真道書院

littlekkl

真道直上嘅真道書院，知唔知band幾？

stepyau

Thanks. I know it's not apple to apple comparison, but can we say, LA Chi A + Eng B = most of IS' Eng A + Chi B, just that other IB schools, like CKY, they attempted the TRUE bilingual diploma, i.e. Chi A + Eng A.  

hkparent

原帖由 stepyau 於 14-04-15 發表
好奇一問，國際學校一般讀Eng A Chi B，還是兩個都係A？

Almost all IS take Eng A, and Chi B or even ab (lower level), or French/Spanish B or ab. They can't fight with Logos on Chinese :(

So, if you target local universities, Logos is a good choice.
If you target overseas universities and want native oral English and don't want to take Chi A, international schools are good choices.

stepyau

好奇一問，國際學校一般讀Eng A Chi B，還是兩個都係A？

thomastaxi

U better go to esf or Chinese int school website and check out the ib exam result. See what uni the graduates are going to.
Most of them are taking Ib and eng a.
Remember I am talking about the norm.
For genius or very smart and hard working students, they can shine in any school. La is cherry-picking the very best.

Also, take a detailed look in the gov issued IA report a few years before. U will feel funny after u find out the old headmaster spent 150k( some saying 2 mio) in training mainland school principal

penguin_chick

回覆 thomastaxi 的帖子

Does  average 38 show that they can compete with any IS?

ChiChiPaPa

回覆 thomastaxi 的帖子

其他學校臨考DSE前應不會repeat，但會drop科。

thomastaxi

repeat before taking dse
not after
normally it is zero for other schools

poonseelai

原帖由 thomastaxi 於 14-04-14 發表
I think la is not the right school for a lot of us. For ib. I can see they are not providing a stron ...

5%學生選擇重讀，這比例同其他學校比較是否偏高？

thomastaxi

I think la is not the right school for a lot of us. For ib. I can see they are not providing a strong English speaking environment.
How can they compete with those native speakers and those from international schools? Remember other candidates from elite schools have got a year more to prepare for the examination

For dse exam half memorize half analyze a lot of local students are good at memorizing things. La have not pushed students in the primary school and I am afraid the students just hate doing so when in secondary school.

From the biology perspective a man will get matured in the brain development at around 20 years old. I can't tell my boy is a genius or not but I think he is not likely as a matter of statistics

And as a matter of fact 5per cents of the dse candidates in la chose to repeat before taking dse. So all people know the disadvantage of a 11 years education

If they extend the curriculum a year further, it would be totally different, if I am going to send my kids abroad at 14 years old, la could be a good choice.

AgapePa

HaYi 發表於 14-4-14 16:19
如果由學生自選, 選的人數多過可以開IB的人數 (因直資政府限定只有一定比例的能選IB), 校方會用甚麼機制來 ...

係簡介會, 學校講首要睇英文水平, 英文一定要好好先可以選IB.

HaYi

如果由學生自選, 選的人數多過可以開IB的人數 (因直資政府限定只有一定比例的能選IB), 校方會用甚麼機制來選學生?

ozoz

原帖由 HaYi 於 14-04-14 發表
我個曾為真道收錄, 很多朋友就讀真道, 亦響往IB,  雖現在另一間普通制小學就讀, 都仍在看中學轉入IB的可能 ...

我以前喺外國讀書，讀公立學校，咁啱學校有IB,讀完grade 12可以選讀，要grade 12𠹭科達某個水平再加埋做assessment。到咁大個人,自己知自己有冇能力或者啱唔啱讀，我當年無讀因為自己習慣傳統港式背誦，都幾肯定自己唔啱讀，無謂浪費自己時間，我自己情願專心考好local 省試，考入自己想讀嘅學科好過啦。當時IB並非有乜大不了，人各有志，人人唔同，有同學有能力考，我地不知幾高興，鄧佢開心。至於真道，現在由學生自己選擇DSE 定IB, 無人知約干年後會否有assessment 之類先比讀𠺢。

FZMM

AgapePa 發表於 14-4-12 14:47
其實"全港第三"呢句係今年簡介會, 學校講嘅.
有去聽簡介會都知.
而且今年改由中二選IB, 早D預備.

Agreed....雖然我囡今年先IN 都係因為BUY佢個教育理念. 希望有機會成為一份子.

Rachelmummy2008

我揀真道呀！
囡囡自信有禮，合群開朗。

HaYi

我個曾為真道收錄, 很多朋友就讀真道, 亦響往IB,  雖現在另一間普通制小學就讀, 都仍在看中學轉入IB的可能性, 因為始終覺得長遠地說IB會更符合自己的目標 , 所以特別留意EK IB的討論, 尤其是真正用家的見解十分好, 所以多方面的意見請多提出, 會幫助我們此些有興趣的家長厘清對IB不明白的地方.

關於真道, 如果以樓上一貼所說, 未來將不再是以成績排位取入IB, 那如何界定主誰可讀, 希望真道家長指明一下. 當然真道是有自己的學制, 外來生想在中學階段入讀IB 都不是一件易事.

behappydad

真道事件，忘了嗎？

ozoz

原帖由 littlefaith 於 14-04-13 發表
本帖最後由 littlefaith 於 14-4-13 18:28 編輯

未決定讀真道前，我的確有擔心過取考，缺德等問題。由於太少數據，太新，好小例子參考，只好爬文，爬文亦不能信晒表面所講，要自己分析，去請教下用家了解長短處。問教授朋友亦係其中一個參考，佢一定知道班畢業生有冇料同埋態度。當然啦，大學咁大，教授唔會知全部學系同學嘅嘢，起碼佢同朋友傾開，加埋睇自己d學生會知多d實況，比我自己作參考亦不錯。有家長提出過，如果讀老牌名校，老世好多時遇到師弟妹，有機會幫一把，呢樣我都有諗過，最終我覺得個人嘅工作態度，能否與人相處，有思考有判斷力先係真正對工作仕途有最大影響，所以我唔再介意學校年資，反而注意間學校點去教育我小朋友。我有個親人任職某大機構高層，佢專責請人，能夠見佢嘅求職者已經係經過多重考驗，的而且確，見到師妹會有興趣見下，可惜係近年佢越見越覺得失望，甚至有高分低能出現，未到見佢已經被foul, 結局都未必會請神級學校畢業嘅師妹。

講返近d, DSE, IB 分數，呢個對我黎講係參考。我係怪媽，唔會希望或者鋪路比女兒入大學，大學畢業，我要求佢態度正面，知自己做乜，識分析事物，有良好語文基礎作溝通工具。人生係佢嘅，將來做乜，點做，自己決定。了解多咗真道，相信同我理念相近，所以我選佢。過多幾年，我會更加深入了解，到時可以再分享多d。

ozoz

原帖由 ChiChiPaPa 於 14-04-13 發表
我相信被負面批評的應該不是國際學校學生。

國際學校只係教法不同，喺香港讀國際學校，家庭資源一定係較豐足，學生即使成績唔好都有資源請額外老師教，但一樣可以有高分低能，有叻學生亦有學術成績唔理想。