HY, GHS大家会点揀

tung_yan0623

一个好敏感的話題，但亦正值人生交叉点，大家会点揀，請比d意見

momomingchen

This year, I know several girls gave up the GH offer and registered in HY.  HY is good not only in academic, but also sports, music, moral, quite comprehensive.

For government school, when compare BPS and YWG, for me, I definitely choose YWG.  In fact, both are good at academic.  However, YWG are better in the new campus and moral education. All the top ten girls of my daughter's school will choose 1 YWG 2 BPS.

Another concern is what does  your daughter like?

I agree with Yanamum. Final decision should by made by the child.

BallBallMaMa

原帖由 myfanwy 於 16-03-17 發表
回覆 momomingchen 的帖子

Acutally it is difficult to say. We can take YWGS and BPS as example. They ...

That is because they need to take students from lucky draw.

myfanwy

回覆 momomingchen 的帖子

Acutally it is difficult to say. We can take YWGS and BPS as example. They also accept top students in different primary schools but they are yet to become the second best girls school in Hong Kong.

momomingchen

Agree with crystalwsm. Most of the girls from HY primary school are polite and kind.  In fact, their academic are weaker than those from other famous primary schools.  Most likely, only 4-5 girls of HY primary school can be selected into the elite's class.   Others come from other famous primary school.

However, even though she still reserves seats for HY primary school, she can maintain 50% entrance to 3 main Universities. If she no needs to reserves seats for HY primary school after two years. Her academic achievement may be the second among the girls' school.  Actually, DGS still be the first.

The information is given by my friends who have daughters from HY and GH secondary school.

crystalwsm

momomingchen 發表於 16-3-16 08:59
Agree with crystalwsm, if HY secondary school no need to take girls from HY primary school after two ...

That's why I think HY is better than GH，this just my opinion

momomingchen

Agree with crystalwsm, if HY secondary school no need to take girls from HY primary school after two years, the academic of HY secondary school must improve a lot. She can choose all the smart girls. She will compete against DGS.

hugub

crystalwsm 發表於 16-3-2 16:05
Thank you hkpapa852，其實我都攪唔清楚D時間，我女今年小五，2017年9月升中一，今年年尾至出年年頭開始考 ...

咁你已經呈左1次分上協中, 來緊6月係第2次呈分上去協中..加油

hugub

crystalwsm 發表於 16-3-2 17:14
Sorry hkpapa852，想再了解清楚多少少，請問是否今年派位是協小最後一年以直屬關係升上中學？2017年尾的升 ...

現正讀緊P.5既係最後一批收87%入協中...  成績要 D grade 或以上

jackjackwin

回覆 dordormom 的帖子

Thanks dordormom

dordormom

回覆 jackjackwin 的帖子

I like   油真, then HY and last is GH.Convenient ; 油真is the best
Eng and Chinese average also this one is balance.

Y2kqk

但我識一個上年是叩門入的

jackjackwin

回覆 Yanamami 的帖子

YWG係無叩門, 以上做法係如果佢有後補位時, 你又係佢WAITING LIST, 佢仍會CALL你咁解, 校長今年特登係ADMISSION TALK時都有提, 但一定係有IN過自行同埋有預先通知校方已TAKE直資, 但對YW仍然好有興趣先得

Yanamami

ggfather222 發表於 16-3-3 16:40
回覆 surewin 的帖子

如果叩門, 有幾間很好的女校, 不防考慮, BPS,  放榜當日可試, 但同區不接受.   (YWG, ...

YWGS又話無得叩门既……

ggfather222

回覆 surewin 的帖子

如果叩門, 有幾間很好的女校, 不防考慮, BPS,  放榜當日可試, 但同區不接受.   (YWG, 今年轉了校長可能不同) 去年,可於放榜前, 預先致電書記(取電郵地址), 再發一個電郵, 向校方闡明願放棄某某直資之OFFER (但不用即時放棄, 如YWG收了才放棄). 她們會打印並放入您女兒的FILE , 當然, 甲部要有YWG, 並有出席面試, 油真(同區也可試, 但最好中, 英, 數 也是甲等).

小木偶媽咪

原帖由 surewin 於 16-03-02 發表
想再問清楚, 有直資offer而又簽了承諾書, 便要放棄大抽獎, 7月5日放榜後還可以叩回津校的嗎? 是不是這個意 ...

無錯！某些學校接受放榜日叩門，你要喺放榜前一星期上學校網頁，睇清楚需要交嘅文件，然後放榜日係小學收到註冊證後，直接過去中學校交文件就得

peggy

crystalwsm 發表於 16-3-2 17:14
Sorry hkpapa852，想再了解清楚多少少，請問是否今年派位是協小最後一年以直屬關係升上中學？2017年尾的升 ...

應該明年才是協小最後一年以直屬関係升上中學部
李校長做埋今個學期就會退休

jackjackwin

我想請問大家又覺得油真比HY及GH差得遠嘛? 請賜教, 先謝!

surewin

小木偶媽咪 發表於 16-2-26 21:07
可以呀

想再問清楚, 有直資offer而又簽了承諾書, 便要放棄大抽獎, 7月5日放榜後還可以叩回津校的嗎? 是不是這個意思? 謝謝!

crystalwsm

hkpapa852 發表於 16-3-2 16:28
你阿女係最後一年可以直升HY(要成績達C級).

脫龍後成績如何...... 無人會知.....

Sorry hkpapa852，想再了解清楚多少少，請問是否今年派位是協小最後一年以直屬關係升上中學？2017年尾的升中投考會有多些學位放出來？
另協中好似換校長，不知以後情況又會如何？