺得in得好快.我都未有心理準備,一登記完就入去,好彩個女冇喊,又肯拖住老師行入去... in 完仲好開心咁跳出來.我問佢響班房裡面做咩,佢話玩ABC既puzzles同煮飯仔.我問老師有冇同佢講野,佢話問佢叫咩名,邊個同佢來.我唸4分鐘都係咁上下野了.
點都好喇~~收唔收都唔係重要,最重要係我覺得一個2歲半既小朋友已經好叻了~~
BTW,大家既小朋友都已經好叻了~~
努力呀~~

eggmama

your daughter is very good! can tell & remember what happen!

原帖由 cherylyau_b 於 10-2-2 16:13 發表
我都覺得in得好快.我都未有心理準備,一登記完就入去,好彩個女冇喊,又肯拖住老師行入去... in 完仲好開心咁跳出來.我問佢響班房裡面做咩,佢話玩ABC既puzzles同煮飯仔.我問老師有冇同佢講野,佢話問佢叫咩名,邊個同佢來 ...