St. Cat PN 下午班或劍鳴PN上午班

Oceanpapa

新手爸爸不知如何為兒子選擇，可否給意見？

AL1987

Pls make a decision and release 1 seat, many people are waiting for the PN in these 2 schools.

bb8608

回復 yingval 的帖子

They will let us know in Nov.
They have given us a deadline date of 31 May to let us know whether they will offer us K1 or not, however they never reply, even we call & ask.

manmanchubb

回復 homepridealice 的帖子

倒不如話,
想入喇沙的或OLD boy ,
會因為對教學上既要求或希望易於銜接傳統小學而比小孩讀KM

mammyleung

你好！我考慮為我家1歲半小男孩報考這兩間n class。 想大家比點意見那間學習模式較適合，謝！
小朋友較活潑，喜歡跑跑跳跳，求知欲好強，上playgroup 時如對物件有興趣，會出位，亦喜歡集體活動，不害羞，但自我中心強，喜歡人讚和認同。

yingval

bb8608 發表於 12-6-22 09:47
This year not the same case. Many of us put on the waiting list never got an answer. They rather tak ...

So, can you advise when (which month) the parent know their children can go straight to K1 from PN?

homepridealice

bumblebee_wong 發表於 12-6-21 21:42
甘KM創辦人係咪LS 前校監？

有關劍鳴的創辦人, 早年港台節目家家有教有介紹過:
前校監: 創辦人陳仲勉校監兼校董，於喇沙小學服務40年，曾任下午校校長21年, 而現時校監就是陳仲勉的太太陳嚴黛莉(Mrs Helena Chan)，為瑪利諾修院學校小學部英文科主任服務36年。

不過, 相信只是因為這背景加上劍鳴畢業生都有不少讀喇沙, 所以有此感覺吧.

bb8608

This year not the same case. Many of us put on the waiting list never got an answer. They rather take outsiders even there are seats release from existing PN kids!!

elmolly

around 80% for the 1st round, eventually, 99%

Oceanpapa

Thanks for all the advices.  Seems that

KM:
- 多點關懷
- 不用轉換作息時間
- 看似與喇沙有點關係（非官方推測）
- 但最令人擔心就是不保證上K1

SC:
- 名氣較佳（對小一面試有否幫助？）
- 保證上K1
- 聼說學生英文水平很高，學生表達能力佳

If so, my biggest concern is that KM does not guanrantee the child can go to K1.  Does anyone know that the percentage of KM students that can go up from PN to K1?

Thanks!  

bumblebee_wong

甘KM創辦人係咪LS 前校監？

bumblebee_wong

哦！

小曳人

bumblebee_wong 發表於 12-6-21 19:56
有人話喇沙好鐘意收KM畢業生！

應該唔關事
LS跟本無收生權去揀人，而叩門位亦係有人事先有機會！

但倒轉講：大機會讀LS嘅小朋友，家長鍾意揀KM就差唔多

bumblebee_wong

有人話喇沙好鐘意收KM畢業生！

kerkermui

peko5 發表於 12-6-21 11:40
KM better than St. C?

I would say..  KM can fit my boy better than SC.
but it's not essentially = KM is better than SC.

Parents, something which is good for my kid, doesn't mean it's good for your kid too.  Just list down what do you want.. and see which school may better fit your loved one.

and most importantly, both are good schools.

JC_mami

我個人喜歡劍嗚多點，因為小朋友得二歲多，好似細校會照顧得比較好。
而且上午校作息時間和課外活動的安排比較容易。

elytis

回復 kufubaby 的帖子

y km is so good??

kufubaby

if location not a problem, personally i like KM