12網華仁, St. Joseph 和高主教那間最谷?

yingsumyee

12網華仁, St. Joseph 和高主教那間最谷?

cmchang0927

回覆 JMSS 的帖子

谷的定義?功課量?如果功課量，高記就算少。我大女讀12網女津校，功課量和默書測考量比高記細仔都多

rognfan

請問那間是偽名校

matsushima

hkpapa852 發表於 15-9-10 10:37
其實好多"名校", 根本唔係坊間所謠傳咁恐佈, 反而D"偽名校", 為咗搏上位先至恐佈
...

絕對正確

JMSS

原帖由 yingsumyee 於 15-09-10 發表
本帖最後由 yingsumyee 於 15-9-10 10:25 編輯

12網華仁, St. Joseph 和高主教那間最谷?

高主教

dunstany

回覆 hkpapa852 的帖子

Cannot agree more.

KikiDaddy

回覆 hkpapa852 的帖子

Agreed with you WYHK can disclose its DSE results in a more transparent way.
However, the 19% of 5* and above and 6% of 5** (not exact figures but estimates from the bar charts) are already pretty close to other Band 1A boys' schools like LS and SJC.

Based on the Distinction rate, the local university admission rate should be very good unless its Chinese subject results are really bad.

hkpapa852

KikiDaddy 發表於 15-9-16 21:41
回覆 lugano 的帖子

From the 2013/14 Annual Report published in its website, WYHK 2014 DSE results a ...

The 5 or above % cannot reflect the average performance of the all students.

The average 3 or above % even can say is a misleading index.

Honestly, I think the info in WY annual report was written in quite "tricky" style.

Chinese is one of the subject most schools have difficulties to get high scores, the average 3 or above % may give a "false" idea to readers about the 3322 ratio of the school.

In WY report, it only show the "average 3 or above %", instead of show the 3 or above % of Chinese, which seems want to made the reader think the "3322 ratio" of WY is better than the real one.

In addition, there is another "tricky" thing, with refer to the following statement in 2nd paragraph of P.8 (P.9 of the doc):

Most of our students chose to further their studies locally. Of those who did so, about 65% were offered degree programmes.

So, what is the % of student offered degree programmes exactly? 65%? No, it should be lower than 65% because the report did not mention how many students had furthered their study locally.

The % of student enrolled in degree programmes = % of student further study locally x 65%

It may be 60%, 50% or even just 30%, only the school can tell you.

When compare with other school's DSE data, WY is quite protective.

cyhh

如果三間做比較，咁St Jo和華仁的名氣，真係大過高主教呀，始終幾十年歷史嘅學校同百年老校係有距離，成績上我唔識比較，可能st jo、華仁好d，但高小亦唔係差，如果三間可以同時選擇，揀St Jo/華仁係好正路，但⋯⋯⋯高小係要放棄抽獎嘅私校，如果今年11月考到高小，就要諗吓會唔會去博抽另外2間，但12網係一念天堂、一念地獄的，我自己舊年就寧願一鳥在手，好過百鳥在林

wchnyl

回覆 Nbranson 的帖子

陳奕迅讀SJPS不是SJC。

wchnyl

回覆 lugano 的帖子

聖若瑟 / 香港華仁 / 高主教

其實三間都有D淵源。

聖若瑟書院 Wiki - 前身是成立於1860年的聖救世主書院（St. Saviour's College），是葡資私立學校，原址位於砵典乍街。當時的天主教香港教區主教 "高主教" 神父（Father Timoleon Raimondi）說服了羅馬教廷派出喇沙會修士到香港殖民地。1875年11月7日，第一批共六人的喇沙會修士來到了香港。他們把學校改名為聖若瑟書院。


香港華仁書院 Wiki - ....... 徐仁壽先生生於1889年，………入讀"聖若瑟書院"，故篤信天主教。 畢業後到廣東梅縣任教中學，四年後回到母校聖若瑟書院任教。1919年，徐仁壽毅然獨自創立華仁書院，其後更邀得舊同事林海瀾先生一同辦學………1925年在九龍設分校……毅然將心血結晶，親手創立的華仁書院付予耶穌會接辦。"
........ 香港華仁書院於 1921年遷往半山羅便臣道 2 號較大校舍(即 "高主教書院" 現址)..1932年 9 月並以相鄰的羅便臣道 8號前"聖若瑟書院" 南座校舍作擴充.....。


高主教書院 Wiki - 1955年， 高主教書院的名稱來自一名宗座外方傳教會會士，高雷門主教（Bishop Timoleon Raimondi）。高雷門主教在1827年出生，曾於1874年至1894年從義大利米蘭遠赴香港傳教，並成為香港第一任宗座代牧。...... "香港華仁書院"  遷往皇后大道東新校舍。1958年4月1日，適值宗座外方傳教會慶祝來港服務100周年，高主教書院由當時的教區主教白英奇主教奠基興建，並邀請訪港的教廷傳信部部長雅靜安樞機（Cardinal Agagianian）為該校主持祝聖。

ecml

原帖由 hkpapa852 於 15-09-10 發表
其實好多"名校", 根本唔係坊間所謠傳咁恐佈, 反而D"偽名校", 為咗搏上位先至恐佈
...

認同

KikiDaddy

回覆 lugano 的帖子

From the 2013/14 Annual Report published in its website, WYHK 2014 DSE results are actually pretty good.

http://web.wahyan.edu.hk/attachments/article/289/School%20Annual%20Report%202013-14%20for%20public.pdf

The Distinction rate (>5) is more than 30% which is very good among all boys' schools. It may not be as good as other top tier schools like QC but is better than its brother school WYK and comparable to Sing Yin - a boys' school with very good public examination results in recent years.

lovebb2

原帖由 karen55407 於 15-09-16 發表

弓起

karen55407

sissysze

原帖由 karen55407 於 15-09-16 發表

叻仔

retriever

回覆 lugano 的帖子

"聖若瑟數據為 3.2 (16狀元 ÷5班),
喇沙數據為 3.85 (27狀元 ÷7班),
香港華仁數據為 4.25 (17狀元 ÷4班),
最勁的都是 QC, 數據為 11 (55狀元÷5班), 真的寫個服字。"



咁樣都可以計個平均數, 真係也寫個服字...




睇到有人話高記精英班仲叻D....




話時話, 高記有收女仔, 學業成績及要求高D , 可以預料之中喎

karen55407

所以之前估錯晒啦！

karen55407

sissysze

原帖由 karen55407 於 15-09-16 發表
$2000一張飯飛😱

你阿囝插咗去邊似乎呼之欲出..... 我有無估錯呢