男拔 VS 英華

EKSon

如果大家有呢兩間 OFFER, 請問會選擇邊間?

ANChan59

我記得第一次DBS新生家長日，當時校長張灼祥先放一段video，題目係”Good boys, bad boys, are DBS boys。

他跟住解釋坊間形容好成績才是好學生，讀書唔叻，運動叻，音樂叻，寫作叻，數學叻⋯的不是好學生，不過在DBS，都係好學生。

我同意之前有家長講過，學校過往什麼公開試成績，跟兒子選擇入讀冇乜必然關係。反而我會要求兒子中上成績，然後盡量去玩多啲，識多啲人，擴闊視野，無謂嘥咗個位。

小黃豆B

73662710 發表於 25-1-17 11:06
英文有4有5會聽唔明課？每年靠死背考tofle入美英本科碩士的內地人, 難道也聽唔明書！

大學收得, 就是認可 ...

其實情況有少少唔同，雖然學費一樣，但香港人用DSE考內地大學是另一計劃，並沒有佔用內地高考生的名額。而且內地大學第一年係數理生化咩都要讀，我兒子在其中一間C9就讀，同樣的科目比他中學同學在三大所讀的深好多，假如DSE都搞唔掂就算執漏上到好的大學都好大機會掛科，我們亦聽過有案例係內地大學讀唔掂要退學。
至於有人用高才通鑽空子用本地生身份入大學，我都贊成要設例，例如假如無永久居民身份證，就要有本地認可中學入學證明，先可以走本地生既途徑。其實內地DSE收生計劃，一樣要求有回鄉證（香港永久居民），唔係有身份證考完DSE就可以申請。

Joe8889

回覆 Poyau 的帖子

英國醫科申請學生要先考試，cut-off 比本地生高唔少。
之後面試再cut，post interview rate 可以低到20%

過到先攞到CO，但頭2關已踢走好多人。

ANChan59

UCAT 會不會篩走不少人，所以無機會面試？

Poyau

猴子爸 發表於 25-1-23 11:13
所有考生都要面试？请问面试占比多少，还是起了收还是不收的作用？
英国大学比较看重考生跟报读学科相关的 ...

英國大學 達成績門檻 比併面試
例如港大中大醫科4A* 牛劍可不用3A*
劍僑醫科2018/19/23年18%無3A*

Oxford
https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/courses/admission-requirements/admission-requirements-table

Medicine
https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/courses/course-listing/medicine

Course overview

UCAS code: A100
Entrance requirements: A*AA (excluding Critical Thinking and Thinking Skills)
Course duration: 3 years (BA); 6 years (BM BCh)

Subject requirements

Required subjects: Chemistry with either Maths, Further Maths, Biology or Physics.
Recommended subjects: Not applicable
Helpful subjects: Not applicable

Other course requirements

Admissions tests: UCAT
Written Work: None

Admissions statistics*

Interviewed: 23%
Successful: 8%
Intake: 149
*3-year average 2021-23

Contact

Email: [email protected]

Cambridge
https://www.undergraduate.study.cam.ac.uk/courses

Medicine
https://www.undergraduate.study.cam.ac.uk/courses/medicine-mb-bchir

Minimum offer level

A level: A*A*A
IB: 41-42 points, with 776 at Higher Level

······

Subject requirements

To apply to most of our Colleges for Medicine, you will need A level/IB Higher Level or the equivalent in:

Chemistry2 other science or mathematics subjects from:MathematicsBiology or Human BiologyPhysicsFurther Mathematics

You will usually need A*/7 in Chemistry and another science or mathematics subject.

······

What Medicine students have studied 

Most Medicine students (who had studied A levels and started at Cambridge in 2018, 2019 and 2023) achieved at least A*A*A* (82% of entrants).

The majority of IB students achieved at least 44 points overall and/or grades 777 at Higher Level. 

All A level entrants had studied Chemistry and almost all had studied at least two of: 

Biology
Further Mathematics
Mathematics 
Physics

Check our advice on choosing your high school subjects. You should also check if there are any required subjects for your course when you apply.

······

Admissions test

You will need to take the University Clinical Aptitude Test.

You will need to register in advance for this test.

Applicants to A100

For UCAT results, we will look at an applicant’s overall cognitive subtest score. We will not be using the situational judgement score as part of our assessment for 2025 entry.

We will use results as part of our selection for interview and when making offers. We will consider your results alongside all the other information we know about you.

Visit our UCAT page for more information.

KikiDaddy

回覆 猴子爸 的帖子

My nephew applied Maths and Statistics of Oxford many years ago. He attended the interview and he told me didn't perform well and ended up with no offer. He did well in DSE with 5 x 5** and study at a local university.

My younger cousin applied the GBus of LSE and performed very well in the interview. She received a conditional offer relatively easy to achieve. She got 2 x 5** in DSE and then go to study at LSE.

My son's classmate applied a G5 university and performed OK in the interview. He received a conditional offer with strict requirements. His DSE results cannot meet the requirements and study at a local university eventually.

My son did not apply any UK university so I don't have further detailed information to share.

猴子爸

KikiDaddy 發表於 25-1-22 16:15
回覆 猴子爸 的帖子

Interview is also important for UK top universities.

所有考生都要面试？请问面试占比多少，还是起了收还是不收的作用？
英国大学比较看重考生跟报读学科相关的能力是否够强，而不看重全人发展，对吗？

KikiDaddy

回覆 猴子爸 的帖子

Interview is also important for UK top universities.

twhkleung

埋到有幾個points吸引左我注意.
1. 高考生係叻过HK DSE生, 重要係好多果隻.
2. 大學应该收成绩好的学生, 而唔需理係咪(non)domestic student.
3. 中或英考DSE係咪同样公平.
4. 高考式操練係叻过d乜乜愉快學習.

73662710

dodotin0505 發表於 25-1-20 00:01
仲要全部都係一年級直上的

咁又唔一定, 年年有級頭插班！包括來自英華！

dodotin0505

nhi 發表於 25-1-15 13:26
朋友仔仔grade 6直升入最勁個班, 話外來生只有几個人！ 所以db本身勁人己經好多, 有條件收多啲運動尖子.
DB ...

仲要全部都係一年級直上的

Sing13

mcl233 發表於 25-1-17 18:44
人地學校IFY 100% 有20大offer, 你質疑冇睇過咁有趣，牛劍咪20大囉～～～

人哋學校直接銜接英國名中，學生實力加家長財力，邊使開海外課程，冇興趣同你摘星玩DSE。

mcl233

bettyay 發表於 25-1-17 14:56
其實你有冇睇過深國交的教育方向？牛劍offer係咪單靠成績同錢就有offer? 不如你睇吓先回來告訴大家～

...

人地學校IFY 100% 有20大offer, 你質疑冇睇過咁有趣，牛劍咪20大囉～～～

bettyay

Sing13 發表於 25-1-17 13:07
最多牛劍offer既應該是深國交。
亦同學生成績，家長財力有關。

其實你有冇睇過深國交的教育方向？牛劍offer係咪單靠成績同錢就有offer? 不如你睇吓先回來告訴大家～

73662710

Sing13 發表於 25-1-17 14:00
所以內地香港入牛劍比美國名校多，美國名校搞咁多評審標準，就是等你不著邊際，人哋大學是私校，你將來會 ...

搞咁多不著邊際就是可以明正言順地歧視.
單靠成績亞裔一定贏晒！

https://m.sohu.com/a/838648264_121124316/?pvid=000115_3w_a

猴子爸

Sing13 發表於 25-1-17 14:00
所以內地香港入牛劍比美國名校多，美國名校搞咁多評審標準，就是等你不著邊際，人哋大學是私校，你將來會 ...

摘星学生可能也不一定入香港的大学，英国大学可能更吸引。
说到底，分数分数分数。。。

香港学生 ，看着办吧。

Sing13

猴子爸 發表於 25-1-17 13:10
英国大学似乎也不太在乎ECA的，好像也是分数为王。

所以內地香港入牛劍比美國名校多，美國名校搞咁多評審標準，就是等你不著邊際，人哋大學是私校，你將來會唔會捐錢俾學校？唔是比學生，就是比家長。

猴子爸

Sing13 發表於 25-1-17 13:07
最多牛劍offer既應該是深國交。
亦同學生成績，家長財力有關。

英国大学似乎也不太在乎ECA的，好像也是分数为王。

Sing13

猴子爸 發表於 25-1-17 12:57
外国学校重视分数之余，很重视leadership， teamwork ability, personal goal 等等，当然，这些是需要用钱 ...

最多牛劍offer既應該是深國交。
亦同學生成績，家長財力有關。