民生 pm vs St Cat am?

papamama1113

Pls advise any comment. Thanks.

DCMaMe

回覆 AAAFamily 的帖子

我小孩未讀過SC，只能從朋友的小孩表現或朋友的評價去講。
民幼上年開始有NET做班主任，所以英文的時間係等同上課的時間，我諗呢點同SC一樣。我唔太Sure SC 現在K2是否都有NET做班主任，民幼3年都係有NET的。

但SC的學生有一定的數目，父母係偏向操英文的，所以SC的學生感覺上英語唔錯。我自己亦有些朋友本身係回流香港，所以家中都係普遍英語，小孩英語程度完全不成問題。但同時亦有朋友普通香港家庭，媽媽加工人照顧，平日主要講中文，雖然由2歲開始去ESF 學英文，加埋入左SC後跟一些媽媽去幫小朋友補英文，不過英語程度一定普通過普通。

我家小孩，小時只懂說英語，在2歲多才學講中文，所以在民幼佢的英文水平亦算唔錯。不過眼見民幼的家長好似單純D，好多都係好普通的香港家庭，在家中文為主，所以普遍學生都講中文多過英文，呢點我估係唔同的。

By the way，講咁多其實係想帶出，語言係要運用才發揮到，學校幫的只可以話係小小。我覺得家庭環境重要D。

AAAFamily

原帖由 DCMaMe 於 14-01-07 發表
The same situation last year, MS finally without regret !!!

But no problem to me as I had prioritis ...

How is the experience in Munsang K1? Is the English language environment competitive as compared with SC?

DCMaMe

The same situation last year, MS finally without regret !!!

But no problem to me as I had prioritised my rank before result announced.  

papamama1113

原帖由 arkops 於 14-01-05 發表
請問大家是在談在北角的民生嗎？北角的民生差很遠嗎？

係九龍民生。

Aprilbaby

原帖由 arkops 於 14-01-05 發表
請問大家是在談在北角的民生嗎？北角的民生差很遠嗎？

我諗講梗九龍民幼，因為北角ms好似唔系龍校

winnietingting

原帖由 volar 於 14-01-06 發表
如果你唔鍾意民小，根本唔需要考慮民幼啦！

yes, 如樓主like民小，民幼啦。if not, st cat.

abby0624

唔鐘意民小，一定要St. Cat啦

volar

winnietingting 發表於 14-1-6 07:58
but if don't like 民小; target Dgjs; ......

still sure 100%????

如果你唔鍾意民小，根本唔需要考慮民幼啦！

winnietingting

原帖由 OSMrLai 於 14-01-06 發表
For me, 100% MS for sure.
It is a totally different game (3 years later) if u get a backup on hand.  ...

but if don't like 民小; target Dgjs; ......

still sure 100%????

OSMrLai

For me, 100% MS for sure.
It is a totally different game (3 years later) if u get a backup on hand.
The drawback is you cannot join the lucky draw for primary school but you can still apply those private school or else.

Moonlight819

SC

fishmaruko

If not join lucky draw is ok, of course choose through train school la

arkops

請問大家是在談在北角的民生嗎？北角的民生差很遠嗎？

wipebb

我都有sc 同民生offer, 但我會選民生

fishmaruko

First, MS is a very good school, the kinder has many opportunity to borden the horizon, which other school cannot has this opportunity
MS primary also good standard, and many extra curricilar activities

So if you think u will study MS P, and will not lucky draw, of course MS
Bcos if in other kinder without primary, finally 都是考類似民小的小學，
No need to border again

Cheerglory

民生三年幼稚園雙班主任制，每日有net 班主任陪你小朋友講足3個鐘英文，英文吾會差過sc，但band one英中龍校backup的話， 進可攻， 退可守，sc無得比。

AAAFamily

原帖由 Busybody! 於 14-01-03 發表
民生考直資私校成果如何？

好少聽到關於民幼升其他私/直小的數據。唔知有冇sisters有啲idea?

conniew117

回覆 Busybody! 的帖子

去年有同學仔, 考到陸慶濤,英華, 陳守仁, 德望, 蔡繼有...