港生英文羞家僱主頭痛

cow

吾知邊年(200X)起無佐guarante, 有JD後入PCLL更難. London U external LLB 60 分2:1. 無佐guarante後, 55分都入到PCLL, 宜家要成60 分先入到.

cow

以前 HKU SPACE 讀London U external LLB, pass degree 就guarantee 入PCLL.

cow

如果宜家讀London U extern LLB 入倒PCLL, 英文唔會太差. 讀law , 英文差, 好難攞高分.

cow

好多讀LLB校外課程的人,都只是想增加法律知識, 並無打算做律師. 近年畢業的律師IELTS要有7分, 以前無這要求. 因之前有D律師的英文真係好差.

item

ANChan59 發表於 13-11-18 11:06
這篇集中講法律系學生，但沒有講那一間大學。

小女有兩個同學 A Level 英文攞A，但那一年競爭劇烈，只能入到中大Law，這兩個同學英文都很好，如果有講法律系學生都被投訴，我想應是⋯⋯⋯那間。

chunyatmama

WKDRB 發表於 13-11-19 15:42
"但寫同文法就俾外國人强。"

根本冇可能，除非是同啲冇乜讀書嘅外國人比。要比較，應該是同一大學同一學係 ...

In fact, when I was in the University, my supervisor of my dissertation advised me to find someone to proof read my draft before submitting to her.  She said her gramma is not good as she have not really learnt gramma.  That's what she said.

After some years later, I worked for a company under an English.  He also advised me that his gramma is not good. He asked me to proof read his email or advise to a lawyer.  Sometimes, I raise some questions on English, he has to ask his wife in order to provide me a good answer.

irene_e

以前我讀書嘅年代就話我地啲英文聽同講差，但寫同文法就俾外國人强。點解課程改革左咁多次，依家會仲俾以前差！攪到依家樣樣唔到岸。。。

chunyatmama

iodine 發表於 13-11-19 09:38
上一代要批評下一代係一件好容易的事，因為上一代真係做多幾十年人。
啱啱畢業個D＂專業人仕＂叫trainee,顧 ...

I tend to agree with you.  For Law Degree, it really depends on which University that the passage referred to.  Even for other professional degree, I can really tell one of the University graduates are comparatively weak.

Besides, if the company is renowned, even if they pay less, they can always attract good graduates/trainees.

iodine

上一代要批評下一代係一件好容易的事，因為上一代真係做多幾十年人。
啱啱畢業個D＂專業人仕＂叫trainee,顧名思義，仲要比人教。

要screen英語能力亦十分簡單，叫晒D candidate一人作一篇文就知。
要鬧，關埋房門鬧。一個律師同人講你D靚英文屎。原因一係無揀過，一係出手低，一係你檔野豆泥。

cow

CityU LLB
HKAL Use of English minimum C
HKDSE English 2012 min (5), 2013 min(5*)

ANChan59

你誤會了，是自我感覺良好!

shadeslayer

item 發表於 13-11-18 15:48
港大畢業生拿6分，是讀那個學糸? 水泡科?

係教育局評英文六分到七分的為良好至優異，即大學生畢業拿個六分還叫良好。

shadeslayer

Artie 發表於 13-11-18 17:01
收幾多分？

高分低能也可以。