九龍禮賢學校

ACCC

各位好,
本人想幫女兒選讀禮賢，因聽聞老師很有愛心，請問各位有沒有兒女正在或曾在此校就讀，可否給予一些意見及實况？例：程度如何？教法、是否能照顧到學生學業以外的發展(e.g.社交,強弱處)而加以引導呢？謝謝！

Furbabies

My friend's son studied there and got into LaSalle Middle School.

Heard that students are trained to be well mannered.

sweetmj

請問禮賢和聖芳濟各英文小學您會如何選擇和評價?
有很多朋友都會說一定入聖芳濟各, 但禮賢的老師是很有愛心的.  學費禮賢貴成$500-700有多, 程度應是聖芳濟各深, 讀禮賢是不是表示會讀得comfortable D呢 ? (當然讀那間學校都須要付出的), 好煩, 因禮賢快要2nd registration la !  請給予意見. sweetmj

原文章由 Furbabies 於 08-5-28 18:57 發表
My friend's son studied there and got into LaSalle Middle School.

Heard that students are trained to be well mannered.

Furbabies

Has your child been accepted by both?

I am sure SFA is more demanding academically.  

原文章由 sweetmj 於 08-5-30 10:22 發表
請問禮賢和聖芳濟各英文小學您會如何選擇和評價?
有很多朋友都會說一定入聖芳濟各, 但禮賢的老師是很有愛心的.  學費禮賢貴成$500-700有多, 程度應是聖芳濟各深, 讀禮賢是不是表示會讀得comfortable D呢 ? (當然讀那 ...

SandyWu

原文章由 Furbabies 於 08-5-30 12:19 發表
Has your child been accepted by both?

I am sure SFA is more demanding academically.  

e個case同我囡一樣,我就選左sfa,禮賢first reg已經放棄左,俾其他會讀既小朋友,

ACCC

請問sweetmj 你的小朋友是否09年讀小一呢？以我所知禮賢未開始報名，點解你話快要2nd registtration呢？另外，聖方濟各又是何時開始報名呢?thanks!

sweetmj

我的小朋友是08年9月入學小一的學生, 所以不是chengwaiking您所說的未開始報名.
謝謝sandywu的分享, 我都聽聞SFA是demanding的.  有時會想是否真的要選較top的學校呢 ? 如果SFA和宣道相比又如何 ? 是否距離拉近些 ? 不過有人說APS的中學校網較SFA好, 您們意見如何 ?

SandyWu

原文章由 sweetmj 於 08-5-30 22:53 發表
我的小朋友是08年9月入學小一的學生, 所以不是chengwaiking您所說的未開始報名.
謝謝sandywu的分享, 我都聽聞SFA是demanding的.  有時會想是否真的要選較top的學校呢 ? 如果SFA和宣道相比又如何 ? 是否距離拉近些 ?  ...

SFA同宣道都係好既學校,各有賣點,但我自問無太多時間俾囡囡
practice管弦樂,而且升中既派位都可自行去考同用home
address既NET,唔知我有無理解錯,anyway六年後既教育制度有無改變我就唔敢肯定,而家只想打好囡囡小學既基礎

sweetmj

原文章由 SandyWu 於 08-5-31 12:06 發表



SFA同宣道都係好既學校,各有賣點,但我自問無太多時間俾囡囡
practice管弦樂,而且升中既派位都可自行去考同用home
address既NET,唔知我有無理解錯,anyway六年後既教育制度有無改變我就唔敢肯定,而家只想打好囡囡 ...

SandyWu, thanks for your reply.  
My son learns to play piano for nearly one & a half year and has awarded grade 2 certification.  As I know that piano is not counted to be one of the musical instrument if U studies in APS.  Someone had reminded that school fee together with the expense spend on musical instrument are too high in APS.  Don't U agree ?  I agree that SFA can provide a good basis to the students but it will be a very tired path for both parents and child to finish.  Do U know whether students have to study "Literature" in SFA ?  Which level ? Start from P1 ?  If so, I am worry about this since I've got no idea on this Eng literature.    sweetmj

sweetmj

SandyWu, thanks for your reply.
Do U know whether SFA has to study "literature" ? Start from which level ?
From the booklist, there is no books about Putonghua.  Is just teaching Chinese by Putonghua only ?  
In fact, no matter we study SFA or APS, I think they are also demanding but SFA is more demanding, right ?  If my son cannot adapt to SFA studying environment, it is difficult to change to other school.  But, I agree that SFA can provide a good basis to the students.  / sweetmj

Lauyl

講回禮賢學校啦!

各位認為禮賢派位好嗎?入band 1中學是否一些高質素的學校?

ACCC

我都想知。請問有冇人的兒女是在禮賢讀呢？請分享一吓！

CurrieCheung

我個女依家讀緊禮小二年班....由於要考慮到弟妹升學, 所以最近忙著為她轉校, 希望可以入到好的資助學校...

禮小是一所很好的小學, 老師很好, 好有愛心, 課程其實都幾深架, 測驗都唔少, 係一年班時真係要d時間適應, 特別係英文, 佢哋要每月規定閱讀一本英文故事, 之後要quiz。所以我個女出去考班試, 佢同我講中文卷有d難, 但英文同數學都好容易, 佢考咗兩間資小, 都係噤講囉!!!   

Furbabies

Does that mean that KRS's Chinese standard is less compatible?  Do you mind telling us what 資助學校 your girl have been interviewing?

My friend used to teach at their kindergarten and her comment is also that their teachers are very kind.  That's a very consistent feedback.  

原文章由 CurrieCheung 於 08-6-19 09:27 發表
我個女依家讀緊禮小二年班....由於要考慮到弟妹升學, 所以最近忙著為她轉校, 希望可以入到好的資助學校...

禮小是一所很好的小學, 老師很好, 好有愛心, 課程其實都幾深架, 測驗都唔少, 係一年班時真係要d時間適應,  ...

littleeva

我兒子是禮小一 (9月升小二)


禮賢是一所基督教學校.   學校是很重視信仰.  所以老師們全部都是基督徒.  至於是否全部都是有愛心的老師.  這點每個人的對愛心的準則不同.  個人來說.  "是".


程度的問題. 又真是仁見智. 有同事問我禮賢程度. 我都是這樣答.
個人來說 是 中上. (85-90% 深)  
這一年裡看著仔仔進步不少. 我已經很滿足.  中文禮賢是用普通話教.   而英文堂.  我仔就話老師唔講中文.  <好似加拿大人咁bb 爸爸... >  我覺得如果能備下課才上堂. 會更加好.
常識: 小一上學期是中文 ,  下學期 就有埋 英文 和 中文常識.
(要用英文science 書教 )  這點是我意料之外.  不過都好.  老師教得十分好. 小朋友沒有因為是英文而不喜歡常識. 反之他們是好很歡常識堂.  我覺得唔錯. 禮賢的課程真係安排得幾好.

我都有個細囡, 以前都會諗讀住先啦. 遲下轉校(govt) 妹妹便可跟住入 現在我完全地打消轉校的諗法.

係就係吃力些. 但總不能因為細果個而要"希生" 哥哥.
我相信天父有安排. 我仍然希望妹妹將來入讀禮小.  當然$又是一個問題.  但我不為明天憂慮太多.  將來的事將來再算吧.  
兄妹同一學校當然好,如不 我都唔會放棄哥哥.
惟有花少d $ , 去少d 旅行...... 我好呀 Q.  我會諗妹妹有學券. E D  都係 我大仔讀幼稚園果時無. 現在妹妹將會有.  我心中的計法係  政府資助了我囡囡3年 小學.  (我將學券金額留來小一用LOH!. 係唔係好呀Q)

原文章由 Furbabies 於 08-6-19 09:43 發表
Does that mean that KRS's Chinese standard is less compatible?  Do you mind telling us what 資助學校 your girl have been interviewing?

My friend used to teach at their kindergarten and her comment is ...

CurrieCheung

其實之前我都開咗個topic...

http://forum.baby-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=1439768&extra=page%3D6

唔係個女同我講, 我都唔道出面 d 中文原來係噤深....其實以我後來個人分析, 可能現在出面大部份資小還未完全實行全面已普通話教中文課, 相對學校可能多點時間在中文文句運作, 閱讀理解, 詞彙各方面的教授和練習。 相反, 大部份私小就已推行全面普通話教授中文課, 這樣, 佢哋可能會花多點時間係朗讀課文, 讀音, 發音上。

loy211

我都想仔仔讀禮賢,不過我知幾難入,有d驚仔仔入唔到.
我想幫仔仔報面試班,不過坊間的費用太貴,究竟面試班是否有用?

CurrieCheung

我哋都唔想放棄讀禮賢，不過＄就真係一個問題，除咗學費，仲有校內必收嘅課外活動費，校車費等等。當我有第二個小朋友時，都無諗過唔讀禮賢，不過依家有三個，就真係應付唔離啦！！！我哋都希望天父會為囡囡預備另一所好的資助學校就讀啦！

以我知禮賢依家真係幾難入, 個女有個同級同學，佢媽咪同我講細仔都考唔到入去，其實私校就真係無guarantee 一定收堆細佬妹，真係要睇個人囉。

Furbabies

I know a few friends giving up KRS.  I am sure God will provide

KRS' curriculum is not too demanding comparing with other more 'difficult' schools though.

原文章由 CurrieCheung 於 08-6-19 12:23 發表
我哋都唔想放棄讀禮賢，不過＄就真係一個問題，除咗學費，仲有校內必收嘅課外活動費，校車費等等。當我有第二個小朋友時，都無諗過唔讀禮賢，不過依家有三個，就真係應付唔離啦！！！我哋都希望天父會為囡囡預備另一所好的資助學校就讀啦！
  ...

barry326

Dear Currie,

Can you tell how much the total cost if include all additional charge?