讀醫成績

Jilli

youma 發表於 14-6-23 20:43
If all candidates with 41 (4C+3X) are admitted, does it mean that CU counts merely academic results  ...

I think "All candidates" means the students with 41 (4C+3X) and "satisfactory performance in the interview".

Obviously it is impossible for medic to intake students only by considering the results, esp. CUHK medic which counts more on the interview. In CUHK medic's interview, the format is 2 prof. vs 1 student, which can really test the students' ability to deal with difficulties (prof. like to ask difficult questions and require immediately responds).

Earlier in this post, there is a student with 41.5 (4C+3X) but he is also rejected by CUHK med. I can be sure there are some other cases.  In addition, in the old HKALE, even 3A students can be rejected by medic.

Interview maybe isn't really important in other subjects, but is crucial in medic.

youma

qingdynasty 發表於 14-6-22 19:14
回覆 jessimm 的帖子

The official speaker from CU Medic Admission told talk attendants on 21/6 that they admitted ALLcandidates with 41 points while only one with 40.5 was admitted last year.  Is your information accurate about 41.5 being rejected or purely a rare case being rejected for "not showing proper attitude to become a good doctor" (as how they put it) or some other reasons?

If all candidates with 41 (4C+3X) are admitted, does it mean that CU counts merely academic results regardless of interview performance? Tks.

qingdynasty

回覆 jessimm 的帖子

Thanks.

jessimm

回覆 qingdynasty 的帖子

Anyways, there are two successful cases with 35(4c+2x) 41(4c+3x) points being admitted in 2013. One of them took chem/bio/econ, the other took phy/chem/bio. According to the student helper's information delivered yesterday, DSE candidates with 41 points or above are very likely  to be given an offer from CU medic provided that the interview performance is satisfactory.

qingdynasty

回覆 jessimm 的帖子

The official speaker from CU Medic Admission told talk attendants on 21/6 that they admitted ALLcandidates with 41 points while only one with 40.5 was admitted last year.  Is your information accurate about 41.5 being rejected or purely a rare case being rejected for "not showing proper attitude to become a good doctor" (as how they put it) or some other reasons?

annie40

最難是「服侍」病人，要非常慈愛的人，才能做到。遊走於非常有同理心，又邏輯性地平常心之間，鬆容包容，非常人也。

ANChan59

原帖由 liloNstitch 於 14-05-22 發表
我意思係~~超晒同佢一齊讀果一班,

科學探索無極限, 我當然唔會認為甘係超班

If compare with mainlanders, may be just mediocre.

liloNstitch

friendlyguy 發表於 14-5-22 11:41
讀 science，點叻都唔會超班，如果有 passion，唔會浪費。

我意思係~~超晒同佢一齊讀果一班,

科學探索無極限, 我當然唔會認為甘係超班

friendlyguy

liloNstitch 發表於 14-5-22 11:25
41分讀science超晒班, 浪費左d
41.5分  報 MEDICINE, NEXT CHOICE 風馬牛不相及, 呢位同學對MEDICAL FIELD  ...

讀 science，點叻都唔會超班，如果有 passion，唔會浪費。

liloNstitch

jessimm 發表於 14-5-16 23:38
2013 unsuccessful cases of CUHK medicine

4c+2x  4c+3x  interview                                   ...

41分讀science超晒班, 浪費左d
41.5分  報 MEDICINE, NEXT CHOICE 風馬牛不相及, 呢位同學對MEDICAL FIELD 既 PASSION 有限, 唔收都係岩既

judywan

唔知HKU遲啲會唔會又話,讀醫唔使要phy chem bio。

jessimm

回覆 qingdynasty 的帖子

All of them took phy chem bio. Coincidentally, none of them got 5* or 5** in English

qingdynasty

For the CUHK medic unsuccessful cases, what are their 3 electives subjects?

jessimm

judy 發表於 14-4-30 15:44
去年，以6科最高25%, 50%, 最低25%和最低分數計：
港大: 39,38,37,36.
中大*:37,36,35 (中大無公佈最低分). ...

2013 unsuccessful cases of CUHK medicine

4c+2x  4c+3x  interview                                      result
33       39        no                                                Physiotherapy (HKPU)
34       40        yes (school nomination)              Dentistry (HKU)
35       41        yes                                               Science (HKU)
36       41.5     yes                                               IFAA/Qfin (CUHK)

It seems that interview performance is so crucial.

judy

仲有一樣最简單嘅嘢，不過啲人死蠢咁都諗唔到:

想讀醫嘅人，明知中大收4+3x，佢會唔會走去考4+2x 呢？

judy

It is definitely brainless to make a conclusion based on the the score of 4+2x while the requirement is 4+3x. For example, do you think that students with 35+5, 36+4 can be admitted to medicine or not  

我凈係話中大 4+2x 的最低分可能是34。根據2013中大嘅出生資料，最低1/4 4+2x 收生為35。

當然，我知道中大收4+3x，但最後一科，應是最差嘅，所以，4+3x.為35+5有咩出奇呢？

港大雖然話收 4+2x，但，佢收生中，有幾多冇考7科呢？佢收生中，有幾多第7科差過中大呢？要知道，成績越好的人，選修越多科。

samsam123321

解剖條屍係處理過，基本上無血，無屍味。
但真屍係血淋淋，同有機會有屍味。