華仁定高主教?????

twu_hk

爸爸是華仁舊生, 想個仔入華仁, 但我喜歡高主教(英文小學而中文用普通話教), 請問可否分析一下, 多謝.

yjoan

高主教小學真的不錯,但聽我老公講高主教中學就比小學差很多.長遠沒好處. 我一定選華仁.  

原文章由 twu_hk 於 08-6-24 23:09 發表
爸爸是華仁舊生, 想個仔入華仁, 但我喜歡高主教(英文小學而中文用普通話教), 請問可否分析一下, 多謝.

乳猪媽媽

原文章由 yjoan 於 08-6-25 00:59 發表
高主教小學真的不錯,但聽我老公講高主教中學就比小學差很多.長遠沒好處. 我一定選華仁.  

兩間學校我都有子姪讀, 冇得比兼唔駛諗, 當然華仁喇, 兩個世界.

YMCAkids

Absolutely Wah Yan!!!!!!!!!

No need to think about secondary school no need to pay for 6 yeras of primary and the level is sooooooo different

YMCAkids

Actually U can apply both as one is free and one is private

麟媽媽

我係你會先考高小，有個後著，
你先生係舊生，但係唔係教徒？
因為20分報華仁唔一定收，
如果25分先會收硬，
20分抽中先至煩要邊間啦，
而家少位，20分都好難中呀。

yauyauyanyan

原文章由 twu_hk 於 08-6-24 23:09 發表
爸爸是華仁舊生, 想個仔入華仁, 但我喜歡高主教(英文小學而中文用普通話教), 請問可否分析一下, 多謝.

Sure Wah Yan , is free and have secondary school.....

鳳梨

如果唔係教徒，　可唔可以入會　（唔知有無華仁舊生會呢？），
應該多５分喎

原文章由 麟媽媽 於 08-6-25 15:51 發表
我係你會先考高小，有個後著，
你先生係舊生，但係唔係教徒？
因為20分報華仁唔一定收，
如果25分先會收硬，
20分抽中先至煩要邊間啦，
而家少位，20分都好難中呀。 ...

麟媽媽

只有入天主教會先有多5分，
又或者「番禺旅商會所」都有5分，
因為華仁有兩個辨學團體既。
不過番禺會所點入會？？
我真係唔知，好少見人有。

原文章由 鳳梨 於 08-6-25 16:50 發表
如果唔係教徒，　可唔可以入會　（唔知有無華仁舊生會呢？），
應該多５分喎

bb86

agree!!

原文章由 yauyauyanyan 於 08-6-25 16:39 發表

Sure Wah Yan , is free and have secondary school.....

Freesia_cat

一定揀華仁，因為華仁中學點都好過高主教中學，長遠計點都係華仁好d！

twu_hk

我地有25分, 都諗住希望係第一ROUND入到買保險先.  

其實我本來都唔想多事, 但因為教堂主日學有部份家長同我老公華仁的舊老師都給與了現時華仁的意見 (唔知係真唔係), 令我有少少猶疑 .

而高小係英文小學真係幾吸引, 因為小女升了英文小學一年級後, 英文真係突飛猛進, 佢表哥讀九龍一間出名小學三年級, 全級前50名, 英文90分以上, 但佢的ORAL好差, 今年暑假竟然同我個女讀同一班ORAL班,  所以先引發我咁多問題.

其實我都冇資格發表意見, 因為好多都係聽番來, 如果有得罪希望大家唔好介意.

亦希望有華仁家長比下意見. 多謝.

hei_mother

其實我都有同一疑問，因為華仁係中文小學，除左英文堂之外，其他全部都係用中文教，亦聽聞香港區無九龍區個間咁好，同埋華仁中學只收6成華仁小學學生，有兩班會飛出局，如果唔標青未死火?而高主教小學就好，中學就麻麻地，究竟應該點選好，有冇媽媽仔女係高主教讀小學，到派位時通常係讀邊間中學?唔該晒

yankle

if your son always speaks in English and only know a little Cantonese,  u should choose 高主教.  Otherwise, you may choose Wah Yan because the secondary school is better and boys are well behaved(above P3) & polite & happy.  Their parents are also humble, helpful and nice.  Though the academic level is not very high especially English, it is enough to make boys try to study hard but not too stressful.  I am interested what '教堂主日學有部份家長同我老公華仁的舊老師都給與了現時華仁的意見' you said?  Would you tell us?

yauyauyanyan

原文章由 Freesia_cat 於 08-6-25 18:08 發表
一定揀華仁，因為華仁中學點都好過高主教中學，長遠計點都係華仁好d！

Agree !!

laiheiyau

揀華仁，因為華仁中學....

jackjackma

高主教小學課程深D,老師嚴D,
另外數位朋友囝囝讀緊高主教中學都一致好評.

華仁小學到中學都自由D, 比較適合自侓的小朋友.

楝學校最好以學生能力,性格為主,
只要小朋友每日高高興興去上學便是好學校.

holokmom

原文章由 twu_hk 於 08-6-25 23:48 發表
我地有25分, 都諗住希望係第一ROUND入到買保險先.  

其實我本來都唔想多事, 但因為教堂主日學有部份家長同我老公華仁的舊老師都給與了現時華仁的意見 (唔知係真唔係), 令我有少少猶疑 .

而高小係英文小學真係幾吸 ...

你女兒小一是否指在"高小"讀？
英文小學都要睇學校是否著重Oral，
平時校長訓話、assembly 等是否全用英語.....
本身學生個人吸收和課餘進修等都造成不同效果。

至於中學:
(1)假設讀得唔錯，直上中學，兩間比較，華仁佔優。
(2)假設讀得差，上唔到中學，都是在同一校網派位。(wanchai)
(3)假設讀得很top, 自行揀兩間，出自華小或高小，可能有唔同。

高小在中西區自行揀一間時，top students 去Kings 多。

小天子

Hi,

Strongly agreed to jackjackma.  My son is studying in P1 in Raimondi now and I never consider applying WY though I am a catholic when we choose Primary school last year.  It's because of the English standard in Raimondi and they use Mandarin to teach Chinese Lang.  If your son able to stand in top 20, he will go to Kings or St Joe or even Wan Yan.  I can say that those bright student are not aim at Raimondi Secondary but just treat it as a back up.

From my observation this year, the boys in Raimondi are quite smart.  My son's english also improved a lot because they have some maths exercise in english and 3 text books out of 4 for General Studies are in English.

All you need to consider is whether you son likes / loves English, because they need to learn English prayer and many other topics in English.  

Hope my little comment can help a bit

原文章由 jackjackma 於 08-6-28 11:21 發表
高主教小學課程深D,老師嚴D,
另外數位朋友囝囝讀緊高主教中學都一致好評.

華仁小學到中學都自由D, 比較適合自侓的小朋友.

楝學校最好以學生能力,性格為主,
只要小朋友每日高高興興去上學便是好學校. ...

ratafan

My kid is also in Raimondi. My problem is that there might be too much focus on English.  And before P1, he studied in a non-traditional kindergarten which doesn't place much emphasis to write a lot. My son resists to read Chinese books now but he likes reading English books a lot (there are reading classes every day, and he only brings English books to school and he told me that all his classmates only bring English books to school). Seems that the teachers do not push the kids to read Chinese books.  I have to push him to do quite some Chinese comprehension exercises at home in order to let him learn more vocab.  I actually come across some difficult moments in helping his Chinese...