入基督教或天主教好?

broadband

讀小學宗教有5分.我個女歲幾,所以未有心水將來報邊間.我一直都信有天主,只係未入教. 請問為個女我應入基督教或天主教?

baekdoosan

你信天主, 咪入天主教囉, 四歲前可以嬰兒領洗.

MimiCactus

父母是旦一方為教友並要行天主教婚禮, 小朋友先可以四歲前領洗

broadband

我打去教堂問,佢地話係3歲以下.係唔係間間天主教堂唔同?

pooh仔

你可以讀成人"慕道班", 為期1.5年. 然後同小朋友一同受浸.
但夫婦二人要做補禮(即婚配盛事).
因嬰兒領洗要3才前先可以. 如同成人一同領洗可以5才前都得. (其他堂區可能有唔同做法, 要視乎神父決定)

pooh仔

因現時基督教學校(指聖公會)已接受天主教教徒領洗紙的.

kkbbkk

I am not a religious person.

But I can't help saying that religion should be treated as a tool for "schooling", "marriage", etc , in the first place. It can be a tool incidentally only.

bbkingdombb

pooh仔 寫道:
因現時基督教學校(指聖公會)已接受天主教教徒領洗紙的.

is it confirmed in all schools of 聖公會?  :

bbkingdombb

kkbbkk 寫道:
I am not a religious person.

But I can't help saying that religion should be treated as a tool for "schooling", "marriage", etc , in the first place. It can be a tool incidentally only.

Strongly agree!   

kevkev1968

Please put your hands on your heart! Why!

pooh仔

喺唔喺全部聖公會學校都一致咁做, 我唔咁肯定. 因聖公會教會自己說的. 學校跟唔跟就另計.

bbkingdombb 寫道:
[quote]
pooh仔 寫道:
因現時基督教學校(指聖公會)已接受天主教教徒領洗紙的.

is it confirmed in all schools of 聖公會?  : [/quote]

heima

你是因為愛天主先去做天主教徒, 只是信是不夠的

我有朋友係天主教徒, 一樣係入唔到心目中的天主教學校, 即使係有宗教分, 都要抽籤的

leschelems

Naturally, your choice of church for your daugther is the one you are going to.  I don't reckon it's a good idea to compromise your faith.  

broadband 寫道:
讀小學宗教有5分.我個女歲幾,所以未有心水將來報邊間.我一直都信有天主,只係未入教. 請問為個女我應入基督教或天主教?

mattsmum

from newspaper a few monthes ago: 聖公會is considering re-united with chatholic church after separation of 500 years. maybe that is the reason why聖公會已接受天主教教徒領洗紙的.

jovina

如果你覺得宗教信仰係咁用嘅話，咁就兩個教都信喇！       

WAI888

我覺得都無問題,因為根本就係現時教育制度造成

kevkev1968

Yes..I agree.

開開心心

不是經濟唔好或失業, 你就可以去打劫

何謂好的教育制度, 如何派位, 請俾意見

WAI888 寫道:
我覺得都無問題,因為根本就係現時教育制度造成

Lion_King

唉!我真係知有人兩個信仰都信曬, 個女仲自行抽到MCS.

jovina 寫道:
如果你覺得宗教信仰係咁用嘅話，咁就兩個教都信喇！

kevkev1968

其實羅馬教會(天主教會)都承認其他大宗派(聖公會)或正統教會的領洗紙的,但在小一派位的合約是跟前教育署簽訂的,至現在還未重新簽訂,聖公會是已簽訂新條款,因此可以收有效領洗紙的小朋友入學分.