音樂學前班：香兒 or 通利?

dociousbaby

想請教用家意見，那一家俾較可培養或認清幼兒音樂天份（我不希望只似another playgroup)....
thanks!

picture

原帖由 dociousbaby 於 16-04-08 發表
Thank you picture! I have now enrolled my son with Tom Lee.. he is in the 3 year old class and think ...

BTW

I didnt join香兒 so can comment on it.   please seek others feedback.

picture

原帖由 puichingforsure 於 16-04-11 發表
我都有興趣JMC呀！但我又怕個別老師教的效果會不一樣（我怕遇到HEA老師），請問你是那一區的TOM LEE，有冇 ...

聽說 日籍老師較嚴格。

我的老師 雖然跟curriculum教亦都好knowledgable,  但佢style係好「就」小朋友的。 我本身唔mind因為興趣班，唔想逼。

socute

推，有無人上過天后center

dociousbaby

Thank you picture! I have now enrolled my son with Tom Lee.. he is in the 3 year old class and think it steps up to JMC.. he seems to enjoy it!

picture

原帖由 dociousbaby 於 15-05-18 發表
i see, helpful info. thank you.

I love tom lee JMC

My child enjoys it.  You get to sing,  move to. muaic,  learn basic theory., practice identifying pitch,  be exposed to contempory music rather than just classical.

It is a good introductory course to music taught in a fun and modern way.

even though some children can't play well towards the end of JMC 4 (stages 1 to 4),  they can identify harmonies well.

Children will have learnt 4 majors and 2 minor cadences by end of JMC 4.

Better performing children will start to acquire relative pitch ability.

dociousbaby

Jane1983 發表於 15-5-14 16:37
我小朋友K1時亦參加過通利10堂的音樂班，不知道是不是你指那個。我們上的那一個，就相當類似音樂playgroup ...

i see, helpful info. thank you.

Jane1983

我小朋友K1時亦參加過通利10堂的音樂班，不知道是不是你指那個。我們上的那一個，就相當類似音樂playgroup，因為小朋友仲係，啓發為主，教吾到太多實質野。

dociousbaby

sorry i mean JMC, not YMC..

dociousbaby

回覆 Jane1983 的帖子

Thank you for your sharing - 很有道理。

我看過YMC的簡介, 對這course都有興趣。但小朋友未到4歲, 現時只有YMC之前的幼兒班.  請問你小朋友有無參加過？我看過class time video, 感覺有點似playgroup 所以想聽聽家長意見。

Jane1983

如果小朋友好細個，都係培養興趣，多過認清音樂天份。

我小朋友無讀過香兒音樂班，但一路有讀通利的Yamaha，讀完Jmc，經audition被挑選加入精英班Jsac。我小朋友音樂上有佢的優點，但其他同學亦好強，有6、7歲已經演奏能力超強的。香港音樂叻的小朋友好多，就算有天份亦要放好多時間、精神和資源。將目標放在認清天份，可能有點太目標為本，因為即使無天份，只要有興趣，音樂對小朋友的成長其實好好。