Drama Class - Teacher Mark

lfcdhsbc

I overheard students talking about the drama class teacher.  They used the word "hate" to describe the class and the teacher.
They said honest students were punished while liars could escape punishment.
If this is how the students are thinking, what actually are the students being taught?
Why?  Anybody knows?
Should the school look into it?

bjdadishe

我八到多少資料, 分享一下.
這老師在堂上只是口頭要求學生回家做這做那, 有學生聽不太明白, 也有英語水平較好的學生說老師的要求不明確不夠清楚, 結果呢, 學生沒有依指示做足, 就被罰.
有些英語水平好的學生, 雖沒有依老師指示溫習, 由於英語根底好, 表現中規中矩, 問佢有沒有溫書, 只能說有, 結果無被罰.
有些英文水平低的學生, 另別人溫習十五分鐘, 佢已溫了五十分鐘了, 但表現還是不好, 結果被罰.
這情況的客觀後果是, 水平高的學生不再溫書, 水平低的學生反正都被罰也不想溫書.
這老師的罰留堂也沒有跟學校的指引, 因為他沒有把功課的明確要求放在ECLASS. 如果他把功課的明確要求放在ECLASS, 讓堂上聽不懂的同學可以翻閱, 若同學依然不做, 再罰留堂就算公平.
樓上的家長, 請不要叫我向學校反映, 因為以上的情況並不發生在我女兒的班中, 所以沒有資格投訴, 而告訴我的學生又不敢向校長反映, 怕被針對.

JadeW

Just to explain my view

lfcdhsbc

No need to be defensive.

JadeW

Hmm.... I hate Chinese history, history and even Chinese in the past and I hate some of the teachers as well. But I won't think it is that serious as everyone has heir preference of subject and teachers.  Some teacher you hate may be a good teacher and some teacher the kids love may be a bad teacher indeed.  Time will tell.

lfcdhsbc

I overhead a conversation between 3 or 4 students.  I don't know them and I don't know what class or what grade they are in.  I am not sure if I could recognize them if I see them again.  
Some parents or teachers may know more than I.  That's why I posted it here to give it a try, hoping someone may have more info to follow up.
Maybe it is misunderstanding.  And I do hope it is a misunderstanding.
But when a group of students hate a subject,  that itself, right or wrong, qualifies as an issue to be taken up.

JadeW

I think Maybe u should report to the school or class teacher instead of talking here as no one knows what really happened.