ESF沙田小學vs畢架山小學

dorisho0409

請問有沒有現時就讀 沙田小學 及 畢架山小學的家長，可以分享中文課的學術情況？ 功課多唔多？ 多唔多出去補中文？

Luvhk628

回覆 cherry1126 的帖子

多謝你提醒！ 咁請問IS/KGV/SC, 呢3間，有咩評價？邊間好呢？

Saboc

回覆 Nottcivil 的帖子

其實好多人都答咗無乜大分別

cherry1126

hilary_tang 發表於 21-9-3 21:08
Would you know whether from next year's Year 1 onwards whether exceptions can be made for this assoc ...

ESF is committed to keeping families together.  Students in BHS who have older siblings in another ESF secondary school which is out of zone or not Island school will be able to attend their sibling’s secondary school.

yankiyan

cherry1126 發表於 21-9-3 18:24
今日更新咗8/2022年YR1才生效

Oh.. thank you so much!

cherry1126

yankiyan 發表於 21-9-3 18:21
唔係得今年yr 6先可以照揀catchment zone，下年yr6都一定要上IS咩
我以為只括免今年yr6
...

今日更新咗8/2022年YR1才生效

yankiyan

Nottcivil 發表於 21-9-3 17:06
BHS 2022 year 1 入學開始計，到year 7 入中學就一定係island school, 唔睇地址。 sibling可以跟哥哥姐姐果 ...

唔係得今年yr 6先可以照揀catchment zone，下年yr6都一定要上IS咩
我以為只括免今年yr6

Nottcivil

BHS 2022 year 1 入學開始計，到year 7 入中學就一定係island school, 唔睇地址。 sibling可以跟哥哥姐姐果間唔使一定入island school, 今年入year 1 仲可以跟catchment zone 到 year 7 時揀其他中學 （KGV, SC)

Nottcivil

我2個小朋友一個讀BHS,一個讀SJS. 2間其實差唔多，我諗大部分ESF foundation primary school 分別都唔大。都係happy school 無功課，最多都係借學校library書返屋企讀。我建議係揀近屋企果間讀。

cherry1126

yankiyan 發表於 21-9-2 21:04
So Now it belongs to STC
But TW primary catchment zone is BHS, so they need to go IS since next ye ...

Understand that the new Year 1 cohort of August 2022 will be the first group that will move as a cohort to Island School and will not be allocated by zone. Existing students will have the choice to opt out of the Island school association if they wish or to attend their school of zone based on their residential address.

yankiyan

hilary_tang 發表於 21-9-2 18:28
I see, sorry, perhaps I was mistaken. I guess Tsuen Wan is the exception in this case.
That's very c ...

Yes agree
Thanks for your explanation

yankiyan

cherry1126 發表於 21-9-2 18:19
Tsuen Wan (to the east of KCR West Rail) belonged to STC, others belonged to IS

So Now it belongs to STC
But TW primary catchment zone is BHS, so they need to go IS since next year due to the new policy
Am i right?
So confusing..thank you

cherry1126

yankiyan 發表於 21-9-2 16:51
Thank you for your information.
it seems that the catchment zone information on ESF website is not  ...

Tsuen Wan (to the east of KCR West Rail) belonged to STC, others belonged to IS

yankiyan

hilary_tang 發表於 21-9-2 16:04
Actually by school zone, residential address assigned to BHS has now also been changed to under Isl ...

Thank you for your information.
it seems that the catchment zone information on ESF website is not the most updated versioneg Students who live in Tw need to go Island School now instead of STC.

Island School (Secondary)

Discovery Bay (shared with West Island School)*, Mid Levels (including Kennedy Road west of the Hopewell Centre), Old Peak Road, Conduit Road, Robinson Road as far as Castle Road, some of Central District served by Glenealy School and the Peak. Tsing Yi Island. West Kowloon bordered by Ferry Street and Tong Mi Road to Lai Chi Kok Road, north of Boundary Street and west of Tai Po Road, extending west to Tuen Mun except for the area of Tsuen Wan that is part of Sha Tin College zone (see Sha Tin College).

Beacon Hill School (Primary)

The west side of Nathan Road from Tsim Sha Tsui to Boundary Street excluding areas south-west of Cherry Street and Ferry Street (except The Hermitage), the area north of Boundary Street, including Kowloon Tong and Caldecott Road. Extending westward along the Lung Cheung Highway including Tsuen Wan and Tuen Mun.

yankiyan

愚傑 發表於 21-9-2 15:06
本身已經小學，但唔諗住咁上中學既家長咪中曬伏

係囉
如果讀緊BHS Yr5,原本跟地址可能係去STC/KGV
無啦啦要去IS真係頭都大

愚傑

本身已經小學，但唔諗住咁上中學既家長咪中曬伏

cherry1126

yankiyan 發表於 21-9-2 12:00
明明KGV同STC都近好多

自我安慰下IS 係新校舍因為我無得㨂無論地區定直屬都係呢間，都要照讀