West Buckland School vs Malvern St James

xin0420

Hi大大們話說小妹非常好彩 收到呢兩間學校既sixth form offer
喺度糾結緊讀邊間好
雖則頭先見到有個post講MSJ唔好既嘢 同埋mumsnet都見到有人話除非你係唔會挑戰老師權威既人 如果唔係千祈唔好讀（其實我係interview個時已經有講過我係會挑戰老師既人）
不過佢有多d我鍾意讀既科 個時佢哋提到我有一科考得麻麻 我當時唔記得問大概即係差成點 email問番 佢哋冇答
反而WBS冇乜負面既意見 但係D科我唔係最鍾意讀
其實我係個個講MSJ既po見到 話宜家仲收生既學校肯定有d問題啦（意思大概係咁） 我都想知大家對呢樣既睇法 始終比咁多錢 香港個間學校又唔算好差（1A）媽咪見到個個po同埋個cm 就話覺得宜家既學校唔會有咁既問題 個個老師都好好（呢個我認同 但係我係香港繼續讀真心會癲）
我想知大大們對兩間學校（主要係WBS）有咩睇法同見解（作為八卦的人 如果有埋rumors可以聽就好了）
希望大家可以比d建議我啦 真係thank you soooooo much！！！

Poyau

xin0420 發表於 22-7-5 00:27
thank you!!!我想問對於millfield同埋oakham呢兩間你點睇呀

Welcome
成績 Oakham > Millfield
寄宿 Millfield > Oakham

Oakham School
https://www.oakham.rutland.sch.uk/academic/examination-results/

2022 Results

Overall 57% of all exams taken (at A-level, BTEC, Pre-U or in the IB Diploma) were awarded A* or A grades or equivalent.

A-level/ Pre-U/ BTEC:

 A*/A grades: 55%

 A*-B grades: 76%

Overall pass rate of 99%

15 pupils achieved straight A*/A grades

IB Diploma:

Average point score: 35.5 (compared with the worldwide average of 30)

More than a third of pupils (35%) achieved 38 or more points (equivalent to 3 A*s at A-level)

One pupil achieved full marks (45 out of 45) putting them in the top 1% of students worldwide

A*/A grades equivalent (7-6): 67%

A*-B grades equivalent (7-5): 91%

GCSE:

A*/A/9-7: 58%

A*-B/9-6: 78%

A*-C/9-4: 97%

https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/rutland/oakham/oakham-school/

Religious affiliation: Church of England

Day/boarding type: Day, Weekly/Flexible Boarding and Full Boarding
Gender profile: Coeducational
Size: 1016

Oakham School fees:

Boarding fees per term:
£7,910 to £13,550
Day fees per term:
£6,580 to £8,140
Scholarships & bursaries:
Available

ISC reference number:
40368
DfE reference number:
857 / 6000

Boys - age range & pupil numbers:
Day: 10 to 18 (270)
Boarding: 10 to 18 (271)
Sixth form: (191)

Girls - age range & pupil numbers:
Day: 10 to 18 (255)
Boarding: 10 to 18 (220)
Sixth form: (177)

Millfield School
https://www.millfieldschool.com/sixth-form-16-18/academic/results

A level Results 2022 
A*-A grade 38.6%
A*-B grade 66.2%
A*-C grade 84.9%
A*-E grade 99%

https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/somerset/street/millfield-school/

Religious affiliation: All Faiths

Day/boarding type: Day and Full Boarding
Gender profile: Coeducational
Size: 1291

Millfield School fees:

Boarding fees per term:
£13,785
Day fees per term:
£9,055
Scholarships & bursaries:
Available

ISC reference number:
94949
DfE reference number:
933 / 6022

Boys - age range & pupil numbers:
Day: 13 to 18 (184)
Boarding: 13 to 18 (552)
Sixth form: (332)

Girls - age range & pupil numbers:
Day: 13 to 18 (148)
Boarding: 13 to 18 (407)
Sixth form: (273)

sleung2020

964000 發表於 22-7-5 07:54
本帖最後由 964000 於 22-7-5 07:55 編輯

你讀緊band 1A, 冇理由過英國就求其搵間讀，始終最後兩年要準 ...

嚴重認同

964000

xin0420 發表於 22-7-5 00:25
因為想讀自己鍾意既科 同埋有番校園生活 見識下世界

你讀緊band 1A, 但過英國就求其搵間讀，始終最後兩年要準備公開試，不容有失。
你不如睇吓香港有A level的學校，成績隨時好過你以上求其搵一間, 如果你成績不錯可考慮Kellet/Harrow，都好多科可以揀, Harrow有politics讀，還有寄宿，另一科想讀的是甚麼？想見識世界大學出外讀也可。

964000

Poyau 發表於 22-7-3 17:33
突飛猛進神校有不少......

https://www.best-schools.co.uk/uk-school-league-tables/list-of-league-tab ...

舊年well known grade inflation, 靠校內試評分，個個大派A*, 朋友boarding school返咗香港要zoom考，佢話跟本好多人出貓

sleung2020

xin0420 發表於 22-7-5 00:25
因為想讀自己鍾意既科 同埋有番校園生活 見識下世界

6th form忙a level，唔會有好多時間做第二啲嘢，你而家揾嗰啲又係二三流學校，有啲無謂

xin0420

Poyau 發表於 22-7-4 20:27
表中各校可考慮 d'Overbroeck's
兩間女校亦可諗吓
成績低於平均 寄宿比例太低 三思

thank you!!!我想問對於millfield同埋oakham呢兩間你點睇呀

xin0420

sleung2020 發表於 22-7-4 18:43
點解想去讀6th form？

因為想讀自己鍾意既科 同埋有番校園生活 見識下世界

Poyau

xin0420 發表於 22-7-4 16:26
hello大大們話說我呢兩日篩咗個list
得出以下既名單
唔知大大們會唔會覺得有問題 可以麻煩你地幫我睇睇嗎  ...

表中各校可考慮 d'Overbroeck's
兩間女校亦可諗吓
成績低於平均 寄宿比例太低 三思

embley
DfE A level APS (Grade)
2019 36.90(B-)
2018 31.95(C+)
2017 29.95(C)
Boarding 7.47%(41/549)^
Sixth form 65
^ Incl. prep. Boarding from 11
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/hampshire/romsey/embley/

chase grammar
DfE A level APS (Grade)
2019 29.38(C)
2018 32.64(C+)
2017 31.8(C+)
Boarding 3.05%(5/164)^
Sixth form 25
^ Incl. prep. Boarding from 10
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/staffordshire/cannock/chase-grammar-school/

doverbroecks
DfE A level APS (Grade)
2019 44.16(B+)
2018 44.78(B+)
2017 45.04(A-)
Boarding 40.63%(284/699)
Sixth form 383
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/oxfordshire/oxford/doverbroecks/

farlington
DfE A level APS (Grade)
2019 42.39(B+)
2018 44.69(B+)
2017 33.26(C+)
Boarding 10.19%(32/314)^
Sixth form 31
^ Incl. prep. Boarding from 11
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/sussex-west/horsham/farlington-school/

millfield
DfE A level APS (Grade)
2019 35.33(B-)
2018 35.11(B-)
2017 33.86(C+)
Boarding 74.28%(959/1,291)^^
Sixth form 605
^^ Full boarding. No Weekly/Flexi
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/somerset/street/millfield-school/

Oakham
DfE A level APS (Grade)
2019 39.08(B)
2018 37.63(B-)
2017 39.42(B)
Boarding 50.19%(526/1,048)
Sixth form 368
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/rutland/oakham/oakham-school/

oratory
DfE A level APS (Grade)
2019 32.54(C+)
2018 37.54(B-)
2017 32.42(C+)
Boarding 38.83%(139/358)
Sixth form 96
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/oxfordshire/reading/the-oratory-school/

queen Anne
DfE A level APS (Grade)
2019 40.62(B)
2018 40.66(B)
2017 39.26(B)
Boarding 47.56%(195/410)
Sixth form 101
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/berkshire/reading/queen-annes-school-caversham/

sherfield
DfE A level APS (Grade)
2019 36.97(B-)
2018 29.21(C)
2017 35.61(B-)
Boarding 8.85%(47/531)^
Sixth form 49
^ Incl. prep. Boarding from 9
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/hampshire/hook/sherfield-school/

royal high school bath
DfE A level APS (Grade)
2019 41.07(B)
2018 41.71(B+)
2017 41.72(B+)
Boarding 16.14%(92/570)^
Sixth form 121
^ Incl.prep. Boarding from 10
https://www.isc.co.uk/schools/england/somerset/bath/royal-high-school-bath-gdst/

sleung2020

xin0420 發表於 22-7-4 16:26
hello大大們話說我呢兩日篩咗個list
得出以下既名單
唔知大大們會唔會覺得有問題 可以麻煩你地幫我睇睇嗎  ...

點解想去讀6th form？

xin0420

hello大大們話說我呢兩日篩咗個list
得出以下既名單
唔知大大們會唔會覺得有問題 可以麻煩你地幫我睇睇嗎 等我可以參考下有d我唔敢肯定佢哋既成績 不過照寫埋先啦
embley
chase grammar
doverbroecks
farlington
millfield
Oakham
oratory
queen Anne
sherfield
royal high school bath

Poyau

sleung2020 發表於 22-7-3 14:10
就係有啲學校2020年嗰時唔敢太離譜，但成績出嚟，見到有學校進步神速，覺得自己蝕底咗，咁2021年咪自己都 ...

突飛猛進神校有不少......

https://www.best-schools.co.uk/uk-school-league-tables/list-of-league-tables/girls-boarding-schools

Girls' Boarding Schools by A Levels and Pre U

2021 Results | DfE 2019 AL APS

# A+A* Name | APS (Grade)
1. 93.9 Wycombe Abbey | 50.72 (A)
2. 90.3 Woldingham | 42.04 (B+)
3. 88.6 St Swithun's | 45.65 (A-)
4. 88 St Mary's Ascot | 51.37 (A)
5. 85 St Cat.'s Bramley | 46.86 (A-)

= 85 Downe House | 45.73 (A-)
7. 84.3 CLC. | 48.97 (A)
8. 83 Benenden School | 43.78 (B+)
→ 81.8 Roedean School | 45.07 (A-)
9. 81 St Mary's Cambridge | 42.47 (B+)

10. 79 BSG | 40.15 (B)
= 79 Badminton School | 45.26 (A-)
= 79 Mayfield School | 44.51(B+)
13. 78 St Francis' College | 40.71 (B)
= 78 Queen Margaret's York | 40.26 (B)

15. 77.5 St George's Ascot | 36.85 (B-)
16. 77.2 Rye St Antony | 27.97 (C-)
17. 76.1 Headington | 43.46 (B+)
18. 75 MSJ Girls' | 40.52 (B)
19. 74.8 Sherborne Girls | 42.51 (B+)

→ 74 Burgess Hill Girls | 43.39 (B+)
→ 74 Truro High | 35.28 (B-)
→ 73.5 Adcote School | 38.21 (B-)
20. 73.3 Tudor Hall | 41.45 (B)
21. 72.5 RHS Bath | 41.07 (B)

22. 72 Queen Anne's | 40.62 (B)
23. [70] Moreton Hall | 41.62 (B+)
→ 69.7 Wychwood | 32.08 (C+)
24. 69 Harrogate Ladies' | 36.99 (B-)
25. 67.8 Queenswood | 35.61 (B-)

→ 67.3 Talbot Heath | 40.27 (B)
→ 67 Cobham Hall | [37.63 (B-)]^^
→ 67 The Mount York | 37.16 (B-)
26. 65.8 Monmouth School for Girls
27. 65 Heathfield School | 39.89 (B)

28. 64 Royal Masonic | 36.07 (B-)
→ [62] St Teresa's | 37.76 (B-)
→ 61 Kent College Pembury | 38.81 (B)
→ 59 Thornton College | 31.22 (C+)
29. 56 Godolphin School. | 40.07 (B)

^ St Mary's Calne TAG not released
^^ IB results. AL from 2020
^^^ Prior's Field A* 39% | 37.61 (B-)

tsechris

英國人會覆得慢，找agents 代問

xin0420

tsechris 發表於 22-7-3 14:35
其實WBS 校風唔錯，同學相處也很好，只是較遠離市區，學術成績中上

但係佢哋學校個份接受offer之後填既申請書 寫到好似欠條咁 退學都唔俾 要搵到人攝個位先可以退 如果唔係要一路交學費（雖則唔知係唔係間間都係咁）同埋問咗佢好多次幾時揀科 定係已經安排好 佢都唔答

tsechris

xin0420 發表於 22-7-2 18:01
我以為呢兩間都唔錯 所以覺得好彩

其實WBS 校風唔錯，同學相處也很好，只是較遠離市區，學術成績中上

sleung2020

xin0420 發表於 22-7-3 13:05
但係20有比tag啊我唔係想讀 只係覺得好神奇 所以一直問

就係有啲學校2020年嗰時唔敢太離譜，但成績出嚟，見到有學校進步神速，覺得自己蝕底咗，咁2021年咪自己都突飛猛進咗囉

xin0420

回覆 karanica 的帖子


BTW pmed！

xin0420

cfs 發表於 22-7-3 10:53
因為2020無考公開試疫情呀,你想睇成績就睇2018同2019.去讀Sixth唔好考慮Abbotsholme喇.再搵啦. ...

但係20有比tag啊我唔係想讀 只係覺得好神奇 所以一直問

karanica

sleung2020 發表於 22-7-3 06:37
oxford私校唔少家長本身都係phd，如果學校一個phd都冇，應該難捱

     

攪到我都想讀番個phd!

Poyau

ElaiUKStudy 發表於 22-7-2 18:31
個list有幾多成真呢？幾驚呀連Concord College, Caterham college etc 仲有位。

十二月的時候，個agent比 ...

學校可能有位 想收水平較高嘅學生
最後召集後才 Call waiting list
類似本地升中叩門 難度高於自行