真心求教, 細b應該選何文田victoria/九龍塘樂基? 用家請分享

stewartc

維多利亞： pros 出名d, IB 課程, happy school, 有照顧細b經驗 Cons: 如果直資名小課程好似太淺，好多家長會出外補習 九龍塘 樂基/HKPS Pros 小班教學，校長好好，語境好，有室外空間 Cons 唔係好多人識，強迫搭校巴，要學寫字有d chur 普遍想法：想入直資名小就選 樂基... 想入國際學校就vic 除左想小朋友將來升到直資小學，其實都想佢過一個愉快既童年，唔知樂基既家長會不會覺得好chur? 又唔知vic 既家長會唔會覺得課程太淺？ 大家點睇？有冇用家分享一下 樂基/Vic 既經驗？

stewartc

希望大家都搵到最適合自己仔女既學校啦. Add oil!

宇宙翹楚

原帖由 puichingforsure 於 16-02-26 發表
點解學校又咁答我嘅？我唔係質疑大家，也冇質疑學校，不過如果冇見你地分享，我只會跟網上指引以為9月打後 ...

講真，學校咁安排好唔公平囉，有守規矩家長唔交表就反而冇咗個機會，唔守規矩就得咗。樓主，我唔係話你，你細  b兩間名校都考到一定有過人之處，我係唔同意學校呢種手法囉

SarahGil

回覆 stewartc 的帖子

Am a Harts user. Regarding the question of the school letting their kids to write starting from 2nd term of K1, I initially also have concerns that it's a bit aggressive as most other kids would start writing in first term of K2 as for most kindergartens and as suggested by EDU.  However, I still finally chose Harts considering all factors.  Now my kid is studying K1 and I found that although part of their homework is to write Chinese characters, the teachers would still factor in each individual kid's development and capability. They wouldn't push the kids if they found them not yet ready to write.  So I think they have great flexibility and are very caring in that that would cater each kid's situation. I believe that HKPS would be the same and even more sophisticated than Harts.  All in all, I would vote for HKPS over Victoria unless VSA is your only target for primary.

maomaofafa

我會選vic，因為vic收多D細B，個分岐無咁大。同埋好似話九龍塘hkps一定要乘校巴，要看適不適合，而且聽說好多資深老師調了去新校（有錯請指正），所以如㨂hkps brand會否㨂harts仲好過hkps kln？

Dadagaga

原帖由 puichingforsure 於 16-02-26 發表
點解學校又咁答我嘅？我唔係質疑大家，也冇質疑學校，不過如果冇見你地分享，我只會跟網上指引以為9月打後 ...

我估大家搏一搏，其實之前有聽過收細B，不過好似有sibling .....

stewartc

坦白講我真係唔識HKPS 入面既人... 可能係仔仔interview 表現唔錯啦
至於報唔報得，我同老婆都覺得俾$40買個機會afford得起咪照報囉
結果火炭樂基同九龍塘樂基都報左，火炭就彈番轉頭錢都唔收, 樂基就有得in
其實之前都有post話九龍塘樂基係有收細b既，不過係唔係靠關係就唔知啦

Dadagaga

原帖由 puichingforsure 於 16-02-26 發表
真心請教，係咪即係細B（9至12月出世）都可以照入表？

根據我朋友經驗，佢個仔11 月出世係有去interview , 早我一個time slot, 不過只係冇收，因為interview 時，佢得12－13個月，其實真係一舊飯，group interview, 做晤到指令。我個time slot, 我自己就見唔到超細B。我問返今年9月入學媽媽，暫時我見到收到5-6月都有。

Dadagaga

原帖由 puichingforsure 於 16-02-26 發表
學校的回覆是：我們的2016至2017的PLAYGROUP（兩歲班即其他學校叫PRE-NURSERY的班級）只接受二零一四年一月 ...

我朋友個仔11月出世，都有HKPS interview, 不過最後冇收到。10月B收，其實真係好lucky。

回應個post, 我自己就揀咗HKPS, 原因係我喜歡small class size ，對小朋友照顧好D，同埋本地/國際小學兩邊有出路, 因為我未知道小朋友適合邊條路。另外喜歡佢個reading scheme! 我覺得小朋友主動喜歡閱讀，對終生也受用！

個人覺得2間都係好學校，反而好睇你想小學點走。因為維記考直資始終少D優勢，讀完幾年，先發現原因唔想入國際學校，就太遲。

lvmh88

原帖由 puichingforsure 於 16-02-26 發表
請問你是細B的意思是幾細？咁如果係8月，收都唔出奇，但如果係9月打後的細B，一早就講明不ACCEPT FORM就真 ...

樓主其他post講咗係10月b 啦

mrivan

to small b, i think victoria is more easy for him to handle, it is IB curriculum.  but if you target traditional school, victoria may not be very very fit...
to big b, i think HKPS is good to help him/her practice, languages are good there.  it can fit to both IB / traditional school... small class size...

letterland

8月b黎講真係好勁，你唔等埋st cat, km, LH 先再諗？果2間都入到，呢3間更無難度。👍👍

fluty

細b 兩間都有offer ?
好勁好lucky ar

hahashiu

回覆 stewartc 的帖子

請問你bb係幾月b?