如果比大家返轉頭揀SC vs MS ?

LWL1212

請教各位：SC vs MS 對升小好啲！
TArget : CKY / SPCC

boryi

karen55407 發表於 12-12-13 16:42
我依然揀SC

i am 100% agree with you!!! SC is a really good kindergarten with high reputation among primary schools!!

karen55407

我依然揀SC

boryi

回復 dwkw333 的帖子

I think its means Braemar Hill Kindergarten

dwkw333

原帖由 rai_fc 於 12-12-13 發表
回復 kwansara 的帖子

Total 89 offers (but may have double count as some students may be offers from ...

BH =? Thanks.

rai_fc

回復 kwansara 的帖子

Total 89 offers (but may have double count as some students may be offers from 2 out of these three schools)  from these three schools have gaven offers to St Cat students (total 700 +), so the successful is around 12.7%.  Then my guess is around 10% would not be too far off.  This ratio should be high vs. other schools (except CCKG or BH).  

kwansara

我有另一個諗法, 係咪應該比較各名小如 SPCC, DGS, DBS....etc, 收生總數中佔幾多係St Cat 學生 ?

假設另一間幼稚園有學生100人, 5人考入SPCC = 5%... 但其實SPCC 收生200, 當中只佔2.5%.... 相對St Cat 有30人考入, 就佔SPCC收生總數的15%,  可能依個ratio 有參考性d

ps. 數字只係假設

boryi

回復 tikma 的帖子

of course! assume if ALL K3 students applied SPCC, DGS and DBS! (which i think its impossible!) therefore the admission rate for SC students getting into these schools are AT LEAST:
SPCC rate 29/600 = 5%, DGS, 30/300 girls = 10%, DBS, 30/300 = 10%. i think its quite good figure, you cant compare the percentage rate with CCKG.

dwkw333

原帖由 picture 於 12-12-13 發表
2x successful students out of.how many graduates?

~7xx K3 graduates .

picture

原帖由 蓮蓉包 於 12-12-12 發表
本帖最後由 蓮蓉包 於 12-12-12 16:14 編輯

just curious..CKY & SPCC are two very very different sch ...

exactly the question i.have

picture

原帖由 dwkw333 於 12-12-11 發表
補充:2010-11 SC K3 大約有2x人考到SPCC 。

2x successful students out of.how many graduates?

catyoyo

回復 tikma 的帖子

的是的,、還有學校當年的收生人數。但還有幼稚園報考該小學的人數,一切只能作參考。

tikma

回復 boryi 的帖子

純睇幾多人入左冇乜意思，相信要用埋上年縂畢業生人數去比較！

boryi

回復 dwkw333 的帖子

yes! SC students got 29 offers from SPCC, around 30 from DGS, around 32 from DBS for that year!!!

boryi

回復 boryi 的帖子

thanks! of course SC!!!!!!

蓮蓉包

just curious..CKY & SPCC are two very very different school (i work in SPCC before)...
are you choosing these school by their fame? or have you considered if it is suitable for your child?

LWL1212

呢兩間我都無報丫

Jack0128

我會選嶺南或聖公會

dwkw333

原帖由 dwkw333 於 12-12-11 發表
本帖最後由 dwkw333 於 12-12-11 23:49 編輯

如果 target SPCC, SC and MS would not the best choice.. ...

補充:2010-11 SC K3 大約有2x人考到SPCC 。

boryi

SC is St Catherine, then what is MS?