同時學英文拼音(phonics)同普通話拼音小朋友會亂嗎？

gumbyworld

有冇小朋友同時學緊英文拼音(phonics)同普通話拼音，會唔會好混亂呢？謝謝

Yanamami

我女幼稚園時先学英，遲－年再学普拼音。到中学，再先学韓文，後学日文。或者佢有少少天份，但如楼上話齋，超細开始越易｡

心曠神怡

好大機會會窩，因為英文同拼音好大分別。

Mr_Jed_J

回覆 conniewktang 的帖子

Yes, I believe you are correct although my experience and knowledge of Pin Yin is quite limited... Children's brains are smart enough and pliable enough to compartmentalise and differentiate between the two languages and to distinguish the differences... Maybe with some overlapping at times but primarily, they are capable enough. Like switching on a light or changing a channel, that distinction is made soon after the brain is developed enough.

Mr_Jed_J

I am a father of 3 bilingual (mixed race) girls and an English Teacher. In my experience from my career as a teacher who teaches phonics as well as other English courses to various age groups, I have come to the conclusion that learning two ( in my daughter's case, 3 languages: English, Cantonese and Putonghua) that having such a diverse and wide range of exposure to phonetic variations may have a longer duration of learning curve but helps to enrich them in the diversity and use of language and sound
for better hearing and comprehension abilities, especially in the long term. Besides, it helps to train their ear as well as increase intelligence and their language centres of the brain. If anyone would want any tips or more on my opinion, please feel free to PM me.

conniewktang

gumbyworld 發表於 19-5-21 12:07
有冇小朋友同時學緊英文拼音(phonics)同普通話拼音，會唔會好混亂呢？謝謝

...

從來不會亂。2樣都是我自己同時教的。
普通話是先學漢語拼音才學PTH;
英文是先學Letterland 及RWI,然後自然就會串英文字。

不但不亂，相輔相成，都是blend埋啲音，原理一樣！

cafeva

我個幼稚園學，無亂

山貓姐

例如普通話拼音的雙韻母，跟英文 phonics 的 digraphs 同一串法，但發音完全不同，怎會不混亂？  

英文是拼音語言，中文不是，哪樣要優先處理好，很清楚了。

Mrscatcatfung

我個仔快5歲又唔會。
phonics, 普 一直都好清楚。
他三歲半仲自学法文，西班牙，俄羅斯字母，可讀可寫可背默。冇亂過。只係唔喜歡廣東話。現在唔俾佢学法俄，專攻中英文先，加小小西班牙文。努力一年中英溝通無問題。

會不會亂是因人而異。你可以什麼都学一学先，再調節。也許你的小朋友好有天份。

我本人見到拼音那堆声母韻母，頭开始痛了。但阿仔如獲至寶，順序背又可，倒背又可。自創玩法。

我估是因為他的記性和耐力好好。如果記性，耐力好，同時学應無問題。否則慢慢來;一點一點累積，也是美事。

bonbonha

我小朋友讀英普幼稚園，冇呢個問題

Aman666

我個女未有這個問題喎，可能係起初會亂，但時間耐了會清晰番啦.

huba

阿仔幼稚園有英普班，學生同時學 phonics 及普通話冇問題噃。另外，也有其他知名雙語幼稚園提供英普班，沒聽過家長話有問題。

這些基本學習交給幼稚園吧，毋須另行安排。

bobochu0101

我也覺得會

nkd

好彩我仔幼稚園有英語粵語無國語，到小學先學拼音。

HaYi

我2個幼稚園都是英普班, 佢地幼稚園K1開始學phonics,  PTH 幼稚園反而冇特別教拚音. 只是教用字.  
PTH 拚音是小學(普教中) 時才會學多些. 到了小學(英文直資) 反而沒有phonics 堂, 所以他們的PTH 拚音同Phonics  是在不同時間注重學, 感覺不會太亂.   

反而我自己小時先學PTH 拚音, 有了小孩後跟他們學phonics (之前我都有學過正式字典用個D拚音) , 就有點亂.   

Yanamami

我女两样－齐学，番英普班，無问題｡不过都係先开始phonics－排，学到blending先再开始学拼音｡