公文式中文

陰公之人

我小朋友4歲(下個月升K2), 剛開始讀公文式中文, 但每次上堂要聽大約5分鐘CD, 跟住老師會教小朋友聲母發音等, 然後俾功課, 每日在家聽CD.

有無人知道究竟有無成效呢? 會幾時先教認字,寫字呀? 因有些擔心, 什麼也學唔成........

如轉1對1學普通話會否好D呢? 加學記憶課程的中文, 會否好D呢? 因怕到面試小一時, 什麼也不懂回答.......

有無家長可俾一些意見呢?

謝謝!

tina2007

一個月幾多錢????

symfen

我之前由k1開始教個小朋友中英文，，會由故事同遊戲開始，教到依家k3，小朋友唔抗拒，仲會成日表達意見:) 無論英文定中文都講:D 不過我發現好多小朋友如果有家長喺附近，會比較少表達，可能驚爸爸媽媽話xd

kungkungjireh

very good feedback from my niece. high recommend.

jojoplanet

hing7 發表於 12-10-2 16:28
當然搵個普通話老師一對一係最好啦, 但係洗既錢亦都係最貴WOR.. 我自問屋企既生活質素都唔差, 但都未至於 ...

係呀我都覺得係經濟實惠！
阿仔學左十個月而家升小一我覺得佢中文跟得比我想象中好！我覺得係公文中文既成果！

Shirley3

My son doesn't like Kumon at all..  He cries whenever he is listening the CD..

jojoplanet

hkparent 發表於 12-9-20 13:23
But other classes or tutorials are only 1 or 2 times per week.  The kid can't learn any PTH on the d ...

岩..我個仔之前都係PLAYGROUP形式上普通話, 但一星期一堂佢真係唔記得, 上咗公文日日聽好咗好多, 講的確係唔夠既, 再可以有普通話老師同佢一對一講就PERFECT.

hkparent

If the PTH teacher's fee is very low say $100/hour, 0.5 hour/day x 30 days = $1500/month.  But can the teacher come for 0.5 hour every day to earn just $50?

hkparent

But other classes or tutorials are only 1 or 2 times per week.  The kid can't learn any PTH on the days without lessons. The ideal learning is: using Kumon material but with native PTH teacher speaking with the kid every day, 7 days a week.  If it's too expensive, then Kumon material + CD is a good choice.

bbforever

• kumon 中文要聽cd 外在課堂上都要朗讀句子(pth)，小朋友從中係會認埋字，老師係會教他們锐pth，重有埋pth 拼O

  ---