Characteristics of IS kids

gigglelela

I'm struggling for IS and LS stream. Can anyone share with me what is the +ve and -ve impact on your kid for choosing IS? I have no question on English language skill. My key concern is more about discipline, Chinese core value and personality. If you don't mind, pls share your experience and the age of you kid. Thx.

cathygum

Cannot agree more!

minirat

luckyveronique 發表於 13-3-21 07:08
好同意你講的，我都算係填鴨教育制度下成長起來的一個乖乖女，由細到大習慣了按部就班，服從order，成績好 ...

同意！我都有同你類似的童年，所以現在都是一個“高級的打工仔”，穩穩陣陣，完全無冒險精神，無排除都同我個人性格有關。所以負擔得起就會俾仔仔讀IS，尤其我覺得一般男仔其實不太適合現在LS的教育方式，有少少難為了他們。穩穩陣陣唔系唔好，只是我真的唔想他太重視成績而忽略了生活和學習的樂趣。好贊成你最後講的“涉獵知識范圍更廣，目的都是為她將來可更好適應呢個瞬息萬變的社會”。 雖然唔知IS是否可以完全做到這點，我地做家長的至少盡力比一個機會他先。

luckyveronique

yuenru 發表於 13-3-20 23:30
Instead of defining the characteristic of an IS kid ,let's think about the differences of teaching.  ...

好同意你講的，我都算係填鴨教育制度下成長起來的一個乖乖女，由細到大習慣了按部就班，服從order，成績好，紀律好。到宜家，我都覺得自己缺少變通的精神，創新能力好一般姐，雖然我已是FTM，但如果繼續工作，我預左我至多仍舊是個“高級打工仔”。

所以到教育個女時，我一定比她讀IS條路，唔谷成績，卻思維活躍度更高，思考問題的角度同LS kids都會有DD不同，涉獵知識范圍更廣，目的都是為她將來可更好適應呢個瞬息萬變的社會

yuenru

Instead of defining the characteristic of an IS kid ,let's think about the differences of teaching.  My kids go to IS school ,instead of telling them what to-do and what not,most of the time ,I need to provide pros and cons and guide them to make judgement call from there own. On the other hand ,when I teach local school students in Sunday school , they tend not to question on things and obey what you said. in a way,it is much easier to handle an local school kid over an IS kid. IS system gives you the freedom to teach and it is rely more on parents how to think and provide guidance.

judymama

Btw, he is still a disciplined student in school.  
What i mean is IS provides them more freedom likes they can run around in school during play time while LS may not allow.

judymama

I mean when he was in LS.

錢錢媽

回復 judymama 的帖子

why did you say "He was ...." ?  :p
do you mean he is not disciplined now?!

minirat

crystalpui 發表於 13-3-20 09:33
係小一選校到有個TOPIC,話個仔有好多CERT, 好SMART, 咁入唔入到神級名校
(個人對那位家長沒有意見)
可想而 ...

好同意你講的
每個人的童年得一次
不過不是人人都可以負擔到IS
如果要應付LS，可能家長都有壓力
根本本地的教育制度本身就有問題

crystalpui

亦同大家分享下係教會時我女的表現
在K1-K3的活動中
我女喜歡主動幫手, 主動答問題
但靜態的聽故事亦都專心
所以我暫時發現唔到有discipline既問題

crystalpui

係小一選校到有個TOPIC,話個仔有好多CERT, 好SMART, 咁入唔入到神級名校
(個人對那位家長沒有意見)
可想而知, 係KINDER時小朋友會用左好多時間去上堂(學術的)
玩既時間相對會少左
我來講, 我鍾意小朋友細個要玩盡佢, 唔應該俾佢地有壓力係考學校上
佢地得個幾歲, 點解唔俾佢地玩?
書有排讀, 玩又可以玩幾耐?
唔係話我女無學野,
但佢學既, 都係佢自己REQUEST的
好似BALLET, DRAWING.....
而我只打算係今個SUMMER開始要佢學埋SWIMMING
其他中/數...遲D先再講
(我小朋友在IS讀K1)

aidan08

LEGOLAND 發表於 13-3-19 19:08
IS 小朋友比較天真，我笑我仔同佢D同學叫「迪士尼人」。至於中文唔中文，自己攪，唔好諗學校可以幫到。
LS ...

我都有同感，我覺得IS小朋友普遍上比較天真，無IS的咁老積，可能佢哋低年班d的都係玩耍中學習較多，無偃苗助長。LS的相對較成熟，細細個就要面對激烈競爭。

LEGOLAND

IS 小朋友比較天真，我笑我仔同佢D同學叫「迪士尼人」。至於中文唔中文，自己攪，唔好諗學校可以幫到。
LS放學要做約二個鐘頭功課+溫習，如果你小朋友用相同時間放喺中文，
你應該唔使擔心佢D中文。

davhui

Chinese Core Values? Corruption? Rule by people rather than law? Relationship over ability? Forget about it!

hkparent

Thank you.

gigglelela

What i got from yours sharing is very positive. I like IS the way of teaching. It seems develop the kid's way of thinking instead of just spoon feed them for examination. When the kid grown up, they need to find their own way and cannot rely on us to make all decision for them.

elmostoney

http://www.amazon.com/How-Build- ... ld+your+own+country

hkparent

Which book is it? Can you share?

elmostoney

我家孩子快七歲:

1.  愛看書
2.  超級鍾意同人玩 (又有時間玩), 好active
3.  對有興趣嘅事物會有興趣自己用唔同方法去表達同學多d, 如近期佢迷上mozart, 連mozart成家人出生日期都要知; 佢鍾意煮野食, 會嘗試自己設計食譜; 佢鍾意歷史, 聽得多睇得多, 最近睇緊一本教小朋友建立自己國家嘅書, 佢又自己list down設計自己國家. 我覺得幾creative.

negative:

主要都係中文弱d.

judymama

My boy was in LS kinder before and now in IS.  What i feel happy is he developed a highly confident, outspoken and socialised character in IS and it is very obvious.  comparing to when he was in LS, very shy, insecure though he was very obedient and disciplined.