幼童操水班，阿囡呻辛苦，繼續？

eggmama

係12人，4-6歲，已懂2式以上，一星期三天，1.5小時。囡呻辛苦，但游時落力，聽教，不夠信心。應繼續參加操水？

Wishsss

影響發育沒關係，只要能考入名校，便高人一等，前途一片光明，明白嗎？

Glau

細個操得太勁, 會影響發育架.

vinvillalee

游泳不再是強身健體的作用而是為考名校的一種工具。真是本末倒置

reei

it's impressive that she can swim so well at this age, but if she doesnt enjoy it anymore, why not quit? most important is, she already knows how to swim.

vet

原帖由 ysnmama 於 12-07-25 發表
想問小一後還讓她如此操水嗎？小一開始，更多事情要兼顧。幼稚園階段已經辛苦。不如早早下決定，讓游泳當強 ...

可憐，就像馬戲團的小動物一樣！

ysnmama

想問小一後還讓她如此操水嗎？小一開始，更多事情要兼顧。幼稚園階段已經辛苦。不如早早下決定，讓游泳當強身便足夠。不用一定要每星期操三天。還有，有時家長就放𣎴下一些虛名，泳會泳隊一句，你小孩很有潛質，可以操的。就不理時間同小孩感受。

SCKnight

最緊要小朋友開心，如果佢唔鍾意，咪弄巧反拙！

pooh仔

奌解要個咁細嘅小朋友去操水呀？！
我仔8、9才時一星期兩三日有時都嗌，而家11才就慣嗱！

mw7183

大個之後會好大件,同好橫.根本唔應該咁操水.游水系自救唔好咁迫小朋友.真系慘.

yuetmama

As parents, perhaps we need to re-consider what we are aiming to ask a 4-6 years kid to 操水.  To swim faster to win in swimming competition for primary school application?  To make our kids healthier?  To do more exercise?  Once we know what we are target for (of course not sure if it will be good to kids), we should know how to do.

Personally thinking, 1.5 hr 操水 & three times a week are pretty tough for a kid below 6.

jollyma

eggmama 發表於 12-7-3 19:42
係12人，4-6歲，已懂2式以上，一星期三天，1.5小時。囡呻辛苦，但游時落力，聽教，不夠信心。應繼續參加操 ...

幼稚園冇理由咁樣操法, 以為大陸先會發生, 佢咁細個跟本未意識到自己頂唔頂到

healthybaby

好恐怖! 咁細個就操水,我真係第一次聽!

SAGO

eggmama

Thx for all opinion, I have realized my girl getting progress and building up much more confidence. She is a bit tired but healthy, we may adjust lesson Plan after summer vacation. I believe I won't kill my angel.

lojo11

識游就可以.. 睇下自己想個囡去到咩程度...

mandy304

其實水可以照游, 同小朋友傾下如辛苦, 不如一周練一天, 如小朋友接受, 咁咪兩全其美羅.

Bonnie

原帖由 mandy304 於 12-07-07 發表
當佢覺得游水再不是享受時, 佢細個就話聽你點. 到小學四五年級, 佢開始懂咩叫自主權時,  佢會反抗, 甚至產 ...

Agreed ! 我發覺現今嘅父母都幾享受見到小朋友唔開心！小朋友嘅童年去咗邊？唔通真係要全花在學術上？什麼要贏在起跑線！簡直戇居！

mandy304

當佢覺得游水再不是享受時, 佢細個就話聽你點. 到小學四五年級, 佢開始懂咩叫自主權時,  佢會反抗, 甚至產生對游水抗拒, 到時只會得不償失.   你多年的心血只會毁於一旦, 後悔莫及了.