小朋友寫自己中文名

h9800318

小一Interview會考小朋友寫自己中文名嗎？而家K2學校仲未要小朋友寫

佈太

回覆 picture 的帖子

Interesting...  I doubt that it had anything to do with colonial time.  Chinese has always been taught this way.  (Colonial rule was only 99yrs long)  It is only recently that I have seen people trying to teach Chinese characters based on their shapes...  the way of teaching children is much more advance now than they were before, I am sure that kids were just told to copy copy and copy.  Just like in old European times where children are not allowed to write left handed too...  but we have now all moved on from there.     

I have said nothing about stubborness.  I am just saying "chill out".  There is such a thing as learning for learning's sake or doing tests merely to appear that you are doing something with the kids at school or at home.  Kids are not puppets.  We all know that once you leave school, nothing they required from us in tests are used.  Once you are at work, you have all the time to research and find out ways of doing things and getting along with work colleagues are WAY more important than being able to write a word in the correct stroke order.

picture

原帖由 佈太 於 15-03-08 發表
I would have thought that if you repeatedly write the same word in the same way, you learn how to wr ...

For most schools in HK, writing with wrong pencil grip, order of strokes for both.Chinese and English are cobsidered WRONG!


Like it or not it is how it is.

You might argue that it is acceptable in US or Canada or Australia...etc  which I know it is.  It is not in HK.


I would not say people in HK are stubborn.  I support it too because I believe children should learn the right way of writing in school.  And they can have the liberty to write in whatever way they like when they grow up.

I once met an English teacher who cane from the UK and has been teaching in British school for many years that she insists her students to learn to write the alphabets correctly also.  So I gathered that it is our heritage from the British during colonial era.that we do things on a rather strict way. 😉

bubuG

如果每個人是是但但自創一套筆順，加上殘體字入侵，中文正體字加速滅忘。

Ryan_baba

Jane1983 發表於 15-3-9 07:40
吾係咁分析，有些嚴的學校，老師見到寫字筆順錯，會當錯，同埋會鬧。

有小學考試要考中文字筆順添，會問「我」字的第四劃是邊一筆。

Jane1983

吾係咁分析，有些嚴的學校，老師見到寫字筆順錯，會當錯，同埋會鬧。

bubuG

原帖由 佈太 於 15-03-08 發表
I would have thought that if you repeatedly write the same word in the same way, you learn how to wr ...

I also meant the "stroke order" of English alphabet. You are ok if your child writes the alphabet in a bottom to top direction instead of top to bottom ?

佈太

I would have thought that if you repeatedly write the same word in the same way, you learn how to write the word.  

It's like drawing a triangle, does it matter which side you start with?  But if you always start with the same side, then eventually, you will always start with that side and your triangle is still a triangle.  I could see that some chinese characters are so complicated that if you start somewhere else, you will get the proportions wrong....  but that's the only reason I would agree with having to write the strokes in a certain order...

I would argue that it's the repetition that is important and not the order it comes in....  but Chinese have enforced the kids to write in a certain way for so long that it became, "that's the only way to write a word", even though in reality if you draw a line from right to left rather than left to write, makes no difference to the word.  Except you would get told off by anyone who sees you drawing a line from right to left...

Ryan_baba

佈太 發表於 15-3-8 19:55
Why does it matter whether the child writes his name in the correct order?  We use pencil or biro no ...

認識筆順是有助學習中文寫。
http://mandarin.nccu.edu.tw/data/teacher/103/10301.pdf

佈太

No I meant the stroke orders.  If he got the stroke orders wrong, noone will notice as long as ever stroke is there.  If my son spells his name correctly I have no problem if he starts with the last letter first and go from right to left.  :)

In fact, my son writes his name mirror imaged.  Quite talented.  It's wrong though so I tell him to write it the other way but praise him for having the ability to do it mirror imaged.  I can't.

bubuG

原帖由 佈太 於 15-03-08 發表
Why does it matter whether the child writes his name in the correct order?  We use pencil or biro no ...

if your child writes English letters from bottom to top , are u ok ?

佈太

Why does it matter whether the child writes his name in the correct order?  We use pencil or biro now a days, unless you intend on your child writing caligraphy, it doesnt really matter if he writes his name in the wrong order.

jason1978

我覺得我為仔仔舖排得最好嘅事係為佢改單名，方便第二罰抄抄少隻字。so far k2現在寫名寫得唔錯

sissysze

原帖由 little_yolky 於 15-03-04 發表
所以我真係唔太理解有D家長幫小朋友改個好難寫既名為乜, 我囡囡同學仔有個 "璽" 字, 諗起都鄧佢辛苦。:hehe ...

而家啲女好 like 用  “懿 ”

小寶貝兒

我女好早就已經識寫英文名(不過係我地改的, 冇落出世紙, 雖然果陣已經改左, 但怕將來佢唔鐘意又要改好麻煩, 早知個女咁鐘意就落埋啦, 唔洗煩!), 教認同寫字母係由佢名開始先, 一黎簡單, 二黎佢個名的字母都係直劃, 冇曲線, 好易學~

中文就未教佢, 睇黎要快D開始教~

little_yolky

sbux 發表於 15-3-5 18:31
前嗰輪有幾個新樓盤用呢個字起名，風水師話呢個字用受得起先好用



  ...

佢個名三個字都咁難寫, 我斷估都係風水師傅既傑作

sbux

原帖由 little_yolky 於 15-03-04 發表
所以我真係唔太理解有D家長幫小朋友改個好難寫既名為乜, 我囡囡同學仔有個 "璽" 字, 諗起都鄧佢辛苦。:hehe ...

前嗰輪有幾個新樓盤用呢個字起名，風水師話呢個字用受得起先好用

little_yolky

mimics218 發表於 15-3-4 14:21
絕對認同"認人好過識字"!

經過考幼稚園同小學之後, 我地呢啲全無關係人士, 真係要"認命".

所以當初見老公個姓咁鬼難寫, 我就決意小朋友個名其中一個字一定係個 "一" 字, 大囡個名兩個字加埋11劃, 細囡得8劃, 佢哋學得好快。好一段時間, 細囡寫工作紙時, 堅決唔寫個姓, 因為個姓一個字要寫16劃

little_yolky

mimics218 發表於 15-3-3 19:56
唔關係咪考試事, 自己個名係一定要識寫!

小朋友個名好複雜, 剛4歲示範左3次, 已經自己記哂, 跟住自己練

我哋老師係逐個教, 然後响中文簿人人起字頭寫。