CKY vs SPB

Leungmay_ling

感恩有呢兩間學校offer，兩間都係好好學校，DSE vs IB，傳統vs 新派

普通雙職家庭，小兒性格活潑、愛表達、中英文都平均，會主動做功課，請教過學校老師，話小朋友傳統/IB 課程相信都能應付到，只是看看父母期望而已

想請教大家，如日後無打算離港升學，係咪應該揀SPB 會較適合？感謝(emoji)(emoji)

Ann201403

唔敢講CKY for sure! 因未讀過SPB

b3410

Awyleung 發表於 21-3-22 13:18
IB is costly but I think SPB vs CKY should be a matter HKDSE vs IB as both are consider good schools ...

can't agree more

Awyleung

IB is costly but I think SPB vs CKY should be a matter HKDSE vs IB as both are consider good schools in their curriculum .

臭屁股

I would definitely pick Spb over Cky !

Kaytechan

回覆 Ann201403 的帖子

Thank you for sharing the reliable information issued by the government . While the info is a bit outdated may not reflect the actual situation, I think those parents who are interested in IB and would like to know more about the recent university placement of IB candidates at the designated websites of their preferred universities.

Ann201403

Kaytechan 發表於 21-3-22 08:24
回覆 Ann201403 的帖子

Of course, if one is targeting competitive degrees in HOng Kong local univers ...

參考埋呢個表會較客觀。雖然不是最update, 但競爭近年應是更激烈。

https://gia.info.gov.hk/general/201807/04/P2018070400714_287505_1_1530701707791.pdf

Kaytechan

回覆 Ann201403 的帖子

Of course, if one is targeting competitive degrees in HOng Kong local universities such as Medicine, Law , IB scores over 42-44 are required in recent years. If one is just targeting to get admitted to HKU, I think IB score of over 35 should suffice.
For additional reference for the admission figures in previous years
https://aal.hku.hk/sites/default/files/admissions%20standards191031a.pdf

Ann201403

Kaytechan 發表於 21-3-21 22:15
回覆 Ann201403 的帖子

Yes and students with IB score over 35 can mostly be admitted to a lot of sub ...

35分我覺得只可簡三大不太熱門科目，但39-36分range ，又可以多d選擇。

Kaytechan

回覆 Ann201403 的帖子

Yes and students with IB score over 35 can mostly be admitted to a lot of subjects in the top 3 local universities in HK( HKU , CU and UST) according to the university admission history in recent years .

Ann201403

bearbearhome 發表於 21-3-21 20:41
我覺得兩款唔同教學模式，冇話邊間一定特別高級。論升學成績就cky better, 但如果喜愛傳統教學的穩陣咁就sp ...

http://cky.edu.hk/academics/ibdp/ibdp-results-2020/

Agree!
CKY Over 40 is 61.9% and over 35 is 89.1%

Poyau

baoyeah2014 發表於 21-3-21 15:39
請問可唔可以分享點解？多謝你

SPC 近年DSE成績進步中
2020年男校排第2 同皇仁差不多
第1屆IAL成績非常亮麗 A/A*過9成

2020年 皇仁 | SPC | LSC
主科5+ 42.5% 41.1% 39.8%
整體5+ 47.1% 46.7% 46%

IAL
考生18人 1人考5科 假設其餘考4科
A*/A ≥90.4% [(52+14)/(5×1+4×17)]

https://www.facebook.com/spceduhk/posts/1213808555658032

2019-2020 marks the first graduating class of the GCE IAL stream of students. We are pleased to report that our students performed well and gained enviable assessments in their calculated grades.

The highest accolades go to the Form 6F IAL A2 students, who gained a total of 52 A* Grades and 14 A Grades. 50% of the students achieved A*, the highest grade, in four subjects. One student studied five subjects and obtained A* in all five subjects that he did. An overwhelming majority of the remaining students obtained A* in one to two subjects. 100% of the students who studied Chemistry and those who studied Further Mathematics achieved A* or A. The Form 5F IAS Class (where the highest possible grade is ‘A’) gained 32 A Grades. In addition, the Form 4F Class, who completed their GCE A Level Chinese qualification, gained 6 A* and 12 A Grades.

We congratulate the students, teachers and parents on these fine results, and we look forward to continued success in the GCE IAL programme.

......

bearbearhome

我覺得兩款唔同教學模式，冇話邊間一定特別高級。論升學成績就cky better, 但如果喜愛傳統教學的穩陣咁就spb 啦。

baoyeah2014

大波大 發表於 21-3-21 01:43
Spb for sure
我自己個人認為兩間唔同級數

請問可唔可以分享點解？多謝你

2013skc

如果比較升大學成績，都係cky 比較好

大波大

Spb for sure
我自己個人認為兩間唔同級數

Ann201403

我問過幾個year 12學生的家長，沒有這樣的投訴。轉老師就間間學校都有。

giver

misswendyyan 發表於 21-3-1 22:32
https://www.ischooladvisor.com/reviews/po-leung-kuk-choi-kai-yau-school-hong-kong

oh sorry,  依家先睇到呢個 link ，要慢慢睇吓先 ⋯⋯  ha又發現多一個 forum, 不過呢個好似冇講大學啲嘢？ anyway, Thanks!

giver

deco99 發表於 21-3-4 09:02
我本身都好鍾意cky，但呢個網站評論睇得我好驚，大意都係話小學幾好，中學就好多問題。我之前都收過cky中 ...

小學係好好呀 ; 中學階段嘅需要唔同吖嘛，我哋當年都有陪小朋友一起渡過適應期 ⋯⋯ 回想起來，是細節上協助他們成長，根本理念冇變。

咁多年有冇困難？ 有冇抱怨？有冇約見過社工丶校長？ 有冇(想過) 轉校？ 通通都有。但依家望返轉頭，好多嘢當時唔明嘅，依家都變得通透。簡單嚟講，十分十分慶幸他們能擁有過往10多年的成長空間。

P.S.  我家兩小剛榮升「老鬼」，亦親睹中學部的不斷改進，未知是否涉及你所提到的「好多問題」？ 不如逐一講出嚟研究吓。 ( 究竟驚啲乜嘢呢？ 請唔好介意我咁問，因為近月先返嚟EK，咁仔女要考大學啦，又返嚟學下嘢囉。但發覺大家好少提CKY，試過爬文又睇唔到乜特別嘢。)

areyouangry

misswendyyan 發表於 21-3-1 22:32
https://www.ischooladvisor.com/reviews/po-leung-kuk-choi-kai-yau-school-hong-kong

多謝分享，實在太恐怖⋯⋯