培正 vs 民生

sala222

想了解一下分別，自己做過資料搜集，但有些仍然不清楚，可否指教？先謝！
培正：幼稚園英文唔清楚。小學中學係中文學校，ranking高d。幼上小，小上中100%直上。中學冿校，免費教育。
民生：幼稚園有net班主任。小學中學係中英學校，ranking比培正低d，幼上小收5/6成，小上中找不到資料。中學私校？

Hopeforb

That's why I didn't even apply for PC last year, I m quite concerned and refrained from putting my son to a 中中。With no offence, just my personal preference . PC is a good school though.

coha

原帖由 anpanman_baby 於 15-12-01 發表
I vote for 培正，培正學術+品德教育好好。民生我麻麻地

我㨂咗Ms, so far 我覺得德育及學術都ok! 升中計，如果我仔女會繼續讀，我prefer EMI 學校多d！

anpanman_baby

原帖由 SumYausumsum 於 15-11-27 發表
我都好有興趣知, 如果萬一呢2間都收入 k1 ... 大家點揀 ? 係萬一 .....

I vote for 培正，培正學術+品德教育好好。民生我麻麻地

Hopeforb

我見映班相時，縂共有呢4位老師加1位普通話老師企埋一齊映。而我仔尤其喜歡佢個副班主任！去學校旅行時，專登搵呢位副班主任映相，看來平時上課，呢位老師都好有involvement

KaliB

校工姨姨是2班share 1位。因k1 toilet (和部份K2) 是2班share班房內置的toilet.

KaliB

1 local + 1 NET = 雙班主任，加1 輔助老師,
再加1助教。
輔助老師: 上午班的local班主任是下午班约輔助老師，and vice versa.

Hopeforb

回覆 73662710 的帖子

Base on my son's actual class am K1:
1 local class teacher
1 net class teacher
1 teaching assistant
1 vice class teacher 副班主任（佢本身是下午班其中一班的正班主任）
And 1 校工姨姨（but she may take care of two classes as two classrooms are connected at the back)

73662710

mybabyloveme 發表於 15-11-30 22:38
民幼一班33人，1local , 1net, 1助教 stay in classroom

有人講 係 1NET, 1 中，2助教 1阿姨
究竟邊個先真？

mybabyloveme

Laughing

mybabyloveme

民幼一班33人，1local , 1net, 1助教 stay in classroom

Happytimemama

vpo0615 發表於 15-11-30 11:59
但係參考今年DSE數據都唔代表10幾年後嘅嘢....

咁你仲可以參考D乜？依你咁講，冇人有水晶球，咁讀乜學校都冇所謂啦！話唔定衣家D band 3學校十幾年後變成band 1.咁你會不會衣家入定band 3學校讀丫！

signhere@@

兩間係咪都係大班？有幾多個班主任？

Cutecutebibi

民生呢幾年DSE真係考得好好。民幼全程外籍老師班主任亦好吸引。

vpo0615

但係參考今年DSE數據都唔代表10幾年後嘅嘢....

cpychung

民生都係津校，雖然一般認為培正係band 1a民生係band 1b，但dse出黎後，成績民生上其實唔比培正差，但民生真係會比較谷，個人會選擇培正多啲...

Brainwave

原帖由 crown_629 於 15-11-29 發表
我小朋友可能比較淡定同開朗活潑，因是大b，民生面試時答問題全部都識，但培正面試自己入去，就唔知佢表現 ...

crown_629

Brainwave 發表於 15-11-27 14:26
咁你小朋友好叻！兩間咁難入都同時有offer!
可分享下小朋友面試時表現如何呢？



  ...

我小朋友可能比較淡定同開朗活潑，因是大b，民生面試時答問題全部都識，但培正面試自己入去，就唔知佢表現如何

Happytimemama

73662710 發表於 15-11-28 21:27
Judging from the DSE results in recent 2 years, one school got ~40 （5**）each year while the other  ...

Very well said, it was Stated very clearly on their respective website regarding the DSE results 2014, MS got 4% of all attempts with 5**, totally getting 44x 5** while PC got 18 x 5**. MS has improving vigorously and on steady uptrend in the past years.

73662710

Judging from the DSE results in recent 2 years, one school got ~40 （5**）each year while the other got ~20(5**) each year. It seems one school is improving very fast. The Eng standard in a Chinese medium school can be very good, by the same token, the Chinese standard in an Eng medium school can be equally good. All of the above lead to a very difficult decision to be made.