St Cat vs Anfield

JJ116

小兒現有K1 St Cat am and Anfield full day offer.  

想請教大家如將來小學target CAIS, ESF等，讀哪一間會比較好？我們比較心儀St Cat, 始終是名幼，但又怕英文不是太強...好糾結

多謝各位賜教(emoji)(emoji)

salwa

hilary_tang 發表於 19-12-2 22:20
回覆 salwa 的帖子

Nopes, Anfield Kindies are too far for us unfortunately.

I c...

salwa

hilary_tang 發表於 19-12-2 08:35
I think if you are aiming IS at primary level you have chosen that sort of learning philosophy for y ...

Are you a parent of anfield?  

細佬Bebe

JJ116 發表於 19-12-2 11:16
Totally agreed! You have exactly raised out what my concern.  

There is no perfect school but choo ...

幼稚園兩三年，會學到幾多中文呀？都係認字嘅層面姐
更何況Anfield 都每日一堂中文堂

細佬Bebe

piglover 發表於 19-12-1 11:28
如果target IS. 我會選擇Anfield. 不要因為名幼嘅名而選擇St Cat.

如果target ESF, 就入ESF 幼稚園，好似 ...

Can’t agree more

唔好因為好多家長好心儀st cat而揀
唔係買個名牌袋 係幫子女選校

St cat轉去國際學校 好難嫁 成功既例子你唔知父母付出左咩 （foreign passport ,搵Net一對一補英文，買denenture，先去啲無咁好既國際學校再轉）

St cat係local 路既一線選擇（大眾認為） 但IS路佢唔係一個好既選擇

JJ116

edltw 發表於 19-12-2 10:33
回覆 JJ116 的帖子

We got Anfield pm and St cat as well and have paid $17k for Anfield.

Totally agreed! You have exactly raised out what my concern.  

There is no perfect school but choose the one you think is the most suitable to our kids.

I will probably take Anfield....

Thanks all for your invaluable opinions

edltw

回覆 JJ116 的帖子

We got Anfield pm and St cat as well and have paid $17k for Anfield.
We are struggling between these 2 but i think we should take Anfield as our target is also international school. I think entering Anfield has much higher chance to enter international primary 2 years later.

The only concern is the chi level of my kid. We won't expect my kid having same chinese standard with local school but still want him to study certain level of chinese...

so give and take......

salwa

回覆 JJ116 的帖子

I c! So still considering?

JJ116

salwa 發表於 19-12-1 22:39
回覆 JJ116 的帖子

So you haven’t done the registration yet?

Anfield 已付$17000留位費，St Cat 7/12先註冊，所以想儘快決定

salwa

回覆 siufan15 的帖子

Yes! Totally agree! We have to understand our orientations about “learning” - do you believe in play based learning or sth else? How you see what a kid needs is the basic driver to your choice.

salwa

回覆 JJ116 的帖子

So you haven’t done the registration yet?

salwa

Yes, this really depends on what your target is and what you think about the “curriculum”.

irenewsw

JJ116 發表於 19-12-1 14:22
有報esf k1, 但我們是N無人士，所以連interview 機會都無。

講得好啱，應該選適合的K, 不是揀名幼

Me as well, so we hv to at least admit my daughter to intl kindergarten first. If not, it’s even harder to go to esf, fis etc... so we choose anfield. I also gave up other LS offers...

Sumsumsum123

piglover 發表於 19-12-1 16:09
本帖最後由 piglover 於 19-12-1 16:11 編輯

本帖最後由 piglover 於 19-12-1 16:10 編輯

呀，係，我搞錯左
係今年interview,下年K1
就開始一條龍

piglover

Sumsumsum123 發表於 19-12-1 12:39
今年已開始

本帖最後由 piglover 於 19-12-1 16:10 編輯

No， 明年才直升。有朋友今年入ESF K1, 她話不是直升。2020年入學K1才有直升。詳情可看下面資料。

https://www.sundaykiss.com/379717/education/%e5%b9%bc%e7%a8%9a%e5%9c%92/%e8%8b%b1%e5%9f%ba%e5%9c%8b%e9%9a%9b%e5%b9%bc%e7%a8%9a%e5%9c%92-%e4%b8%80%e6%a2%9d%e9%be%8d-k1%e7%9b%b4%e5%8d%87%e4%b8%ad%e5%ad%b8/

JJ116

piglover 發表於 19-12-1 11:28
如果target IS. 我會選擇Anfield. 不要因為名幼嘅名而選擇St Cat.

如果target ESF, 就入ESF 幼稚園，好似 ...

有報esf k1, 但我們是N無人士，所以連interview 機會都無。

講得好啱，應該選適合的K, 不是揀名幼

Sumsumsum123

piglover 發表於 19-12-1 11:28
如果target IS. 我會選擇Anfield. 不要因為名幼嘅名而選擇St Cat.

如果target ESF, 就入ESF 幼稚園，好似 ...

今年已開始

piglover

如果target IS. 我會選擇Anfield. 不要因為名幼嘅名而選擇St Cat.

如果target ESF, 就入ESF 幼稚園，好似明年開始，ESF 幼稚園可以直升ESF 小學。