以一間無直屬中學的小學來計, 幾多%入到Band 1英中才算理想

cmir

如題
Please share your opinion

taktakchichi

最有透明度係APS, SFA 同TSL, 升中派位都可以係網站睇到. 佢
地升上 Band 1 英中比率都好高, 尤其APS同TSL

pooh仔

原帖由 ha8mo 於 13-06-15 發表

你個表嘅小學升英中比率9x% ~ 100%

ANChan59

回復 iantsang 的帖子

Agree.
Some schools list out all placements in their websites, we can see the standard of those schools.

iantsang

回復 cmir 的帖子

I think there are few things to clarify:

(1) There are no banding on schools, neither secondary not primary schools, banding are only applied on P.6 students for their S1 allocation;

(2) A secondary school with all classes using English as medium of instructions may not be band 1, if they are under Direct Subsidized Scheme;

(3) A secondary school even if all classes using English as medium of instructions, can accept some band 2 students;

So basically if a school claims they have certain percentages entering EMI schools, usually I will discount about 10-20%, depends on what type of schools these students go to (aided or DSS), then this will be closer to the percentage of the school's band 1 student%.

For an aided school, above 40-45% is already good (considering turning 10% of band 2 to band 1 or swapping band 3 out with band 1 students in over the years :p), and above 50% for private schools is consider satisfactory.

cmir

回復 feiji 的帖子

that's true, especially it's a govt aided school.

feiji

回復 cmir 的帖子

cmir, I didn't verify his data.  I guess maybe it is not up-to-date then.  I guess 50% - 60% is already very good.

Bluegene

我覺得有50%以上入Band1都好叻

Bluegene

原帖由 ha8mo 於 13-06-15 發表
李鄭屋官立係南亞之星，大部分學生都要搵英中

擊中核心

cmir

回復 feiji 的帖子

but when i checked the school website...it's only around 60% for Band 1 英中. Please correct me if i am wrong

ANChan59

原帖由 ha8mo 於 13-06-15 發表
某校貼上網的剪報

好嘢！咁都俾你搵到。

我以前冇咁大想頭，50%英中已經十分滿意，100%冇諗過！

cautionchan

英中only , not band one secondary school ! Pls pay attention !

feiji

我突然醒起趙 sir 在一個 talk 裏説，全港的小學中，入band one 中學的 percentage 最高的是基灣，有約80%有多。

ANChan59

邊處搵到㗎？

babyedu

官立和基德絕冇可能100%英中

Anniemun

100%入英中，全級得嗰幾十人……

cmir

回復 ha8mo 的帖子

英中 but may not be Band 1...ahahahaa