元朗萊恩vs青衣學之園

qqyiu

你地會點揀???

sammisammylau

回復 Marco2010 的帖子

Hi.marco.可以pm 我元朗返york 資料嗎?thanks.........

lovebb2

原帖由 hhying 於 13-01-11 發表
其實我有小小唔明點解大家會認為無Net班主任就代表英文唔好，唔值，就算St Cat k2 开始都無Net班主任，但無 ...

同意。補充：我參加過親子王趙榮德的堂。他講過讀幼稚園的小朋友太細，尊注力有限，搭車唔可以太耐，否則小朋友很倦，上堂唔留心。信與不信，家長自己選擇。

chacolmom

feel very touched just by reading all the threads  

we live in YL too, and gave up on long distance travel and branded schools for my 2.5yo girl since the beginning, only considering local schools.

the reason is that i (yes, myself) travelled a lot when i was young.  my parents didn't put me to branded school, but just to the district close to where they work so that they can take care of me (i have 2 younger bro needed lots of the maid's attentions at home already).  

and now i am a mom myself, i will try my best not to put so much travelling time for my children.  UNLESS the time is worthwhile, such as able to sleep well, chat time with mom, learn the environment around us, observe people..etc.  NOT playing on the smartphone or handheld games.  if i knew i cannot commit to spending valuable travel time with my daughter, i wont consider putting her thru the travel.

for english ability, the living environment matters a lot more than the short 3 hours in school.  we hire philipino maid for this reason too.  her accent was one of our considerations when choosing one.  we only speak english at home until my daughter goes to a local PN, and now my daughter is fluent in both cantonese and english.   

Marco2010

hhying 發表於 13-1-11 21:52
Marco,

Please accept my apologies if I sounded too aggressive. I just wanted to share

Hhying, don't worry. We are just sharing our experiences to others.We are eager to help others parent, no need to say apologies.

For a 2 yrs kid to travel so long really not that easy, especially during the peak hrs around 8.
Therefore I highly recommend her not to take mtr.
Kids is first priority, if can overcome this problem.
Then we can consider the course structure and teacher qualification.

I also totally agree you had make the right choice for yr daughter.

My son always wake before 7:00am.
As long as he sleep enough, he will never yelling on the travel.
Also it provide a good time for me talk and teach him during travel.

Sorriso

原帖由 hhying 於 13-01-12 發表
Not sure for LH... for st. Cat, parents are notified with things that are taught in school every wee ...

萊恩真係透明度低的，亦因為佢冇學劵，更加唔知佢點，但由以前有學劵時既視學報告睇，真係令人擔心…但作為同一機構，我唔知york係咪咁

hhying

Not sure for LH... for st. Cat, parents are notified with things that are taught in school every week! Maybe you should check with current parents fron LH...

qqyiu

其實我小朋友現讀萊恩pn(加洲),學校老師有愛心,但我覺得透明度底,唔係太知小朋友每日做咩(我無讀過其它學校,可能其他都係咁)

Sorriso

原帖由 hhying 於 13-01-11 發表
Sorry... I keep pressing the wrong button.

Kids are sometimes too young to express themselves in wo ...

多謝你既分享!!!令人反思，其實我真的介意萊恩冇左net做班主任，但如果英文方面沒大影響，我還是會接受

hhying

... from that of York. Just be fair..

Education is important but do put into considerations traveling time and other issues rather than only focusing on how good a school's English is.

hhying

Sorry... I keep pressing the wrong button.

Kids are sometimes too young to express themselves in words.

St. Cat and HKPS have always been my first priority(even for now). I almost cried when my daughter got the offer. However, I was too naive to have thought that distance is nothing. There are many things which are more important than English and brandnames.

As per St. Lorraine's English, I know for certain that it's not as bad as what you ve told us. I am unable to compare it with the standard of LH but its not far from that York

hhying

Sorry... I pressed the wrong button. I just wanted to share my experience as my daughter has attended St. Cat since Aug last year. It is definitely a good school. However, I do know some graduates who don't speak good English. That is one of the reasons why I said that a good school doesn't mean everything. It's always about how much effort parents are putting in a child's education.
Be frank, I know very little about kindergartens. I just want to share the feelings my daughter has expressed concerning travelling long hours to and from school every day. Everyone has different values and perspectives. To me, rest is one important aspect in young kids' daily life. It also affects their efficiency in learning. Sometimes we mainly focus on how good a school is without putting our kids' health and emotions into consideration. Kids are sometimes too y

Sorriso

原帖由 Marco2010 於 13-01-11 發表
如果返上午，得兩個鐘，邊夠小朋友學野。小朋友排洗都用左半個鐘啦。
最大分別佢有多元智能班而元朗無，不 ...

佢返三小時的，二小時既係playgroup。我覺得總校既師資應該比萊恩好吧

hhying

Marco,

Please accept my apologies if I sounded too aggressive. I just wanted to share

Marco2010

Sorriso 發表於 13-1-11 19:06
如果咁講，好似york值啲了

如果返上午，得兩個鐘，邊夠小朋友學野。小朋友排洗都用左半個鐘啦。
最大分別佢有多元智能班而元朗無，不過唔係人人都加雞精班，而且學費就昇到8K，加上校車就1皮
自己計下數cost VS benefit啦

Sorriso

原帖由 Marco2010 於 13-01-11 發表
本帖最後由 Marco2010 於 13-1-11 17:56 編輯

如果咁講，好似york值啲了

Marco2010

晞晞爸b 發表於 13-1-11 16:41
謝謝
我想問:
1.元朗經唔經錦田既?

當吹下水，想問下點解要長途跋涉去讀Zenith?課程一樣，師資都係抽其他分校去如之前YL Mr.
Sigh等，但學費就貴D?
不過真係抽左好D老師去ge

Marco2010

hhying 發表於 13-1-11 16:34
其實我有小小唔明點解大家會認為無Net班主任就代表英文唔好，唔值，就算St Cat k2 开始都無Net班主任，但無 ...

妳講得對無Net班主任就代表英文唔好, 相反有NET如果教得唔好一樣無用.

不過我自己禁樣睇這件事, 假設本地及NET都教英文得OK, 兩者英文學術好, 如果同等學費, NET口語/口音一定比LOCAL好.是否小朋友更有效益. (PS 一口流利英文不等於英文好)
LOCAL老師有部份都未有大學畢業, 而且宜家本地大學英文水平之高, 如果中五或中七去考左CE教幼稚園, 情況是否更加擔心? 查一下ST LOR老師擁有學位的比例看一下.
如果只是教單字, 我就覺得兩者分別不大, 係2歲班係可以接受, 但如果K1-K3三年都係禁,比較危險D啦.

英語是須要浸淫係良好語境中,慢慢成長. 如果單獨NET教PHONICS係唔夠LAW.
如果係日常生活中/學校生活中多些機會接觸, 英文水平一定進步較快.

老師無得比我地INTERVIEW, 而小朋友返學又無得視學, 其實好多未知因素.
所以妳講得對無Net班主任就代表英文唔好係絕對CORRECT, 不過我自己會以或然率PROPOBABILITY去做決定.
誰會有較高機會教得好D呢去作決定.
ST CAT K1已經開始教完整句子, 有個小朋友係LH轉去讀跟唔到進度, 老師建議小朋友補習.
個人意見: 而且ST LOR兩個男性NET TEACHER比我感受唔到有教學及喜歡小朋友PASSION! 另外普通話老師是否國家一級教師?


萊茵係YL區都是一間不錯學校, 上年都有畢業生入了英華/陳守仁等.
妳為阿女選擇一定係對的,因為只有妳知道不同學校對她有什麼PROS AND CONS.
正如之前所講, 以小朋友行先, 佢都唔起唔到身/唔想返學, 比間哈囉去讀都無用, 事倍功半.
無一間學校係PERFECT, 父母只會為自己仔女選擇最好的, 不會有錯與對之分!!!!!

晞晞爸b

Marco2010 發表於 13-1-10 21:30
校車是張太，有需要pm我但注意大約七點半要上車

謝謝
我想問:
1.元朗經唔經錦田既?
2.可否只搭下午(上午我自己車仔仔出九龍)
3.可否不是York? 我意思係如果我仔仔係讀英藝九龍塘..會否兜埋?  (我仲考慮緊明年俾小朋友返英藝或者York...)

LL222

Sorriso 發表於 13-1-10 18:08
有$2100/月

今年加到$2300/月啦