YW vs St Paul's College vs 赤柱 St Stephen's

PhilC

我仔未升中，但想請教大家對呢幾間學校的評價。如學費唔係考慮因素，大家會點排位？謝謝！

nvitined

Isaacmommy 發表於 16-10-3 13:17
SSC 是否 compulsory 要寄宿？F1開始？比我就唔捨得啦！

SSC不是一定要留宿。然而，我家住新界，沒可能不住宿。

Isaacmommy

原帖由 nvitined 於 16-10-03 發表
三間學校各有好處。不過，選舉SSC時，除了考慮學費外，家長亦要自問是否捨得兒子或女兒離開家中往留宿？要 ...

SSC 是否 compulsory 要寄宿？F1開始？比我就唔捨得啦！

nvitined

PhilC 發表於 16-2-4 13:32
我仔未升中，但想請教大家對呢幾間學校的評價。如學費唔係考慮因素，大家會點排位？謝謝！



  ...

三間學校各有好處。不過，選擇SSC時，除了考慮學費外，家長亦要自問是否捨得兒子或女兒離開家中往留宿？要在中學放手給小朋友自己往返家校已會擔心，更何況是留宿？講真，SSC校舍是無敵的，有些香港的大學都未必有，家長在選擇時要先問問自己，才好作決定。

hippoo

Up tks

9498mami

PhilC 發表於 16-2-5 11:09
SPC在音樂及體育方面的表現如何？另外，若不是一心讀IB, SSC的學生，DSE成績和另外兩間比較如何？



  ...

經過依幾年學生們嘅努力，不單辯論隊，公開試成績，音樂組向舊年校際音樂節都有好表現。

Title : 67th School Music Festival Results Updates

Group Events:

Group	Event	Result
Junior Choir	Secondary School Choir – Foreign Language – Boys – First Division – Junior	Champion
Mixed Voice Choir	Secondary School Choir – Chinese – Mixed Voice – First Division – Intermediate	Champion
Mixed Voice Choir	Secondary School Choir – Foreign Language – Mixed Voice – First Division – Intermediate	Champion
Symphony Orchestra	Symphony Orchestra – Secondary School – Intermediate	Champion
Chinese Instrumental Ensemble	Chinese Instrumental Ensemble – Secondary School	2nd runner up
Intermediate Choir	Secondary School Choir – Foreign Language – Boys – First Division – Intermediate	2nd runner up
Intermediate Choir	Secondary School Choir – Chinese – Boys – First Division – Intermediate	2nd runner up
Madrigal	Madrigal – Mixed Voice – Secondary School	2nd runner up
Piano Ensemble	Tom Lee Music Prize for Piano Ensemble	3rd runner up

hippoo

Up

Nath

之前有一個分析有關大學升學，可以參考一下： http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3189915&extra=page%3D2

其實SPC 同SSC 都各有所長，我仔升小學時其中2個offer 係佢地既小學部，結果我選擇左SSCPS。So far 都覺得冇揀錯

Nath

之前有一個分析有關大學升學，可以參考一下： http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3189915&extra=page%3D2

其實SPC 同SSC 都各有所長，我仔升小學時其中2個offer 係佢地既小學部，結果我選擇左SSCPS。So far 都覺得冇揀錯

daisy17772

SPC is relatively more recognized internationally.  It was the first English school established by Christian organization in HK.  If one plans to go overseas for study, this would be a point to consider.  It's not surprised to see the academic level would be gradually improved as the quality of its primary school also shows improvement.  The fundamental isn't too poor.  Plus their alumni is rather active, with such connection, a traditional well recognized school won't dare to fall off too far away.

Among the three, I believe both SPC and SSC used to have some students quit in the middle of their secondary school for overseas study.  YW, in my opinion, their students' turnover isn't as much.   YW's merit isn't strong enough to attract elite students from HK Islalnd.

babybear

原帖由 王家爸爸 於 16-02-04 發表
三間差唔多，個人鍾意SPC多啲。我會排 SPC＞SSC＞YWC。

請問有冇呢三間中學上年嘅入U率可作比較?

Joe8889

其實3間都係好學校, 而且成績除了學校自己的能力同樣重要

我睇得簡單D, 港島就st. paul, 九龍就YW, 想獨立就SSP

YW其實學術,運動, 音樂都幾好.

prettyrabbit

原帖由 Pauline_CC 於 16-02-05 發表
YW小學高小奧數成績是最好幾間之一.這一丶二年去頒獎活動多少小. 所以知道.  如果這班小朋友大部分去番YWC. ...

個人對yw snoopy的style沒什認同

kkk3316

回覆 Lindytiger 的帖子

不妨講講你手頭上的資料给大家参考！

Lindytiger

甚麼為之一般？甚麼叫做多國內人？想了解多一點係因為年青人多對眼前事較敏感而多負面感覺，還是有其他原因？因同我多方面既資料收集似乎有所出入。

PhilC

原帖由 KikiDaddy 於 16-02-05 發表
回覆 Pauline_CC 的帖子

Both top 10% students of SPCPS and YWPS have a good chance to get offers fro ...

咁點睇SSC?

KikiDaddy

回覆 Pauline_CC 的帖子

Both top 10% students of SPCPS and YWPS have a good chance to get offers from Band 1A secondary schools.
It is not easy for their feeder secondary schools to retain the top students unless there is an improvement in their DSE results.

Personally, I think SPC would have a better chance to improve its DSE results because 1) it has more places for external Band 1 students (YWC just has 50 places for non YWPS students) and 2) its admission selection criteria is more balanced between academic results and eca (YWC has a strong preference to sport talents).