學校課外活動學了樂器，還要在外面請私人老師嗎？

Karlhui

回復 ohmygosh 的帖子

其實真係玩樂團真係開心好多,仲記得細個時成日覺得人地一大班人咁玩大大首既symphony真係幾型.自己彈琴最多咪係幫人伴奏為主, collaborative 既又唔多, 最刺激都係玩下franck violin sonata, concerto又未夠班去彈....唉. 真係有D jealous.....

ohmygosh

回復 miss321 的帖子

學習樂器技巧上﹐當然是個別上課為佳。但同時﹐我都鼓勵學生積極參加學校/校外的樂團/合唱團﹐以得到更全面和多元化的音樂教育和發展。

三文魚154

回復 eadonon 的帖子

Hi eadaonon, 你有無搵私人老師呀？
我個仔搵左個老師上左一個月，我覺得個老師好有說服力同好有心機教，阿仔之前吹嚟吹去都系鬼咁多風聲，又無氣，吹唔到一個樂句，而家個老師同佢解釋左點解吹長笛會產生風聲，點樣做可以減少風聲，又教佢點樣可以吹得長氣d。阿仔明左個道理，上左4堂就大有改善，我真系好開心。駛唔駛介紹俾你？

bb86

clarawuwu 發表於 12-5-30 10:45
YES.
我小朋友除了要返學校的中樂團之外,自己仲要搵老師一對一訓練.

my daughter also

clarawuwu

miss321 發表於 12-5-29 19:44
如果係樂團樂器, 我認為上私人課同大班上都有必要。

YES.
我小朋友除了要返學校的中樂團之外,自己仲要搵老師一對一訓練.

miss321

如果係樂團樂器, 我認為上私人課同大班上都有必要。

ohmygosh

回復 clarawuwu 的帖子

Absolutely!!!

clarawuwu

學音樂真係一對一最好.

gabriela0407

咁音統呢?我都煩緊仲比唔比佢學. 佢在音統已4年, 個老師唔係唔得, 不過硬係爭DD 咁, 成日好似聽唔到佢要拉晒成首歌. 跟住又轉新歌啦.

Chowying

小伊 發表於 12-5-26 22:13
沒法，在學校裏，包括音樂科的老和校長，又有多少個懂得和尊重音樂？



  ...

上次家長會, 安排左d學生輪流表演樂器, 有個小二吹flute, 初初聽點解d音色吹得麻麻, 聽聽吓先記得小妹妹只有小二, 吹成咁已經好唔錯, 我feel到個校長好鐘意曬學生識d咩, 所以我好怕join左學校d樂器班, 會個底無學好, 剩係掛住練d咩嘢show比家長睇. 其實我同c6小時都學過小提琴, 我返到屋企重同老公講, 都冇學到幾年琴, 點夾管絃樂團呢

tws2010

回復 ohmygosh 的帖子

My kid join the violin class at school for less than a year.  So far, he is doing quite good and the rest of the students in his group are also doing good.  The teacher is very good.  As parent, I can sit in the class.   My kid knows how to 睇譜, except for the first two songs, my kid does not have to write the 手指位, so do his classmates.  They are all in P.2. The teacher is also with a heart.  She also teaches the musical knowledge.  I don't think joining the classes at school is useless, depends on how quality of the teacher and students.

杰杰媽媽

真係有心學樂器真係千祈唔好係學校一班咁學,成班人咁學只係玩票性質,完全學唔到野,P1時我仔就係咁SIDE左大半年時間,學左成年都仲係唔識睇譜,真係好離譜.

好彩我都發覺得早,有朋友個老師係直資小學到教,又肯收出面學生,又好人,就咁就跟左呢個老師5年啦

小伊

沒法，在學校裏，包括音樂科的老和校長，又有多少個懂得和尊重音樂？

Chowying

ohmygosh 發表於 12-5-25 21:29
回復 Chowying 的帖子

有感而發﹐分享一下﹕由英國畢業回港那年﹐有朋友邀請我去教小學裡面的小提琴班。我 ...

乜原來咁劣, 好彩無join到, 多謝分享.

cpcog

I also feel most students can't learn much from the school instrumental courses. :(
Perhaps the schools would focus training the higher forms students as they can perform in front of the parents. For the lower forms.. just for fun??? My daughter can't really learn much from the school percussion course. Not pleased!!
I was in- charge for percussion courses when I was a school teacher. That teacher was much more professional. So I guess it is more depend on the teacher?!

ohmygosh

回復 Chowying 的帖子

有感而發﹐分享一下﹕由英國畢業回港那年﹐有朋友邀請我去教小學裡面的小提琴班。我見間學校0係正我家對面﹐算係區內名校﹐學生聰明聽話﹐負責人又安排到起碼三班比我﹐全部中班﹐0甘我覺得應該都okay掛。點知去到﹐話就話係中班﹐但d學生學左1-3年﹐都仲係吾識得讀譜﹐之前上初班竟然一直都在樂譜上寫滿fingering (G0, A2, D1, etc.)﹐姿勢和技巧各樣都吾得﹐仲要一對六﹐一對八0甘﹐根本就教吾到﹐教吾好﹔跟得到的幾個學生﹐全部都係外面有跟私人學。我同負責人反映﹐對方不以為然﹐仲反過來叫我最緊要管掂班學生﹐等校長行過見到他們拉琴﹐有d琴聲之類﹐0甘就得喇。我真係接受吾到lor﹐完全無滿足感可言﹐只係消耗時間﹐所以教左一個學期就quit了。