英華定搏九華

vincenthim2004

英華已收，17/3要註冊，阿仔較鍾意九華，係19/3 IN，但未必收，大家會點揀？

Naurto

原帖由 moon.ng 於 16-05-22 發表
現在的香港整天吵吵鬧鬧，三天遊行兩天示威，電視報紙上看到的都是這些，好人好事的報導似乎無法贏取媒體的 ...

內地唔差。深圳有D私辦學校。數學一般學深半年至一年，英文小學時已用longman 書，中文唔洗講……

moon.ng

原帖由 hngr 於 16-05-22 發表
那一个好？看这里口碑也知道不用多说。有关九华，其实年前我在这里已作过客观的分析。当年小兒也徘徊在十字 ...

現在的香港整天吵吵鬧鬧，三天遊行兩天示威，電視報紙上看到的都是這些，好人好事的報導似乎無法贏取媒體的關注，罵政府反國家天天可以上頭條，社會沒有了正能量，籠罩著一層怨氣，這樣的香港我不喜歡，我情願喜歡內地！

hngr

那一个好？看这里口碑也知道不用多说。有关九华，其实年前我在这里已作过客观的分析。当年小兒也徘徊在十字路口上，结果放弃了九华，至今尚未後悔。靠旧生校友扶持？真天真！我伯父是柯士甸道九华校友，以前他公司老是聘九华師弟，但後來发生了一些事，这些老一輩靠感情用人的标准早已取消了。憑实力，重德行，才是現今社会标准！校舍大就好？看是你唸書，还是書唸你，大陆大，香港小，你喜欢那里？这样子说了，相信很快又有打手跑出来骂人了。

moon.ng

原帖由 mcl203 於 16-05-11 發表
英華有小學， 九華全收街外

這樣來看，我們跨區升讀九華機會比較大哦！

austism

原帖由 kkhon 於 16-05-11 發表
我都好想知英華同九華的比較，計難入應是英華，它哪方面吾好？九華哪方面優勝？請各前輩賜教！ ...

各有fans, 各有各好。

本人喜歡九華, 佢地傳統係師兄好照顧師弟，就算畢業生就好肯回饋母校，睇下個新球場就知，仲有小班教學，資助部分學生出國：今年暑假整隊choir去美國/Canada , 上年orchestra 去歐洲, 上星期部分學生去左歐音樂學院交流........，好多resources , 中學唔係淨係讀書，出去見下世面都好㗎。

我女最近同九華join school, 上佢地學校練歌，所以知道佢地d嘢，我女話佢d同學問點解九華校舍大成咁？（這也是賣點之一）

不過，如果小朋友不是自動自覺型，就唔好選九華la。

好在我個係女仔，佢不是自覺型，現在學校比較嚴，啱哂佢

mcl203

原帖由 kkhon 於 16-05-11 發表
我都好想知英華同九華的比較，計難入應是英華，它哪方面吾好？九華哪方面優勝？請各前輩賜教！ ...

英華有小學， 九華全收街外

kkhon

我都好想知英華同九華的比較，計難入應是英華，它哪方面吾好？九華哪方面優勝？請各前輩賜教！

hippoo

wbmom

回覆 hkmom 的帖子

完全同意，這也是我想表達的， 各有支持者，不過要比同grade的學校， 係好難做到完全客觀，用唔同尺踱就有唔同结果。

hkmom

什麼只說XX比XX好，而沒有提供任何論點作補充，相信精明的會員都知是發表者的個人主觀看法 :)

wbmom

回覆 cherrieshum 的帖子

九華比英華好

cherrieshum

英華比九華好

hkmom

回覆 hkmom 的帖子

akys  4-3-3指派位年代，所以係55%or more

原來係咁，明白哂！謝謝！

hkmom

akys 發表於 16-4-1 18:07
Enter the schools' website, find the annual report and you will find the information.

A) Yes.

Thank you so much for your explanation.  I suppose 4-3-3 quoted from your earlier post is just a wild thought, meaning 40% of students being band 1 kids and 30% each for bands 2 & 3.  I think 40% would be quite low for a DSS primary school like YWPS that has got more than thousands of applicants every year

And I agree that the outsiders (approx. 50 in number) should be either very strong academically or talented in one way or another.

akys

hkmom 發表於 16-4-1 15:48
回覆 akys 的帖子

Thanks very much to akys for the information.  So do you mean YWC and QC have rele ...

Enter the schools' website, find the annual report and you will find the information.

A) Yes.
B) Outsiders are usually great at academic results. When these 50 outsiders join the 150 primary students, do they dominate the top rank? (補充：想了解小學入學時幾十揀一嘅學生有幾多%放喺其他學校可以考頭五頭十？)
C) YWPS joins the 呈分試. Those fail the P6 exams and conduct below B are not eligible to enter secondary school. This is a matter of both mental and study preparation. Imagine you are studying in a subsidized school and targeting elite school such as QC, DBS, LSC,  SPCC...etc., we are not talking about passing the exams only(admission criteria), you need to be perfect in the exams and scored very high marks so as to be the top few%. Diligent and pressure is inevitable. This is so called "呈分試嘅洗禮"

hkmom

回覆 akys 的帖子

Thanks very much to akys for the information.  So do you mean YWC and QC have released the Pre-S1 results of their intake in that year?  Where did they publish the results?  Would much appreciate it you could provide the relevant URLs.

You wrote "好奇嘅喺左揀右揀後班直資小學生整體係唔係咁高？冇經過呈分試嘅洗禮，同其他小學比會係點？呢啲要中學家長先知道了。"  In order not to mis-guess your meaning, may I clarify whether you mean the following:

A.  "左揀右揀後" = the admission process for K3 kids (or insert students) by YWPS?

B.  "班直資小學生整體係唔係咁高？" = whether the kids (in the DSS era) as a whole display a high academic performance (i.e. much higher than 40% of them attaining B1 standard) ?  [or do you mean something else?!]

C.  By "冇經過呈分試嘅洗禮", do you mean (1) YWPS won't report the results of the internal exam. (i.e. 不呈分) or (2) the YWPS kids will not prepare the exam. as diligently as they should compared with other kids who don't have the back-up of a through-train secondary school?

akys

回覆 hkmom 的帖子

冇數據，唔放Annual Report。我覺得Pre-S1加DSE成績最能代表中學嘅能力。第一：收生質素，二：增值能力，三：升大學能力。食幾多痾幾多一目了然。不過好少學校有放Pre-S1數據。

純數據看，覺得YWC增值能力應該唔錯。對上幾屆到F3由小學直升嗰班都仲係津貼派位，按4－3－3計，加埋外來50個B1 生，都係得55%或以上B1生（取決於小學增值能力有幾高），掹車邊留喺B1算唔錯喇。始終一條龍對中學有利有弊，好嘅係教育延續性，壞嘅係要收埋B2或B3生，不像其他中學可以全收B1生。

好奇嘅喺左揀右揀後班直資小學生整體係唔係咁高？冇經過呈分試嘅洗禮，同其他小學比會係點？呢啲要中學家長先知道了。

mymelody2003

TSUNTINGMA 發表於 16-3-30 09:58
Hea 教不等同可以Hea 讀!

冇錯, 每間學校都會出現既情況, hea教但考試考得深都會有, 有時選擇直資目的是校內資源豐富一點, 對教導學生會有幫助.
教師hea教並不等於學生唔叻, 囝囝同學仔好多都好勁, 可能勁補習.


最後, 初中階段hea讀, s3才發力去讀書因選科讀s4, 根本唔夠人去爭, 因為好多科都要級頭30-40名才有機會選.

hkmom

akys 發表於 16-3-30 19:38
回覆 hkmom 的帖子

YWC
2014-2015
Pre-S1 Average
Chinese 59.1
English  80.13
Maths  78.8

Million thanks indeed!  Do you have similar figures for DBS and SPCC?