Piccolo(HKPS) vs York

Sailor-Moon

好好好煩惱，兩間都有可取捨的地方：

Piccolo：據聞會沿用HKPS的教學和行政，但畢竟改名轉學校，前景係點無人知

York：有知名度又學術深，將來考直私有保障

個人稍偏向HKPS的教學，happy得黎學到嘢！

但現Piccolo vs York真係R爆頭。

即將要卑大訂，懇請各位卑D意見，謝謝！

debbyau

回覆 alantung8943 的帖子

我會揀HKPS, 我仔仔係 HKPS(Pictorial) 讀了4年, 無揀錯...學習開心又學到野...養成閱讀習慣,
佢班同學考私小直資成績好好..也叩到好既津校。

SarahGil

回覆 JLLmama 的帖子

甘係因為 之前太鬆動, 未用盡空間, 因之前係新校有收生不足既問題,尤其K2-K3. 其實課室規劃係可容纳28人.

JLLmama

vonsin 發表於 17-6-22 23:55
我而家係harts 用家，仔仔讀緊pn, harts將會改名為樂希樂基幼稚園/幼兒園，Harts Hong Kong preschool and  ...

師生比例不變1:9，但多加一老師，甘即係變相成大班教學。問題係如果個課室同硬件係冇變，學習環境會較之前差。

mrivan

york

Sailor-Moon

Syamky 發表於 17-7-7 09:37
呢兩間各自的情況，每人要求不同，睇下邊樣適合自己

HKPS（即預計Piccolo 情況）：

多謝你提供的意見！詳盡、客觀且清晰

Syamky

不過其實校名呢d野，如果學校辦得好，好快會出名。好似學之園，頭1、2年冇乜學生，因為辦得好，短短幾年已被人追捧為名校。還記得學之園校監話青衣校第一年只有4個學生，及後慢慢發展到而家所有分校已有過千學生。而HKPS之前也是好短時間已經幾出名。可以參考下。

Syamky

呢兩間各自的情況，每人要求不同，睇下邊樣適合自己

HKPS（即預計Piccolo 情況）：
- 每班一定有一個NET做班主任，即使本地班也每天20mins PTH，一般comment d老師都有經驗有愛心
- 學校guarantee 必定小班教學（不會大於1:9）
- Phonics program since pn
- A very unique reading program - 不只像一般學校叫學生回家看書，係返到學校老師會逐個一起看，睇下小朋友睇成點（小班所以能做到）
- 蒙特梳尼課程 since pn
- music & art 係請專科老師教，會教d 有用technique 和知識 例如簡單樂理，而不是一般學校simply 唱遊
- 小學interview class since K2 （no extra fee)
- Violin class since K2 (no extra fee needed)
- 除學費，沒有雜費/茶點費
- 但Piccolo 新，有待觀察第一年after HKPS merge 實況

York：
- 每班都有NET，英文強
- 校舍大d靚d （視乎邊個校舍）
- phonics program since pn
- 會幫家長安排考公開試如Cambridge
- Violin和 Tennis 課程（but 要pay some fee)
- interview class since K2 (need pay fee)
- 較多不同雜費，樣樣都要$，不過有d係 optional，自由選擇
- 大校（一級接近600人），未必小班教學，老師質數有d參差，大校多老師，聽過有d好好但有d唔好。
- 歷史悠久有名氣

Tang23

回覆 fluty 的帖子

I also want to know! I am the new pn student follow fr hk preschool kln tong.

fluty

May I know are there any groups for piccolo pn parent ?

莫失莫忘

兩間揀我會揀PICCOLO, 一係我信HKPS可以維持到佢地原有教學模式。二係YORK係幼師界風評好差, 我之前同小朋友上間PLAYGROUP既幾位老師傾下邊間幼稚園好, 一講到YORK佢地都好婉轉咁講話唔好,另之前唔知EK定BK都有做過幼稚園老師既JM講過呢間學校既野,所以我一定唔會揀YORK.

sharonchan.0711

renaya 發表於 17-6-21 11:39
好奇怪大家一面倒撐York但又唔提供多啲理據講下York有幾好，樓主上黎問得當然想知道有用嘅資訊，兩者比較有 ...

York都有30年左右歷史的

mrivan

york

msenglishteache

有冇人知現在piccolo還接受今年pn申請嗎？

peanutbbboy

回覆 SarahGil 的帖子

多謝你的意見, 感覺明朗了很多

SarahGil

回覆 peanutbbboy 的帖子

Let me try to answer you as below:-


其實我搵緊學校幫小朋友報下年pn, 睇到Harts, 好鍾意, 網上家長對學校教法和老師評價都很高. Agree, including me. Their teachers, teaching style and syllabus, which are adopted from HKPS, are excellent.
Piccolo就比較少人有提供學校既教學, 只係睇到話HKPS老師將進駐 Piccolo, 咁係咪即係Piccolo所有班都會跟HKPS以往既教法呢? Yes. 定係只係呢幾年, 完左HKPS舊生就吾跟? I believe if there are enough students, they will still want to run the school following the HKPS style. After all, HKPS has been really popular and HKPS style will attract more students. 定就係HKPS過去既學生先跟呢套教法呢? 其他就係Piccolo原有既方法呢? I don't think so.  All Piccolo students will receive HKPS style teaching.  That's what the school said.

我有呢個疑問係因為我自己好欣賞HKPS既教學方法, 但就猶豫緊Harts好定係Piccolo好? 如果教法一樣, 硬件上Piccolo有戶外活動場地, 吸引d.  Not only that, Piccolo's school fee is also cheaper than Hart's.

peanutbbboy

其實我搵緊學校幫小朋友報下年pn, 睇到Harts, 好鍾意, 網上家長對學校教法和老師評價都很高.
Piccolo就比較少人有提供學校既教學, 只係睇到話HKPS老師將進駐 Piccolo, 咁係咪即係Piccolo所有班都會跟HKPS以往既教法呢? 定係只係呢幾年, 完左HKPS舊生就吾跟? 定就係HKPS過去既學生先跟呢套教法呢? 其他就係Piccolo原有既方法呢?

我有呢個疑問係因為我自己好欣賞HKPS既教學方法, 但就猶豫緊Harts好定係Piccolo好? 如果教法一樣, 硬件上Piccolo有戶外活動場地, 吸引d.

SarahGil

回覆 renaya 的帖子

You are welcome.  I just want to clarify the facts so that there ain't any misunderstanding so that the parents can have an informed decision to choose what is most suitable to their kids.

renaya

SarahGil 發表於 17-6-23 10:39
回覆 beiwoyu 的帖子

The School already issued a notice saying that they could not get EDB's approva ...

thank you very much for all the clarifications, from the day we decided to choose Piccolo, we don't have further doubts about the quality of the school curriculum nor the teacher's experience as well as qualification. Your feedbacks have just enhanced our confidence on the school.